Estelle Berthier,Jonathan E. Kollmer,Silke E. Henkes,Kuang Liu,Jennifer M. Schwarz,Karen E. Daniels
Abstract:In ordinary solids, material disorder is known to increase the size of the process zone in which stress concentrates at the crack tip, causing a transition from localized to diffuse failure. Here, we report experiments on disordered 2D lattices, derived from frictional particle packings, in which the mean coordination number $\langle z \rangle$ of the underlying network provides a similar control. Our experiments show that tuning the connectivity of the network provides access to a range of behaviors from brittle to ductile failure. We elucidate the cooperative origins of this transition using a frictional pebble game algorithm on the original, intact lattices. We find that the transition corresponds to the isostatic value $\langle z \rangle = 3$ in the large-friction limit, with brittle failure occurring for structures vertically spanned by a rigid cluster, and ductile failure for floppy networks containing nonspanning rigid clusters. Furthermore, we find that individual failure events typically occur within the floppy regions separated by the rigid clusters.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to control the transition of materials from brittle to ductile by adjusting the connectivity in disordered networks. Specifically, the authors studied how the average coordination number \( \langle z \rangle \) in two - dimensional disordered lattices affects the failure behavior of materials, from brittle fracture to ductile fracture. They used networks derived from frictional particle packing for experiments and explored how the rigidity percolation of these networks controls the brittle - ductile transition. The main objective of the study was to understand the material behavior under different connectivities and to reveal the cooperative origin of this transition.
### Main problems
1. **Control parameters for brittle - ductile transition**:
- The paper explored how the disorder of materials controls the transition of materials from brittle to ductile by changing the connectivity of the network (i.e., the average coordination number \( \langle z \rangle \)).
- Through experimental and theoretical analysis, the authors studied the failure behavior of materials under different \( \langle z \rangle \) values.
2. **Relationship between rigidity percolation and brittle - ductile transition**:
- The authors used networks derived from frictional particle packing for experiments. By adjusting the connectivity of the network, they observed the transition of materials from brittle to ductile.
- They used the rigidity percolation theory to explain this transition, especially by identifying rigid clusters and flexible regions to understand the failure mode.
### Experimental methods
- **Sample preparation**:
- The sample geometry was derived from the force - chain networks of two - dimensional granular materials observed in experiments.
- These networks were engraved on acrylic plates using laser - cutting technology to form disordered lattices with different \( \langle z \rangle \) values.
- **Experimental conditions**:
- The samples were tested under compression and tension conditions, and the macroscopic force - displacement responses and failure events were recorded.
- A high - speed camera was used to record the experimental process, and the failure locations and modes were analyzed.
### Key findings
- **Transition between brittle and ductile behaviors**:
- When \( \langle z \rangle < 3 \), the material exhibits ductile behavior, and the failure events are widely distributed throughout the sample.
- When \( \langle z \rangle > 3 \), the material exhibits brittle behavior, and the failure events are concentrated in narrow cracks.
- **Roles of rigid clusters and flexible regions**:
- The percolation of rigid clusters determines the brittle or ductile behavior of the material.
- When \( \langle z \approx 3 \), the material exhibits mixed behavior, with both brittle and ductile characteristics.
### Theoretical explanation
- **Rigidity percolation theory**:
- Rigid - cluster decomposition was carried out using networks derived from frictional particle packing, and rigid clusters and flexible regions were identified by the (3,3) pebble - game algorithm.
- The size and distribution of rigid clusters are closely related to the failure behavior of materials. In particular, when \( \langle z \approx 3 \), the existence of flexible regions leads to ductile behavior, while the percolation of rigid clusters leads to brittle behavior.
### Conclusion
Through experimental and theoretical analysis, this study revealed how the connectivity in disordered networks controls the transition of materials from brittle to ductile. This finding is of great significance for designing lightweight and tunable structural materials with specific failure modes.