Ultra-Widefield and Early Treatment Diabetic Retinopathy Study 7-Field Grading of Diabetic Retinopathy
Lloyd Paul Aiello,Barbara Blodi,Xiaoyu Gao,Jennifer K Sun,Rose A Gubitosi-Klug,Neil H White,Dean Hainsworth,Gayle M Lorenzi,Ionut Bebu,DCCT/EDIC Research Group,T Adkins,Anita Agarwal,Lloyd P Aiello,James W Albers,Valerie Arends,Paul Arrigg,Xenia Averkiou,Robert B Avery,Robin Azevedo,Jye-Yu Backlund,N Bakshi,Anna P Bancroft,Anne Bantle,John Bantle,Andrew Barkmeier,Annette Barnie,M Barr,Rachel Bartholomew,Richard Beaser,Richard Bergenstal,Arti Bhan,Matthew Bott,Patti A Bourne,Barbara H Braffett,M Brent,Angela Brown,Alexander J Brucker,Mark R Burge,Jillian Bylsma,Charles Campbell,Anders Carlson,Jerry Cavallerano,Robert Cavicchi,R Chan,J E Chapin,Kathy Chu,Beth A Coonrod,Tina Costacou,Samuel Dagogo-Jack,Ron Danis,Arup Das,Robert Devenyi,Lisa Diminick,Marsha Driscoll,Sean Dunnigan,Paul Edwards,Malek El Muayed,Laure El Ghormli,Kaleigh Farrell,Eva Feldman,Jyotika Fernandes,Om Ganda,Patricia M Gatcomb,Manjot Gill,Michael Goldbaum,Ellen Golden,Gregg Greanoff,Naina S Gregory,Osama Hamdy,Regina Hanna,Monica Hartmuller,Yu-Guang He,Jeffrey Heier,S Hensley,William Herman,Kathie L Hermayer,Irl Hirsch,Susan Hitt,Shuchen Ho,Elizabeth Hoffman,J Hu,S Huddleston,Alan M Jacobson,Alan Jarvis,Mary L Johnson,Sherry Johnsonbaugh,J K Jones,Lin F Jordan,A Joseph,Harsha Karanchi,Amy Karger,Lisa Keasler,David Kenny,Loren H Ketai,Szilard Kiss,Kandy Klumpp,Orville Kolterman,Dara Koozekanani,Keyvan Koushan,Davida F Kruger,John Lachin,Mary Larkin,Jean Lawrence,K Lee,Pearl G Lee,Aaron Leong,Ellen Leschek,Yabing Li,Ming-Hui Lin,Gayle Lorenzi,Cynthia K Lovell,Alice T Lyon,Tim J Lyons,John I Malone,Mark Mandelcorn,Tiffanie Marksbury,Catherine Martin,Michael May,Lynne Mayer,Charlotte McDonald,Edward Mendelson,David Miller,Ryan Miller,Rukhsana G Mirza,Sandra R Montezuma,Anthony Morrison,Sunder Mudaliar,Shereen Mukhashen,Timothy J Murtha,David M Nathan,M Novak,Matthew J Nutaitis,Donna Olegario,Lisa Olmos de Koo,Trevor Orchard,Anton Orlin,Juanita O'Brian,Peter R Pavan,S Pendegast,F Perdikaris,Bruce A Perkins,Rodica Pop-Busui,Philip Raskin,S Rath,Melissa Rhodes,Henry Rodriguez,Michael Rubin,Christopher Ryan,Deborah Saporito,Madalyn Saporito,David S Schade,Deborah K Schlossman,Mark H Schutta,Jesse Seegmiller,Ravi Shah,Baomei Shao,George S Sharuk,Tom Sheidow,Jennifer Sherr,Paolo A Silva,Philip Silver,Lawrence J Singerman,William Sivitz,Elsayed Z Soliman,Lori Spillers,Michael Steffes,Margaret E Stockman,Kathleen Stoessel,Jennifer Sun,William Tamborlane,Trevor Taylor,J Terry,Nopporn Thangthaeng,Lee A Thomas,Frederico Toledo,Victoria Trapani,Rafael L Ufret-Vincenty,Adrian Vella,Brenda Vittetoe,Hugh Wabers,Amisha Wallia,Elizabeth Weimann,D Weiss,Neil White,Rachael Wilson,Jamie Wood,H Zegarra,Zhu-Ming Zhang,Amy Zipse,Ian H de Boer
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1001/jamaophthalmol.2024.2890
2024-08-15
Abstract:Importance: High concordance in diabetic retinopathy (DR) outcomes between 7-field (7F) and ultra-widefield (UWF) images would allow for combining longitudinal assessments based on the 2 modalities both in clinical studies and clinical care. Objective: To compare 7F and UWF imaging with regard to DR severity and the associations of DR severity with risk factors, such as hemoglobin A1c, age, diabetes duration, and sex. Design, setting, and participants: This cross-sectional study describes the outcomes of the randomized clinical Diabetes Control and Complications Trial (DCCT) and its subsequent observational study, the Epidemiology of Diabetes Interventions and Complications (EDIC) study. Of the 1441 participants with type 1 diabetes in the DCCT, 1375 were enrolled in the EDIC study. Of the 1171 participants who were active between March 2019 and December 2021, 200° UWF color imaging and 7F fundus photographs were obtained for 785 participants once at the same visit. Central graders assessed 7F-UWF with a 7F template masking the retinal periphery and the full UWF image (UWF-global). Data were analyzed from January 2022 to March 2023. Exposures: Hemoglobin A1c was assessed quarterly during the DCCT and annually during the EDIC study using high-performance liquid chromatography. Main outcomes and measures: Retinopathy was determined independently for all imaging as mild, moderate, or severe nonproliferative DR (SNPDR) using the Early Treatment Diabetic Retinopathy Study (ETDRS) grading scale for the 7F images and the global ETDRS grading scale for the UWF images. Panretinal and focal photocoagulation were self-reported or based on scarring location and pattern observed during grading. Proliferative DR (PDR) was defined by observed neovascularization or evidence of panretinal photocoagulation. Results: Among the 785 participants included in this study, 420 (53%) were male and 365 (47%) were female. The mean (SD) age was 61 (7) years. DR grading between UWF-7F and 7F imaging was correlated for all outcomes, including for severe outcomes, such as SNPDR (κ, 0.73; concordance, 96%), PDR (κ, 0.74; concordance, 97%), scatter photocoagulation (κ, 0.97; concordance, 99%), and focal photocoagulation (κ, 0.71; concordance, 98%). Most DR severity scores were within 1 step (1410 of 1529 [92%]), and 3% (51 of 1529) were more than 2 steps apart (κ, 0.45; 95% CI, 0.42-0.49; weighted κ, 0.63; 95% CI, 0.60-0.67) on the ETDRS severity scale. DR severity assessed within the UWF-global area was higher compared to 7F (median [IQR] UWF-global score, 3 [2-3] vs median 7F level score, 2.0 [1-3]; P < .001), although the 2 modalities were correlated (1225 of 1508 [81%] 1-step agreement; weighted κ, 0.41). Conclusions and relevance: Standard ETDRS 7F and UWF evaluations of DR were comparable for ETDRS severity levels as previously reported by Diabetic Retinopathy Clinical Research Retina Network reports. In addition, these evaluations of DR were comparable for DCCT/EDIT study outcomes and major study conclusions, suggesting that use of UWF imaging is not likely to introduce relevant measurement biases in future longitudinal studies. Trial registration: ClinicalTrials.gov Identifiers: NCT00360815.