A comment on "New non-parametric inferences for low-income proportions" by Shan Luo and Gengsheng Qin

Wojciech Zieliński

2019-03-07

Abstract:Shan Luo and Gengsheng Qin published the article "New non-parametric inferences for low-income proportions" Ann Inst Stat Math, 69, 599-626. In the note their approach is compared to Zieliński 2009 approach.

Statistics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper mainly discusses non-parametric inference methods for the important indicator of Low-Income Proportion (LIP) or At-Risk-of-Poverty Rate (ARPR). LIP refers to the proportion of the population with income below a certain threshold, commonly used to assess socio-economic conditions and the poverty status of the population. Specifically, LIP is defined as the proportion of the population with income below α times the β quantile of the income distribution.

The paper mentions that Shan Luo and Gengsheng Qin proposed a new non-parametric inference method to estimate LIP and conducted an asymptotic analysis of its properties. They first estimated the cumulative distribution function using the kernel estimation method and then constructed confidence intervals for LIP based on the asymptotic normality of the obtained estimators. Meanwhile, Wojciech Zielinski's research demonstrated another simple estimation method based on the properties of the binomial distribution and its confidence interval calculation method, and validated its effectiveness through simulation experiments under different distributions.

Overall, this paper aims to compare the performance of two different non-parametric inference methods in estimating LIP and to explore their advantages and disadvantages in practical applications. Particularly for small sample situations, the method proposed by Zielinski shows better performance, while the method by Luo and Qin is more suitable for large sample situations.