A psychological model of collective risk perceptions

Sergio Pirla
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1017/jdm.2024.9
2024-01-01
Judgment and decision making
Abstract:Abstract Decades of research seek to understand how people form perceptions of risk by modeling either individual-level psychological processes or broader social and organizational mechanisms. Yet, little formal theoretical work has focused on the interaction of these 2 sets of factors. In this paper, I contribute to closing this gap by modifying a psychologically rich individual model of probabilistic reasoning to account for the transmission and collective emergence of risk perceptions. Using data from 357 individuals, I present experimental evidence in support of my main building assumptions and demonstrate the empirical validity of my model. Incorporating these results into an agent-based setting, I simulate over 1.5 billion social interactions to analyze the emergence of risk perceptions within organizations under different information frictions (i.e., limits on the availability and precision of social information). My results show that by focusing on information quality (rather than availability), groups and organizations can more effectively boost the accuracy of their emergent risk perceptions. This work offers researchers a formal framework to analyze the relationship between psychological and organizational factors in shaping risk perceptions.
psychology, multidisciplinary
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is that in the process of risk perception formation, the interaction between individual psychological processes and social and organizational mechanisms has not been fully studied. Specifically, although a large number of studies have respectively explored how psychological processes at the individual level or broader social and organizational phenomena affect risk perception, few formal theoretical works have focused on the interaction between these two sets of factors. The author makes up for this deficiency by modifying a psychologically rich individual probability - reasoning model to explain the social dissemination and collective emergence of risk perception. The main purpose of the paper is to provide a framework for studying the interaction between psychological and social factors in shaping risk perception, especially how to improve the accuracy of risk perception in groups and organizations through the quality rather than the quantity of social information.