Abstract:Analysis of combined deployments of GPS loggers with cameras or temperature–depth recorders reveals that despite experiencing intraspecific competition for food, northern gannets engage in dynamic, context‐dependent social associations while foraging. Foraging aggregations far from the colony may be beneficial as a source of local enhancement, which may impact foraging profitability and increase access to echelon groups to facilitate colony return. Our results therefore illustrate how competition may, paradoxically, facilitate some aspects of group foraging in colonial animals. Coloniality is strongly shaped by aspects of social foraging behaviour. For example, colonies may be important sources of information, while food competition may increase foraging efforts and limit colony size. Understanding foraging ecology considering these apparent trade‐offs is required to develop a better understanding of colonial living. We combined animal‐borne GPS, cameras and dive recorders to study social foraging in breeding adult northern gannets Morus bassanus—a wide‐ranging colonial seabird. We first tested for indirect evidence of prey depletion around the colony by estimating dive location, depth and duration. Next, we tested for sociality during different behaviours (commuting, foraging and resting) and distance from the colony. Finally, we quantified flocks of inbound and outbound birds to compare social foraging between outbound and inbound legs of the commute. Dive probability and depth (n = 46 individuals; n = 1590 dives) increased with distance from the colony, creating dive clusters at ~100 and 180 km consistent with conspecific prey depletion. Camera stills (n = 8 individuals; n = 7495 images) show gannets are highly social, but this varied among behaviours. Sociality was highest during foraging and commuting; especially inbound and social foraging was more likely far from the colony. Gannets were equally likely to be solitary or social when leaving the colony but returning birds were more likely in larger flocks. In summary, despite experiencing intraspecific competition for food, gannets engage in dynamic, context‐dependent social foraging associations. Conspecifics aggregated far from the colony possibly because of a prey depletion halo closer to home, but this provided potential benefits via local enhancement and by returning to the colony in flocks. Our results therefore illustrate how competition may, paradoxically, facilitate some aspects of group foraging in colonial animals.

Speed consensus and behavioural coordination of Adélie penguins travelling on sea ice in groups

Individual variation in migratory movements of chinstrap penguins leads to widespread occupancy of ice-free winter habitats over the continental shelf and deep ocean basins of the Southern Ocean

Using latent behavior analysis to identify key foraging areas for Adélie penguins in a declining colony in West Antarctic Peninsula

Spatial link between Adélie penguin foraging effort and krill swarm abundance and distribution

Horizontal-vertical movement relationships: Adélie penguins forage continuously throughout provisioning trips

Leaderless consensus decision-making determines cooperative transport direction in weaver ants

Hierarchical group dynamics in pigeon flocks

Proximity and preening in captive Humboldt penguins

Dynamical coupling during collective animal motion

Impact of Variable Speed on Collective Movement of Animal Groups

New Technologies Aid Understanding of the Factors Affecting Adélie Penguin Foraging

Compromise or choose: shared movement decisions in wild vulturine guineafowl

Huddling behavior in emperor penguins : dynamics of huddling

Identifying differences in the rules of interaction between individuals in moving animal groups

Imitation Combined with a Characteristic Stimulus Duration Results in Robust Collective Decision-making in Sheep

Competition and Facilitation Influence Central Place Foraging Ecology in a Colonial Marine Predator

Coordination and Synchronisation of Anti-Predation Vigilance in Two Crane Species

Modelling group dynamic animal movement

Pan-Antarctic analysis aggregating spatial estimates of Adélie penguin abundance reveals robust dynamics despite stochastic noise

Spatial modulation of individual behaviors enables collective decision-making during bacterial group migration

Straight line foraging in yellow-eyed penguins: new insights into cascading fisheries effects and orientation capabilities of marine predators