Abstract:Cost-effectiveness analyses (CEA) are important in healthcare decision-making and resource allocation; however, expanding the scope of CEAs beyond the traditional clinicoeconomic concepts to also include value elements such as health equity has attracted much interest in recent years. This umbrella review aimed to synthesize evidence on how equity concepts have been considered in modified types of CEAs. Publicly available articles in MEDLINE were searched on January 25, 2024, to identify systematic reviews (SLRs) published in English since 2013 that incorporate health equity considerations in CEAs. Title/abstract, full-text article screening and data extraction were conducted by a single reviewer and validated by a second reviewer. Results were qualitatively synthesized to identify common themes. Eight SLRs were included. Distributional CEAs (DCEA), equity-based weighting, extended CEA (ECEA), mathematical programming and multi-criteria decision analysis (MCDA) were the most discussed approaches. A lack of consensus on the best approach for incorporating health equity into CEAs was highlighted, as these approaches are not currently consistently used in decision-making. Important limitations included scarcity of robust data to inform health equity indices, bias associated with commonly used health outcome metrics and the challenge of accounting for additional contextual factors such as fairness and opportunity costs. Proposals to expand CEAs to address equity issues come with challenges due to data unavailability, methods complexity, and decision-makers unfamiliarity with these approaches. Our review indicates that extended and distributional CEAs can support decision-making by capturing the impact of inequity on the clinical and cost-effectiveness assessment of treatments, although future modeling should account for additional contextual factors such as fairness and opportunity costs. Recommendations for actions moving forward include standardization of data collection for outcomes related to equity and familiarity with methodologies to account for the complexities of integrating health equity considerations in CEAs.

Meaningful causal decompositions in health equity research: definition, identification, and estimation through a weighting framework

A New Causal Decomposition Paradigm towards Health Equity

Choosing an Optimal Method for Causal Decomposition Analysis: A Better Practice for Identifying Contributing Factors to Health Disparities

Estimation and Sensitivity Analysis for Causal Decomposition in Heath Disparity Research

Decomposition analysis to identify intervention targets for reducing disparities

Educational note: causal decomposition of population health differences using Monte Carlo integration and the g-formula

Sensitivity analysis for causal decomposition analysis: Assessing robustness toward omitted variable bias

The covariate-adjusted residual estimator and its use in both randomized trials and observational settings

Energy balancing of covariate distributions

Health Equity Considerations in Cost-Effectiveness Analysis: Insights from an Umbrella Review

Evaluating Effects of Multilevel Interventions on Disparity in Health and Healthcare Decisions

Optimal transport weights for causal inference

Practical Guide for Causal Pathways and Sub-group Disparity Analysis

Causal mediation analysis decomposition of between-hospital variance

Causal Inference Challenges in the Relationship Between Social Determinants and Cardiovascular Outcomes

An intersectionality framework for identifying relevant covariates in health equity research

The Target Study: A Conceptual Model and Framework for Measuring Disparity

Hierarchical Bias-Driven Stratification for Interpretable Causal Effect Estimation

Propensity Score Weighting for Causal Subgroup Analysis

Causal mediation analysis: From simple to more robust strategies for estimation of marginal natural (in)direct effects

On the implied weights of linear regression for causal inference