Abstract:We study the complexity of a range of propositional proof systems which allow inference rules of the form: from a set of clauses $\Gamma$ derive the set of clauses $\Gamma \cup \{ C \}$ where, due to some syntactic condition, $\Gamma \cup \{ C \}$ is satisfiable if $\Gamma$ is, but where $\Gamma$ does not necessarily imply $C$. These inference rules include BC, RAT, SPR and PR (respectively short for blocked clauses, resolution asymmetric tautologies, subset propagation redundancy and propagation redundancy), which arose from work in satisfiability (SAT) solving. We introduce a new, more general rule SR (substitution redundancy). If the new clause $C$ is allowed to include new variables then the systems based on these rules are all equivalent to extended resolution. We focus on restricted systems that do not allow new variables. The systems with deletion, where we can delete a clause from our set at any time, are denoted DBC${}^-$, DRAT${}^-$, DSPR${}^-$, DPR${}^-$ and DSR${}^-$. The systems without deletion are BC${}^-$, RAT${}^-$, SPR${}^-$, PR${}^-$ and SR${}^-$. With deletion, we show that DRAT${}^-$, DSPR${}^-$ and DPR${}^-$ are equivalent. By earlier work of Kiesl, Rebola-Pardo and Heule, they are also equivalent to DBC${}^-$. Without deletion, we show that SPR${}^-$ can simulate PR${}^-$ provided only short clauses are inferred by SPR inferences. We also show that many of the well-known "hard" principles have small SPR${}^-$ refutations. These include the pigeonhole principle, bit pigeonhole principle, parity principle, Tseitin tautologies and clique-coloring tautologies. SPR${}^-$ can also handle or-fication and xor-ification, and lifting with an index gadget. Our final result is an exponential size lower bound for RAT${}^-$ refutations, giving exponential separations between RAT${}^-$ and both DRAT${}^-$ and SPR${}^-$.

On CDCL-based proof systems with the ordered decision strategy

Conflict Resolution: a First-Order Resolution Calculus with Decision Literals and Conflict-Driven Clause Learning

Understanding the Relative Strength of QBF CDCL Solvers and QBF Resolution

A Deep Dive into Conflict Generating Decisions

Hardness of Random Reordered Encodings of Parity for Resolution and CDCL

Dependency Schemes in CDCL-Based QBF Solving: A Proof-Theoretic Study

Extended Resolution Clause Learning via Dual Implication Points

Too much information: Why CDCL solvers need to forget learned clauses.

Between SAT and UNSAT: The Fundamental Difference in CDCL SAT

Revisiting the Learned Clauses Database Reduction Strategies

clauseSMT: A NLSAT-Based Clause-Level Framework for Satisfiability Modulo Nonlinear Real Arithmetic Theory

On the Effect of Learned Clauses on Stochastic Local Search

The completeness of reasoning algorithms for clause sets in description logic ALC

A Resolution-Based Interactive Proof System for UNSAT

DRAT and Propagation Redundancy Proofs Without New Variables

Clausal Analysis of First-order Proof Schemata

Lower bounds for set-blocked clauses proofs

Proof Generation for CDCL Solvers Using Gauss-Jordan Elimination

Weighted, Circular and Semi-Algebraic Proofs

On the (In-)Completeness of Destructive Equality Resolution in the Superposition Calculus

Proof Theory and Decision Procedures for Deontic STIT Logics