Techno-environmental assessment of air conditioning systems and refrigerants in arid regions: should the global environmental protocols be revised?

Sarah AlOsaimi,Esra Aleisa,Fotouh Al-Ragom
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10098-024-03088-3
IF: 4.3
2024-11-29
Clean Technologies and Environmental Policy
Abstract:This study employs a techno-environmental and economic analysis to assess the influence of two air conditioning (AC) systems, Split and package and three refrigerants—R22, R410A, and R407C in residential buildings. Life cycle assessment indicates that energy consumption during the AC units' operational phase accounts for over 96% of the total burden. The study reveals that the environmental impacts of refrigerants vary considerably across different life cycle phases. R22 has a more detrimental effect during its production phase, showing a reversed trend during operation. It exhibits superior performance with lower carbon footprint and water footprint and reduced operational costs compared to configurations using R410A, and R407C. Configuration SPLIT/R22 emerges as the most environmentally favorable consuming 45.82 m 3 of water and emitting a carbon dioxide equivalent of 328.23 kg/m 2 /yr. From an economic perspective, configurations PACKAGE/R22 and PACKAGE/R407C are the most cost-effective, incurring annual costs of about $1199/m 2 /yr. Optimization considering carbon footprint, water footprint, and cost trade-offs have consistently favored SPLIT/R22. The findings underscore the need to revise the international protocols and its amendments to include a more detailed consideration of the usage phase and entire life cycle to avoid burden shifting, to ensure that operational efficiency, cost and environmental protection are optimized. While this study specifically investigates the climatic conditions of Kuwait and Gulf corporation council countries, its implications are globally relevant given the rising temperatures associated with climate change.
environmental sciences,green & sustainable science & technology,engineering, environmental
What problem does this paper attempt to address?