Determining the Electron-Phonon Coupling in Superconducting Cuprates by Resonant Inelastic X-ray Scattering: Methods and Results on Nd$_{1+x}$Ba$_{2-x}$Cu$_3$O$_{7-δ}$

Lucio Braicovich,Matteo Rossi,Roberto Fumagalli,Yingying Peng,Yan Wang,Riccardo Arpaia,Davide Betto,Gabriella M. De Luca,Daniele Di Castro,Kurt Kummer,Marco Moretti Sala,Mattia Pagetti,Giuseppe Balestrino,Nicholas B. Brookes,Marco Salluzzo,Steven Johnston,Jeroen van den Brink,Giacomo Ghiringhelli
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevResearch.2.023231
2020-03-11
Abstract:The coupling between lattice vibration quanta and valence electrons can induce charge density modulations and decisively influence the transport properties of materials, e.g. leading to conventional superconductivity. In high critical temperature superconductors, where electronic correlation is the main actor, the actual role of electron-phonon coupling (EPC) is being intensely debated theoretically and investigated experimentally. We present an in-depth study of how the EPC strength can be obtained directly from resonant inelastic x-ray scattering (RIXS) data through the theoretical approach derived by Ament et al. [EPL 95, 27008 (2011)]. The role of the model parameters (e.g. phonon energy $\omega_0$, intermediate state lifetime $1/\Gamma$, EPC matrix element $M$, and detuning energy $\Omega$) is thoroughly analyzed, providing general relations among them that can be used to make quantitative estimates of the dimensionless EPC $g = (M/\omega_0)^2$ without detailed microscopic modeling. We then apply these methods to very high resolution Cu $L_3$ edge RIXS spectra of three Nd$_{1+x}$Ba$_{2-x}$Cu$_3$O$_{7-\delta}$ films. For the insulating antiferromagnetic parent compound the value of $M$ as a function of the in-plane momentum transfer is obtained for Cu-O bond-stretching (breathing) and bond-bending (buckling) phonon branches. For the underdoped and the nearly optimally doped samples, the effects of Coulomb screening and of charge-density-wave correlations on $M$ are assessed. In light of the anticipated further improvements of the RIXS experimental resolution, this work provides a solid framework for an exhaustive investigation of the EPC in cuprates and other quantum materials.
Superconductivity,Strongly Correlated Electrons
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to determine the strength of electron - phonon coupling (EPC) in high - temperature superconducting cuprates. Specifically, the researchers hope to directly extract the strength of electron - phonon coupling from experimental data through resonant inelastic X - ray scattering (RIXS) technology and explore its variation under different doping levels. This research is of great significance for understanding the superconducting mechanism in high - temperature superconductors. Especially in materials with strong electron - electron interactions, the role of electron - phonon coupling remains controversial. ### Core problems of the paper: 1. **Determine the strength of electron - phonon coupling**: Through RIXS technology, the researchers hope to be able to directly measure the strength of electron - phonon coupling, especially in the application in high - temperature superconducting cuprates. 2. **Analyze the influence of different doping levels**: Study the change of electron - phonon coupling under different doping levels, especially for insulating antiferromagnetic parent compounds (AF), under - doped (UD) and near - optimally doped (OP) samples. 3. **Explore the correlation between electron - phonon coupling and charge density wave (CDW)**: Analyze the influence of charge density wave on electron - phonon coupling, especially its performance under different doping levels. ### Research methods: - **Theoretical framework**: Based on the theoretical model proposed by Ament et al., analyze RIXS data to extract the strength of electron - phonon coupling. - **Experimental design**: Use high - resolution RIXS technology to measure Nd\(_{1 + x}\)Ba\(_{2 - x}\)Cu\(_3\)O\(_{7 - \delta}\) (NBCO) films, including insulating antiferromagnetic parent compounds, under - doped and near - optimally doped samples. - **Data analysis**: By analyzing the phonon peaks in the RIXS spectra, determine the electron - phonon coupling matrix element \( M \) and other related parameters, such as phonon energy \( \omega_0 \), intermediate - state lifetime \( 1/\Gamma \) etc. ### Main results: - **Extract the strength of electron - phonon coupling**: Through RIXS data, the researchers successfully extracted the strength of electron - phonon coupling under different doping levels. - **Analyze the doping effect**: It is found that as the doping level changes, the strength of electron - phonon coupling also changes. Especially in under - doped and near - optimally doped samples, the influence of charge density wave on electron - phonon coupling is significant. - **Propose a universal scaling law**: The researchers proposed a universal scaling law, which can quantitatively estimate the dimensionless electron - phonon coupling constant \( g=(M / \omega_0)^2 \) without relying on a detailed microscopic model. ### Conclusion: This research provides important experimental evidence and theoretical support for understanding electron - phonon coupling in high - temperature superconducting cuprates. Through RIXS technology, the researchers can not only directly measure the strength of electron - phonon coupling, but also analyze the change of electron - phonon coupling under different doping levels, laying the foundation for further research on the high - temperature superconducting mechanism.