The Intrinsic Stochasticity of the $^{56}$Ni Distribution of Single-Degenerate Type Ia Supernovae

Chris Byrohl,Robert T. Fisher,Dean M. Townsley

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ab1f73

2018-10-19

Abstract:Binary Chandrasekhar-mass white dwarfs accreting mass from non-degenerate stellar companions through the single-degenerate channel have reigned for decades as the leading explanation of Type Ia supernovae. Yet, a comprehensive theoretical explanation has not yet emerged to explain the expected properties of the canonical near-Chandrasekhar-mass white dwarf model. A simmering phase within the convective core of the white dwarf leads to the ignition of one or more flame bubbles scattered across the core. Consequently, near-Chandrasekhar-mass single-degenerate SNe Ia are inherently stochastic, and are expected to lead to a range of outcomes, from subluminous SN 2002cx-like events, to overluminous SN 1991T-like events. However, all prior simulations of the single-degenerate channel carried through the detonation phase have set the ignition points as free parameters. In this work, for the first time, we place ignition points as predicted by {\it ab initio} models of the convective phase leading up to ignition, and follow through the detonation phase in fully three-dimensional simulations. Single-degenerates in this framework are characteristically overluminous. Using a statistical approach, we determine the $^{56}$Ni mass distribution arising from stochastic ignition. While there is a total spread of $\gtrsim 0.2 M_{\odot}$ for detonating models, the distribution is strongly left-skewed, and with a narrow standard deviation of $\simeq 0.03 M_{\odot}$. Conversely, if single-degenerates are not overluminous but primarily yield normal or failed events, then the models require fine-tuning of the ignition parameters, or otherwise require revised physics or progenitor models. We discuss implications of our findings for the modeling of single-degenerate SNe Ia.

Solar and Stellar Astrophysics,High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the intrinsic randomness of 56Ni distribution in the single - degenerate channel of Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia). Specifically, the paper explores how the flame - bubble ignition process in the convective core of a white dwarf in the single - degenerate model leads to Type Ia supernova events with different luminosities. By using ab - initio models to predict ignition points for the first time and conducting full three - dimensional simulations, the researchers hope to understand how these random ignitions affect the final 56Ni mass distribution and, in turn, the luminosity of supernovae.

### Main research questions:
1. **Randomness of single - degenerate Type Ia supernovae**: The paper explores the randomness of the flame - bubble ignition process in the convective core due to turbulence when a white dwarf in the single - degenerate model approaches the Chandrasekhar limit.
2. **56Ni mass distribution**: By simulating different ignition positions, the researchers attempt to determine the mass distribution of 56Ni and how this distribution affects the luminosity of supernovae.
3. **Verification of ignition models**: The paper uses ab - initio models to predict ignition points for the first time and verifies the validity of these ignition models through full three - dimensional simulations.

### Research background:
- **Single - degenerate model**: The single - degenerate model refers to a white dwarf approaching the Chandrasekhar - limit mass that accretes matter from a non - degenerate companion star and eventually triggers a supernova explosion.
- **Randomness of the ignition process**: Turbulence in the convective core causes flame - bubbles to ignite randomly at different positions, which gives single - degenerate Type Ia supernovae an intrinsic randomness.
- **Production of 56Ni**: 56Ni is the main radioactive isotope produced during the Type Ia supernova explosion, and its mass directly affects the luminosity of supernovae.

### Research methods:
- **Ab - initio model**: Use the ab - initio model to predict the position of ignition points.
- **Full three - dimensional simulation**: Through full three - dimensional simulations, track the entire process from ignition to explosion.
- **Statistical analysis**: Analyze the 56Ni mass distribution under different ignition positions by statistical methods.

### Main findings:
- **Range of 56Ni mass distribution**: Simulation results show that the mass distribution range of 56Ni is greater than 0.2 solar masses (M⊙), but the distribution is left - skewed, with a standard deviation of about 0.03 solar masses.
- **Over - luminous single - degenerate supernovae**: In this framework, single - degenerate supernovae usually appear as over - luminous events.
- **Sensitivity of ignition parameters**: If single - degenerate supernovae are not over - luminous but normal or failed events, then fine - tuning of ignition parameters is required, or the physical model or progenitor model needs to be revised.

### Conclusion:
Through detailed simulations and statistical analyses, the paper reveals the intrinsic randomness of 56Ni distribution in single - degenerate Type Ia supernovae and its impact on the luminosity of supernovae. These findings are of great significance for understanding the physical mechanisms of Type Ia supernovae and their cosmological applications.