Deciphering the Oxygen Absorption Pre‐edge: A Caveat on its Application for Probing Oxygen Redox Reactions in Batteries

Subhayan Roychoudhury,Ruimin Qiao,Zengqing Zhuo,Qinghao Li,Yingchun Lyu,Jung‐Hyun Kim,Jun Liu,Eungje Lee,Bryant J. Polzin,Jinghua Guo,Shishen Yan,Yongsheng Hu,Hong Li,David Prendergast,Wanli Yang
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/eem2.12119
2020-12-28
Abstract:<p>The pre‐edges of oxygen‐<i>K</i> X‐ray absorption spectra have been ubiquitous in transition‐metal (TM) oxide studies in various fields, especially on the fervent topic of oxygen redox states in battery electrodes. However, critical debates remain on the use of the O‐<i>K</i> pre‐edge variations upon electrochemical cycling as evidences of oxygen redox reactions, which has been a popular practice in the battery field. This study presents an investigation of the O‐<i>K</i> pre‐edge of 55 oxides covering all <i>3d</i> TMs with different elements, structures and electrochemical states through combined experimental and theoretical analyses. It is shown unambiguously that the O‐<i>K</i> pre‐edge variation in battery cathodes is dominated by changing TM‐<i>d</i> states. Furthermore, the pre‐edge enables a unique opportunity to project the lowest unoccupied TM‐<i>d</i> states onto one common energy window, leading to a summary map of the relative energy positions of the low‐lying TM states, with higher TM oxidation states at lower energies, corresponding to higher electrochemical potentials. The results naturally clarify some unusual redox reactions, such as Cr<sup>3+/6+</sup>. This work provides a critical clarification on O‐<i>K</i> pre‐edge interpretation and more importantly, a benchmark database of O‐<i>K</i> pre‐edge for characterizing redox reactions in batteries and other energy materials.</p>
materials science, multidisciplinary
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about how to correctly interpret and use the changes in the oxygen K - edge pre - edge (O - K pre - edge) features in battery materials to explore the redox reactions of oxygen. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following aspects: 1. **Questioning existing methods**: Currently, many studies infer the redox state of oxygen in battery cathode materials, that is, whether oxygen is oxidized during the charging process, by observing the changes in O - K pre - edge. However, the effectiveness and accuracy of this practice have been questioned. The paper points out that the changes in O - K pre - edge are mainly affected by the changes in transition metal (TM) - d states, rather than directly reflecting the redox state of oxygen. 2. **Systematic study**: To verify this view, the authors conducted systematic experimental and theoretical analyses on 55 transition metal oxides with different elements, structures and electrochemical states. These analyses cover not only all 3d transition metals but also some ruthenium (Ru) samples. 3. **Revealing the mechanism**: The study found that the changes in O - K pre - edge are mainly caused by the changes in TM - d states. More specifically, O - K pre - edge can project different TM - d states into a common energy window, thus providing a relative energy position map, which shows the relative energy positions of different TM oxidation states. For example, a higher TM oxidation state corresponds to a lower energy position, which is opposite to the traditional TM - L - edge spectral behavior. 4. **Establishing a benchmark database**: Based on the above research, the paper established a benchmark database of O - K pre - edge features for characterizing redox reactions in batteries and other energy materials. This database can be used as a reference for future research, helping researchers more accurately understand the changes in O - K pre - edge and the physical mechanisms behind them. 5. **Analysis of special cases**: The paper also specifically discussed some special redox reactions, such as the Cr3+/6+ redox process. By combining the Cr - L - edge and O - K - edge X - ray absorption spectra (XAS), the authors found that Cr3+ can be directly oxidized to Cr6+, and Cr4+ may not participate in the reaction in some cases. This finding further supports the relationship between O - K pre - edge features and TM - d state changes. In summary, this paper aims to clarify the correct interpretation of O - K pre - edge features and provide a reliable benchmark database to guide future battery material research. Through systematic experimental and theoretical analyses, the paper reveals the main mechanism of O - K pre - edge changes, providing a new perspective for understanding and characterizing redox reactions in battery materials.