Abstract:PurposeRecent studies have documented the significant influence of investment bank relationships on the forecast accuracy of affiliated analysts. However, the literature primarily focuses on investment bank-firm relationships, such as whether the investment bank has underwriter or lending relationships with firms. Little attention has been paid to the impact of investment bank-state relationships. To fill this gap in the literature, this paper investigates whether investment bank-state relationships create an information advantage for affiliated analysts.Design/methodology/approachWe empirically test the information advantage of state-affiliated analysts using a large sample of analyst forecasts from China spanning the period 2008 to 2020. Specifically, we investigate whether state-affiliated analysts issue more accurate and timely forecasts around macro events. To address endogeneity concerns, we examine instances where analysts move between state-affiliated and non-affiliated banks, as well as changes in the controlling structure of investment banks.FindingsWe find that state-affiliated analysts demonstrate greater accuracy in forecasts driven by macro events, indicating their information advantage. This effect is more pronounced under conditions of heightened economic policy uncertainty and closer ties between investment banks and the state. After transitioning to a non-state-affiliated investment bank, analysts no longer maintain the ability to make superior macro-event-driven forecasts. Conversely, when the investment bank's affiliation changes from non-state to state, financial analysts gain an information advantage following the establishment of new state affiliation. Additionally, state-affiliated analysts tend to issue more assertive forecasts in response to macro events, which are subsequently echoed by their peers. Furthermore, this information advantage is recognized by investors, enhancing stock price informativeness.Originality/valueFirstly, we contribute to the literature on the economic implications of state ownership in financial intermediaries. Secondly, we enrich the existing literature on financial analysts by acknowledging the pivotal role of investment bank relationships in shaping analysts' behaviors. Lastly, unlike existing literature that treats forecasts driven by macroeconomic events and those influenced by firm-specific events as a homogeneous category, this study contributes to the literature by innovatively categorizing analyst forecasts into two distinct types.

What can analyst forecasts tell us about imperfect information?

Does State Affiliation Create Information Advantage to Financial Analysts

How Informative is Question-and-answer Similarity to Financial Analysts? Evidence from Chinese Earnings Communication Conferences

Financial Analyst vs. Statistical Model:The Relative Accuracy of Analyst Forecasts and Its Determinants

Analysts' Weighting of Private and Public Information

Rational or Irrational Expectations? Evidence from China's Stock Market

Analyst Characteristics,Market Feature,and Stock Price Informativeness

Do Managers Always Know Better? The Relative Accuracy of Management and Analyst Forecasts

An Experimental Research on Information Efficiency of Securities Markets

Retail Investor Attention and Information Asymmetry: Evidence from China

Information Externalities, Analyst Research Resource Allocation, and Stock Pricing Efficiency

The Effects of True and Perceived Ability on Analysts' Forecasting Behavior

Analyst Forecast Accuracy and Media Independence

Why do Analysts Selectively Announce Cash Flow Forecasts? Empirical Evidence based on Information Requirement Theory

Can Analysts’ Focus on Innovation-Related Information Improve the Accuracy of Forecasts? Chinese Full Text

A multi-dimensional assessment of the accuracy of analyst target prices

The Distinction and the Indication of the Opinions ——A Empirical Study on the Capability of the Financial Analysts in China

Investor Relations And The Analysts' Forecasts: Empirical Evidence From China

Information Production, Cash Flow and Corporate Investment

How Much Information Is Incorporated into Financial Asset Prices? Experimental Evidence

Does Analyst Forecast Informativeness Affect Managers' Financial Reporting Incentives?