Abstract:This study addresses the ongoing debate on forest land-sparing vs land-sharing, aiming to identify effective strategies for both species conservation and timber exploitation. Previous studies, guided by control theory, compared sharing and sparing by optimizing logging intensity along a presumed trade-off between timber yield and ecological outcomes. However, the realism of this trade-off assumption is questioned by ecological and governance theories. This article introduces a mathematical model of Social-Ecological System (SES) dynamics, distinguishing selective logging intensification between sharing and sparing, with associated governance requirements. The model assumes consistent rules for logging, replanting, conservation support, access regulation, socio-economic, soil and climate conditions. Actors, each specialized in sustainable logging and replanting of a single species, coexist with various tree species in the same space for land sharing, contrasting with separate actions on monospecific stands for sparing. In sharing scenarios, a gradient of intensification is created from 256 combinations of selective logging for a forest with eight coexisting tree species. This is compared with eight scenarios of monospecific stands adjacent to a spared eight-species forest area safeguarded from logging. Numerical projections over 100 years rank sparing and sharing options based on forest-level tree biodiversity, carbon storage, and timber yield. The findings underscore the context-specific nature of the problem but identify simple heuristics to optimize both sparing and sharing practices. Prioritizing the most productive tree species is effective when selecting sparing, especially when timber yield and biodiversity are benchmarks. Conversely, sharing consistently outperforms sparing when carbon storage and biodiversity are main criteria. Sharing excels across scenarios considering all three criteria, provided a greater diversity of actors access and coexist in the shared space under collective rules ensuring independence and sustainable logging and replanting. The present model addresses some limitations in existing sparing-sharing theory by aligning with established ecological theories exploring the intricate relationship between disturbance practices, productivity and ecological outcomes. The findings also support a governance hypothesis from the 2009 Nobel Prize in Economics (E. Ostrom) regarding the positive impact on biodiversity and productivity of increasing polycentricity, i.e ., expanding the number of independent species controllers’ channels (loggers/replanters/supporters/regulators). This hypothesis, rooted in Ashby’s law of requisite variety from control theory, suggests that resolving the sharing/sparing dilemma may depend on our ability to predict the yield-ecology performances of sparing (in heterogeneous landscapes) vs of sharing (in the same space) from their respective levels of “polycentric requisite variety”.

Implications for forest management planning in the Northeast: a systematic map

Reciprocal relationships between forest management and regional landscape structures: applying concepts from land system science to private forest management

An Application of Remote Sensing Data in Mapping Landscape-Level Forest Biomass for Monitoring the Effectiveness of Forest Policies in Northeastern China

The Northwest Forest Plan: origins, components, implementation experience, and suggestions for change

Applying the Transtheoretical Model of Change to Legacy Planning Decisions

Incorporating wildlife connectivity into forest plan revision under the United States Forest Service's 2012 planning rule

The Northwest Forest Plan as a model for broad-scale ecosystem management: a social perspective

Regulatory Intensity on Private Forestland and its Relationship with State Characteristics in the United States

Differences and Similarities Among Members and Nonmembers of Forest Landowner Associations in the Southern United States

United States Family Forest Owners’ Awareness of and Participation in Carbon Sequestration Programs: Initial Findings from the USDA Forest Service National Woodland Owner Survey

Forest landowner values and perspectives of prescribed fire in the Northeast/Mid-Atlantic region of the United States

Private land management is more important than public land in sustaining oaks in temperate forests in the eastern U.S.

Mapping historical forest biomass for stock-change assessments at parcel to landscape scales

Land use change and forest management effects on soil carbon stocks in the Northeast U.S.

Insights on linking forests, trees, and people from the air, on the ground, and in the laboratory

Mapping recent timber harvest activity in a temperate forest using single date airborne LiDAR surveys and machine learning: lessons for conservation planning

Public Attitudes towards Birds and Private Forest Land Conservation

Life-cycle impact assessment of hardwood forest resources in the eastern United States

The use of socio-spatial data for sustainable roads planning: a national forest case study

The Implications of Plantation Forest-Driven Land Use/Land Cover Changes for Ecosystem Service Values in the Northwestern Highlands of Ethiopia

Navigating the complexities of the forest land sharing vs sparing logging dilemma: analytical insights through the governance theory of social-ecological systems dynamics