Dynamic facilitation theory: A statistical mechanics approach to dynamic arrest

Thomas Speck

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/1742-5468/ab2ace

2019-02-21

Abstract:The modeling of supercooled liquids approaching dynamic arrest has a long tradition, which is documented through a plethora of competing theoretical approaches. Here, we review the modeling of supercooled liquids in terms of dynamic "defects", also called excitations or soft spots, that are able to sustain motion. To this end, we consider a minimal statistical mechanics description in terms of active regions with the order parameter related to their typical size. This is the basis for both Adam-Gibbs and dynamical facilitation theory, which differ in their relaxation mechanism as the liquid is cooled: collective motion of more and more particles vs. concerted hierarchical motion over larger and larger length scales. For the latter, dynamic arrest is possible without a growing static correlation length, and we sketch the derivation of a key result: the parabolic law for the structural relaxation time. We critically discuss claims in favor of a growing static length and argue that the resulting scenarios for pinning and dielectric relaxation are in fact compatible with dynamic facilitation.

Materials Science

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the behavior of supercooled liquids as they approach dynamic arrest, particularly explaining this phenomenon from the perspective of statistical mechanics. Specifically, the authors propose the Dynamical Facilitation Theory to describe how so-called "defects" or excitations in supercooled liquids sustain particle motion.

### Problems the Paper Attempts to Solve

1. **Understanding the Dynamic Arrest of Supercooled Liquids**: When the temperature of a supercooled liquid drops below the glass transition temperature \(T_g\), its dynamics slow down significantly, and viscosity increases sharply. This phenomenon is known as dynamic arrest or glass transition. This paper attempts to explain this phenomenon from the perspective of statistical mechanics.

2. **Proposing the Dynamical Facilitation Theory**: This theory posits that even with constant configurational entropy, complex dynamic rules can lead to dynamic arrest. By considering the statistical properties of active regions (i.e., regions that can support particle motion), the paper develops a minimal statistical mechanical description and discusses two theoretical models based on this: the Adam-Gibbs theory and the Dynamical Facilitation Theory.

3. **Explaining the Variation of Structural Relaxation Time**: The paper derives an expression for the structural relaxation time as a function of temperature. For the Adam-Gibbs theory, this manifests as a super-Arrhenius behavior; for the Dynamical Facilitation Theory, a parabolic law is obtained, describing the relationship between structural relaxation time and temperature.

4. **Exploring the Temperature Dependence of Related Physical Quantities**: This includes configurational entropy, heat capacity, and other physical quantities related to dynamic arrest, such as dynamic length scales.

5. **Analyzing the Relationship Between Dynamic Arrest and Structure**: The paper discusses whether dynamic arrest is related to static structural features, particularly whether there is a growing static correlation length. The authors point out that although dynamic heterogeneity exists, it does not necessarily imply the presence of two competing dynamic phases.

In summary, this paper aims to provide a statistical mechanical framework to understand and describe the phenomenon of dynamic arrest in supercooled liquids, with a particular focus on the concept of active regions and their impact on dynamic behavior.