The Impact of H-Indexin Predicting Academic Radiation Oncology Promotion

Monique N Westley,Christina C. Huang,Reshma Jagsi,Shearwood McClelland
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jnma.2024.07.104
IF: 2.739
2024-08-30
Journal of the National Medical Association
Abstract:Introduction Productivity in medical academia encompasses research output impact, and professional influence, with the Hirsch index (h-index) serving as a key metric. H-index measures the number of publications (x) cited at least x times. While prior research in radiation oncology has explored the h-index's influence on career trajectories and academic rank, its connection with academic promotion remains underexplored. This study systematically delves into the relationship between the h-index and academic promotion through a comprehensive analysis of a nationwide cohort. Methods The dataset comprises information from 554 radiation oncologists affiliated with 51 National Cancer Institute-designated Comprehensive Cancer Centers, documented in 2019 and reassessed in 2023. The study focuses on oncologists at junior faculty levels or associate professor levels in 2019. By comparing academic ranks in 2019 with positions in 2023, promotion status was determined, and statistical analysis using Fisher's exact test assessed the impact of the h-index on promotion, with significance set at p < 0.05. Results The findings indicate that 61% (338) of oncologists achieved promotion, while 39% (216) did not. The mean h-index stood at 12.3(median = 9), with a notably higher average (15.3) observed among those who were promoted. A statistically significant association (p 9 and promotion was established. Conclusion In summary, an h-index exceeding 9 emerges as a predictive factor for academic promotion within a four-year timeframe among radiation oncologists, emphasizing the critical role of impactful research in academic career advancement.
medicine, general & internal
What problem does this paper attempt to address?