What is the attitude of desire?

Kael McCormacka Centre for Philosophical Psychology,University of Antwerp,Antwerp,Belgiumb School of Humanities and Languages,University of New South Wales,Sydney,Australia
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/09515089.2023.2296589
2024-01-03
Philosophical Psychology
Abstract:I defend a view of the attitude of desire against a close rival. Both views are versions of "the guise of the good" thesis. The guise of the good says that a desire for P involves P appearing good in some respect. I defend a content-based account of value appearances against an attitude-based account. On the content view, a desire for P represents P as good while the attitude of that desire presents P's value as true. In other words, a desire for P presents it as true that P is good. Footnote 1 The attitude view says that a desire represents P non-evaluatively while the attitude of that desire presents P as good. In other words, a desire for P presents P as good. The attitude view struggles to explain the relationship between the qualitative character of desires and appearances of value. It must either implausibly deny that there is a close relationship between the two, or explain the relationship by introducing a poorly motivated, revisionist mental ontology. In the present state of the debate between the two views, this problem tips the scales in favor of the content view.
psychology, multidisciplinary,ethics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?