Optimal topological generators of $U(1)$

Zachary Stier
DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2002.03092
2020-02-08
Abstract:Sarnak's golden mean conjecture states that $(m+1)d_\varphi(m)\le1+\frac{2}{\sqrt{5}}$ for all integers $m\ge1$, where $\varphi$ is the golden mean and $d_\theta$ is the discrepancy function for $m+1$ multiples of $\theta$ modulo 1. In this paper, we characterize the set $\mathcal{S}$ of values $\theta$ that share this property, as well as the set $\mathcal{T}$ of those with the property for some lower bound $m\ge M$. Remarkably, $\mathcal{S}\text{ mod }1$ has only 16 elements, whereas $\mathcal{T}$ is the set of $GL_2(\mathbb{Z})$-transformations of $\varphi$.
Number Theory
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The core problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the characteristics of the optimal topological generators of the unit circle group \(U(1)\), especially the generators related to the golden ratio \(\phi\). Specifically, the paper explores the following issues: 1. **Sarnak's Golden Mean Conjecture**: For all integers \(m \geq 1\), does the inequality \((m + 1)d_{\theta}(m)\leq1 + 2\sqrt{5}\) hold, where \(\phi\) is the golden ratio and \(d_{\theta}\) is the discrete function of \(m + 1\) multiples of \(\theta\) modulo 1. 2. **Characteristics of Optimal Generators**: Which angles \(\theta\) can be the optimal generators of \(U(1)\), and what are the specific properties of these generators? In particular, those angles such that \((m + 1)d_{\theta}(m)\) is less than or equal to \(1+ 2\sqrt{5}\) for all \(m\). 3. **Characterization of Sets \(S\) and \(T\)**: The set \(S\) contains all angles \(\theta\) for which the above inequality holds, and the set \(T\) contains those angles that satisfy the inequality for some lower bound \(m\geq M\). The paper proves that there are only 16 elements in \(S\) modulo 1, and \(T\) is all angles obtained by transforming \(\phi\) through \(GL_{2}(\mathbb{Z})\). 4. **Global Optimization Problem**: The problem of optimal generators in the global scope is studied, that is, for any given \(M\), which angles \(\theta\) can minimize the maximum value of \((m + 1)d_{\theta}(m)\). ### Main Conclusions - **Theorem 1**: The angle \(\theta\) satisfies \((m + 1)d_{\theta}(m)<1 + 2\sqrt{5}\) for all \(m\geq M\) if and only if \(\theta\) is equivalent to \(\phi\) (represented by continued fractions). - **Theorem 2**: There are exactly 16 angles \(\theta\) modulo 1 such that \(D(\theta)=1 + 2\sqrt{5}\), and these angles are given in Figure 1. - **Theorem 3**: For each \(\theta_{0}\in S\), there are infinitely many \(M\) such that \(\theta_{0}\) is \(\argmin_{\theta\in S}D_{M}(\theta)\). These results not only deepen the understanding of the generators of \(U(1)\), but also reveal the special status of the golden ratio in this problem.