Channel Prediction for Underwater Acoustic Communication: A Review and Performance Evaluation of Algorithms

Haotian Liu,Lu Ma,Zhaohui Wang,Gang Qiao
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/rs16091546
IF: 5
2024-04-27
Remote Sensing
Abstract:Underwater acoustic (UWA) channel prediction technology, as an important topic in UWA communication, has played an important role in UWA adaptive communication network and underwater target perception. Although many significant advancements have been achieved in underwater acoustic channel prediction over the years, a comprehensive summary and introduction is still lacking. As the first comprehensive overview of UWA channel prediction, this paper introduces past works and algorithm implementation methods of channel prediction from the perspective of linear, kernel-based, and deep learning approaches. Importantly, based on available at-sea experiment datasets, this paper compares the performance of current primary UWA channel prediction algorithms under a unified system framework, providing researchers with a comprehensive and objective understanding of UWA channel prediction. Finally, it discusses the directions and challenges for future research. The survey finds that linear prediction algorithms are the most widely applied, and deep learning, as the most advanced type of algorithm, has moved this field into a new stage. The experimental results show that the linear algorithms have the lowest computational complexity, and when the training samples are sufficient, deep learning algorithms have the best prediction performance.
environmental sciences,imaging science & photographic technology,remote sensing,geosciences, multidisciplinary
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem this paper attempts to address is channel prediction technology in underwater acoustic communication. Specifically, the authors focus on how to predict the state of the underwater acoustic channel (UWA) through various algorithms to improve the performance of underwater communication systems. Underwater acoustic channels have complex characteristics, such as multipath transmission, frequency-selective fading, and limited bandwidth, which restrict the performance of underwater communication. Therefore, accurately predicting the channel state is crucial for implementing adaptive modulation techniques and improving the reliability of communication systems. ### Main Issues 1. **Complex Channel Characteristics**: The characteristics of multipath transmission, frequency-selective fading, and limited bandwidth in underwater acoustic channels make channel prediction very challenging. 2. **Time Variation**: The time-varying nature of underwater acoustic channels requires prediction algorithms to update channel state information in real-time or near real-time. 3. **Algorithm Performance Evaluation**: Existing research lacks comprehensive comparison and performance evaluation of different channel prediction algorithms, especially when evaluated on the same experimental dataset. ### Solutions 1. **Linear Algorithms**: Including Recursive Least Squares (RLS), Minimum Mean Square Error (MMSE), Exponential Smoothing (ES), and Kalman Filtering. These algorithms are simple and have good real-time performance but are limited in handling nonlinear problems. 2. **Kernel-based Methods**: Including Kernel Adaptive Filter (KAF) and Support Vector Regression (SVR). These methods achieve nonlinear fitting by mapping data to high-dimensional space, suitable for handling complex channel characteristics. 3. **Deep Learning Algorithms**: Utilizing deep neural networks (such as Convolutional Neural Networks CNN and Long Short-Term Memory Networks LSTM) for channel prediction. These algorithms show the best prediction performance when there are sufficient training samples but have high computational complexity. ### Contributions of the Paper 1. **Review and Classification**: This paper provides the first comprehensive review of underwater acoustic channel prediction technology, introducing the principles, implementation methods, and specific applications of various algorithms. 2. **Performance Evaluation**: Based on actual sea trial datasets, this paper compares the prediction performance and computational complexity of existing typical underwater acoustic channel prediction algorithms under a unified system framework, providing objective analysis results. 3. **Future Directions**: Discusses the existing challenges and potential future development directions in the field of underwater acoustic channel prediction. ### Experimental Results - **Linear Algorithms**: Lowest computational complexity, suitable for real-time or near real-time application scenarios. - **Deep Learning Algorithms**: Best prediction performance when there are sufficient training samples, but high computational complexity. - **Kernel-based Methods**: Excellent performance in handling nonlinear problems, between linear and deep learning algorithms. Through this research, the authors hope to provide researchers with a comprehensive and objective perspective to better understand and choose channel prediction algorithms suitable for specific application scenarios.