Improving measurement-based care implementation in youth mental health through organizational leadership and climate: a mechanistic analysis within a randomized trial

Nathaniel J. Williams,Mark G. Ehrhart,Gregory A. Aarons,Susan Esp,Marisa Sklar,Kristine Carandang,Nallely R. Vega,Lauren Brookman-Frazee,Steven C. Marcus
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1186/s13012-024-01356-w
2024-03-30
Implementation Science
Abstract:Theory and correlational research indicate organizational leadership and climate are important for successful implementation of evidence-based practices (EBPs) in healthcare settings; however, experimental evidence is lacking. We addressed this gap using data from the WISDOM (Working to Implement and Sustain Digital Outcome Measures) hybrid type III effectiveness-implementation trial. Primary outcomes from WISDOM indicated the Leadership and Organizational Change for Implementation (LOCI) strategy improved fidelity to measurement-based care (MBC) in youth mental health services. In this study, we tested LOCI's hypothesized mechanisms of change, namely: (1) LOCI will improve implementation and transformational leadership, which in turn will (2) mediate LOCI's effect on implementation climate, which in turn will (3) mediate LOCI's effect on MBC fidelity.
health care sciences & services,health policy & services
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The paper aims to address the following key issues: ### Research Background and Objectives - **Theoretical and empirical research** indicates that organizational leadership and climate are crucial for the successful implementation of Evidence-Based Practices (EBPs) in healthcare settings; however, experimental evidence is still lacking. - **Research gap**: There are currently no trials testing whether changing organizational leadership or climate can improve the quality of clinical intervention implementation. ### Specific Issues - This study utilizes data from the WISDOM (Workforce Innovation and Support for Digital Outcome Measurement) hybrid type III effectiveness-implementation trial to experimentally test whether organizational leaders' use of implementation leadership and transformational leadership behaviors helps improve the organizational implementation climate, thereby enhancing clinicians' fidelity to clinical interventions. - **Specific objectives** include: - Testing the effects of the LOCI (Leadership and Organizational Change for Implementation) strategy on improving implementation leadership, transformational leadership, and the clinic's implementation climate. - Examining whether improvements in implementation leadership and transformational leadership mediate the effect of the LOCI strategy on the implementation climate. - Investigating whether improvements in the implementation climate mediate the effect of the LOCI strategy on fidelity to Measurement-Based Care (MBC). ### Research Contributions - This is the first experimental study to test whether increasing organizational leaders' implementation leadership and transformational leadership behaviors helps improve the organizational implementation climate, thereby enhancing clinicians' fidelity to clinical interventions. - The study provides strong evidence that by demonstrating implementation leadership behaviors and creating a supportive implementation climate within the organization, organizational leaders can improve the implementation of evidence-based practices in healthcare settings. - This research also provides a rigorous example of a multilevel mediation analysis to test the hypothesized mechanisms of implementation strategies. In summary, this paper aims to fill the research gap on how improving organizational leadership and climate can enhance the quality of evidence-based practice implementation in healthcare, particularly in measurement-based care for adolescent mental health services.