Linguistic evolution driven by network heterogeneity and the Turing mechanism

Sayat Mimar,Mariamo Mussa Juane,Jorge Mira,Juyong Park,Alberto P. Munuzuri,Gourab Ghoshal

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevResearch.3.023241

2020-06-05

Abstract:Given the rapidly evolving landscape of linguistic prevalence, whereby a majority of the world's existing languages are dying out in favor of the adoption of a comparatively fewer set of languages, the factors behind this phenomenon has been the subject of vigorous research. The majority of approaches investigate the temporal evolution of two competing languages in the form of differential equations describing their behavior at large scale. In contrast, relatively few consider the spatial dimension of the problem. Furthermore while much attention has focused on the phenomena of language shift---the adoption of majority languages in lieu of minority ones---relatively less light has been shed on linguistic coexistence, where two or more languages persist in a geographically contiguous region. Here, we study the geographical component of language spread on a discrete medium to monitor the dispersal of language species at a microscopic level. Language dynamics is modeled through a reaction-diffusion system that occurs on a heterogeneous network of contacts based on population flows between urban centers. We show that our framework accurately reproduces empirical linguistic trends driven by a combination of the Turing instability, a mechanism for spontaneous pattern-formation applicable to many natural systems, the heterogeneity of the contact network, and the asymmetries in how people perceive the status of a language. We demonstrate the robustness of our formulation on two datasets corresponding to linguistic coexistence in northern Spain and southern Austria.

Physics and Society,Adaptation and Self-Organizing Systems

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **How to explain and predict the spread and co - existence of languages in geospatial areas, especially the dynamic changes of languages under the influence of heterogeneous network structures and Turing mechanisms**.

### Specific problem descriptions:

1. **Language extinction and co - existence**:
- Existing research shows that most languages in the world are gradually disappearing, and a few major languages are gradually becoming dominant. However, in some regions, two or more languages can co - exist in the same geographical area.
- Although traditional models such as the Abrams - Strogatz (AS) model can well explain the phenomenon of language extinction, they have limitations in explaining language co - existence.

2. **Combination of time - space dimensions**:
- Most studies focus on the macro - time scale of language evolution and ignore the influence of its spatial dimension.
- The spatial dimension is crucial for understanding the distribution and interaction of languages in different regions, especially in geographically discontinuous regions.

3. **The influence of human mobility**:
- Previous models usually ignored the influence of human mobility on language spread and competition. Human mobility is an important part of the socio - economic system and has an important impact on the dynamic changes of languages.

### Main contributions of the paper:

- **Introducing a heterogeneous network model**: By discretizing the geospatial area into nodes (towns) and edges (population flows), and combining the Turing mechanism to simulate the competition and diffusion processes of languages.
- **Considering Turing instability**: Using the Turing mechanism to explain the pattern formation of languages on the geographical network, revealing the complexity of language co - existence and distribution.
- **Combining language status perception**: Introducing the language status parameter \( c \), considering people's cognitive differences in the status of different languages, so as to more accurately simulate the dynamic changes of languages.

### Conclusion:

This paper successfully explains the spread and co - existence of languages in geospatial areas by constructing a reaction - diffusion model that combines heterogeneous network structures and Turing mechanisms, and verifies the applicability of the model in Galicia in Spain and Carinthia in southern Austria. This provides a new perspective and method for further understanding the dynamic changes of languages.

### Key formulas:

1. **Reaction - diffusion equations**:
\[
\frac{du_i}{dt}=cu_iv_i + u_i(1 - u_i)+\sum_{j = 1}^N L_{ij}[(d_u + a_{uv}v_j)u_j]
\]
\[
\frac{dv_i}{dt}=-cu_iv_i + v_i(1 - v_i)+\sum_{j = 1}^N L_{ij}[(d_v + a_{vu}u_j)v_j]
\]
where \( u_i \) and \( v_i \) respectively represent the proportion of the population speaking two languages at the \( i \)-th node, \( c \) represents the language status parameter, \( d_u, d_v \) are diffusion coefficients, \( a_{uv}, a_{vu} \) are cross - diffusion coefficients, and \( L_{ij} \) is an element of the Laplacian matrix.

2. **Turing instability condition**:
\[
\lambda^2_\alpha + b(\Lambda_\alpha)\lambda_\alpha + c(\Lambda_\alpha)=0
\]
where \( \lambda_\alpha \) is the growth rate of each mode, and \( b(\Lambda_\alpha), c(\Lambda_\alpha) \) are functions related to diffusion coefficients, competition terms and status parameters.

Through these formulas and models, the paper shows how to combine the geographical network structure and the Turing mechanism to better understand the dynamic changes of languages.