Propensity Score Weighting for Causal Subgroup Analysis

Siyun Yang,Elizabeth Lorenzi,Georgia Papadogeorgou,Daniel M. Wojdyla,Fan Li,Laine E. Thomas

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2010.02121

2021-03-21

Abstract:A common goal in comparative effectiveness research is to estimate treatment effects on pre-specified subpopulations of patients. Though widely used in medical research, causal inference methods for such subgroup analysis remain underdeveloped, particularly in observational studies. In this article, we develop a suite of analytical methods and visualization tools for causal subgroup analysis. First, we introduce the estimand of subgroup weighted average treatment effect and provide the corresponding propensity score weighting estimator. We show that balancing covariates within a subgroup bounds the bias of the estimator of subgroup causal effects. Second, we design a new diagnostic graph -- the Connect-S plot -- for visualizing the subgroup covariate balance. Finally, we propose to use the overlap weighting method to achieve exact balance within subgroups. We further propose a method that combines overlap weighting and LASSO, to balance the bias-variance tradeoff in subgroup analysis. Extensive simulation studies are presented to compare the proposed method with several existing methods. We apply the proposed methods to the Patient-centered Results for Uterine Fibroids (COMPARE-UF) registry data to evaluate alternative management options for uterine fibroids for relief of symptoms and quality of life.

Methodology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the methodological challenges in conducting causal subgroup analysis (SGA) in observational studies. Specifically, the author points out that although causal inference methods are widely used in medical research to estimate treatment effects, the methods for estimating causal effects for specific subgroups are still not fully developed, especially in observational studies. The paper aims to develop a set of analysis methods and visualization tools to more accurately estimate treatment effects in predefined patient subgroups and reduce estimation bias. The key issues in the paper include: 1. **Estimation of Subgroup - Weighted Average Treatment Effect (S - WATE)**: The concept of subgroup - weighted average treatment effect is proposed, and the corresponding propensity score - weighted estimator is provided. 2. **Covariate Balance within Subgroups**: Precise covariate balance within subgroups is achieved through the re - weighting method, thereby reducing estimation bias. 3. **Bias - Variance Trade - off**: The LASSO and re - weighting methods are combined to balance the bias - variance trade - off in subgroup analysis. 4. **Visualization of Subgroup Covariate Balance**: A new diagnostic plot - Connect - S plot is designed to visualize the covariate balance within subgroups. Through these methods, the paper aims to improve the accuracy and reliability of subgroup causal effect estimation in observational studies.

Propensity Score Weighting for Causal Subgroup Analysis

Propensity score weighting for causal inference with multiple treatments

Subgroup Balancing Propensity Score

Propensity Score Analysis with Guaranteed Subgroup Balance

Propensity Score Methods for Creating Covariate Balance in Observational Studies

Using propensity scores for racial disparities analysis

Semiparametric Estimation for Average Causal Effects Using Propensity Score-Based Spline

Evaluating propensity score weighting methods in heterogeneous population: a comparative study

Contrast-specific Propensity Scores for Causal Inference with Multiple Interventions.

Using Propensity Scores to Estimate Effects of Treatment Initiation Decisions: State of the Science

GBM Propensity Score Weighting for Causal Inference Research

Recent Development Of Propensity Score Methods In Observational Studies: Multi-Categorical Treatment, Causal Mediation, And Heterogeneity

Comparing Approaches to Treatment Effect Estimation for Subgroups in Clinical Trials

Uncertainty in Propensity Score Estimation: Bayesian Methods for Variable Selection and Model-Averaged Causal Effects

Addressing Extreme Propensity Scores via the Overlap Weights

Propensity score weighting for causal inference with clustered data

Using multiple imputation to classify potential outcomes subgroups

How to perform prespecified subgroup analyses when using propensity score methods in the case of imbalanced subgroups

A tutorial comparing different covariate balancing methods with an application evaluating the causal effects of substance use treatment programs for adolescents

Analyzing Treatment Effect by Integrating Existing Propensity Score and Outcome Regressions with Heterogeneous Covariate Sets