Abstract:The largest anthropogenic emissions of carbon dioxide (CO 2 ) come from local sources such as cities and power plants. The upcoming Copernicus CO 2 Monitoring Mission (CO2M) will provide satellite images of the CO 2 and NO 2 plumes associated with these sources at a resolution of 2 km × 2 km and with a swath of 250 km. These images could be exploited with atmospheric plume inversion methods to estimate local CO 2 emissions at the time of the satellite overpass and the corresponding uncertainties. To support the development of the operational processing of satellite column-average XCO 2 and NO 2 imagery, this study evaluates "data-driven inversion methods", i.e., computationally light inversion methods that directly process information from satellite images, local winds and meteorological data, without resorting to computationally expensive dynamical atmospheric transport models. We have designed an objective benchmarking exercise to analyse and compare the performance of five different data-driven inversion methods: two implementations with different complexity for the cross-sectional flux approach (CSF and LCSF) and one implementation for the Integrated Mass Enhancement (IME), the Divergence (Div) and the Gaussian Plume model inversion (GP) approaches. This exercise is based on pseudo-data experiments with simulations of synthetic "true" emissions, meteorological and concentration fields, and CO2M observations in a domain of 750 km × 650 km centred on Eastern Germany over 1-year. The performance of the methods is quantified in terms of accuracy in the single-image (from individual images) or annual average (from the full series of images) emission estimates and in terms of number of instant estimates for the city of Berlin and 15 power plants in this domain. Several ensembles of estimations are conducted, using different scenarios for the available synthetic datasets. These ensembles are used to analyse the sensitivity of the performance to the loss of data due to cloud cover, to the uncertainty in the wind or to the added value of simultaneous NO 2 images. The GP and the LCSF methods generate the most accurate estimates from individual images with similar Interquartile Ranges (IQR) in the deviations between the emission estimates and the true emissions between ~20 % and ~60 % for all scenarios. When taking the cloud cover into account, these methods produce respectively 274 and 318 instant estimates from the ~500 daily images that cover significant portions of the plumes from the sources. Filtering the results based on the associated uncertainty estimates can improve the statistics of the IME and CSF methods, but at the cost of a large decrease in the number of estimates. Due to a reliable estimation of uncertainty and thus a suitable selection of estimates, the CSF method achieves similar if not better statistics of accuracy for instant estimates compared to the GP and LCSF methods after filtering. In general, the performances for retrieving single-image estimates are improved when, in addition to XCO 2 data, collocated NO 2 data are used to characterise the structure of plumes. With respect to the estimates of annual emissions, the root mean square errors (RMSE) are for the most realistic benchmarking scenario 20 % (GP), 27 % (CSF), 31 % (LCSF), 55 % (IME) and 79 % (Div). This study suggests that the Gaussian plume and/or the cross-sectional approaches are currently the most efficient tools to provide estimates of CO 2 emissions from satellite images and their relatively light computational cost will enable analysis of the massive amount of data provided by future missions of satellite XCO 2 imagery.

Estimating volcanic ash emissions using retrieved satellite ash columns and inverse ash transport modelling

Estimating volcanic ash emissions using retrieved satellite ash columns and inverse ash transport modeling using VolcanicAshInversion v1.2.1, within the operational eEMEP (emergency European Monitoring and Evaluation Programme) volcanic plume forecasting system (version rv4_17)

An inverse method to estimate emission rates based on nonlinear least-squares-based ensemble four-dimensional variational data assimilation with local air concentration measurements

Using Simulated Radiances to Understand the Limitations of Satellite‐Retrieved Volcanic Ash Data and the Implications for Volcanic Ash Cloud Forecasting

Retrieval of Volcanic Ash Parameters from Satellite Data

A New Algorithm for the Retrieval of Volcanic Ash Cloud Properties using MSG-SEVIRI and Artificial Neural Networks

A Local to National-Scale Inverse Modeling System to Assess the Potential of Spaceborne CO2 Measurements for the Monitoring of Anthropogenic Emissions

4D-Var Inversion of European NH3 Emissions Using CrIS NH3 Measurements and GEOS-Chem Adjoint With Bi-Directional and Uni-Directional Flux Schemes

Benchmarking data-driven inversion methods for the estimation of local CO2 emissions from XCO2 and NO2 satellite images

Stratospheric aerosol source inversion: Noise, variability, and uncertainty quantification

Assessing the Iterative Finite Difference Mass Balance and 4d‐var Methods to Derive Ammonia Emissions over North America Using Synthetic Observations

Is the efficacy of satellite-based inversion of SO 2 emission model dependent?

Estimation of Observation Errors for Large-Scale Atmospheric Inversion of CO2 Emissions from Fossil Fuel Combustion

High spatial and temporal resolution simulations of methane column loadings due to routine emissions and emission events in oil and gas regions

A Method for Estimating the Background Column Concentration of CO 2 Using the Lagrangian Approach

Global Estimates of CO Sources with High Resolution by Adjoint Inversion of Multiple Satellite Datasets (MOPITT, AIRS, SCIAMACHY, TES)

High-resolution Hybrid Inversion of IASI Ammonia Columns to Constrain US Ammonia Emissions Using the CMAQ Adjoint Model

Impact of the Atmospheric Sink and Vertical Mixing on Nitrous Oxide Fluxes Estimated Using Inversion Methods

Verifying national inventory-based combustion emissions of CO2 across the UK and mainland Europe using satellite observations of atmospheric CO and CO2

The use of satellite and ground based measurements for estimating and reducing uncertainties in the spatial distribution of emissions of nitrogen oxides

Inferring CO2 sources and sinks from satellite observations: Method and application to TOVS data