Relativistic corrections to vacuum polarization contributions in muonic hydrogen

Wayne W. Repko

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevD.98.033006

2018-06-28

Abstract:The method proposed by Kinoshita and Nio to compute higher order vacuum polarization contributions to the Coulomb potential in muonic hydrogen is generalized to obtain relativistic corrections to their results.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Relativistic and Recoil Corrections to Vacuum polarization in muonic systems: Three--photon exchange, gauge invariance and numerical values

Gregory S. Adkins,Ulrich D. Jentschura

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.110.032816

2024-09-26

Abstract:For an accurate theoretical description of muonic bound systems, it is crucial to consistently treat relativistic and recoil corrections to vacuum polarization. The one-loop vacuum-polarization effect is by far the dominant quantum electrodynamic (QED) energy correction for bound muons, being of order $\alpha (Z\alpha)^2 m_r$, where $\alpha$ is the fine-structure constant, $Z$ is the nuclear charge number, and $m_r$ is the reduced mass. Gauge invariance of the relativistic and recoil corrections to vacuum polarization of order $\alpha (Z\alpha)^4 m_r$ is investigated with respect to nonretarded and standard, renormalized variants of Coulomb gauge. The invariance is shown after including three-photon exchange diagrams. Our derivation is based on an adapted form of Nonrelativistic Quantum Electrodynamics for bound muon systems (NRQED$_\mu$), which is a version of NRQED where the hard scale is set at the muon mass instead of the electron mass. Updated values for the gauge-independent corrections for one-muon ions with nuclear charge numbers $Z = 1,2,6$ are presented.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology
Relativistic recoil corrections to the electron-vacuum-polarization contribution in light muonic atoms

Savely G. Karshenboim,Vladimir G. Ivanov,Evgeny Yu. Korzinin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/physreva.85.032509

IF: 2.971

2012-03-12

Physical Review A

Abstract:The relativistic recoil contributions to the Uehling corrections are revisited. A controversy in recent calculations is considered, which is based on different approaches including Breit-type and Grotch-type calculations. It is found that calculations in those works were in fact done in different gauges and in some of those gauges contributions to retardation and two-photon-exchange effects were missed. Such effects are evaluated and a consistent result is obtained. A correct expression for the Grotch-type approach is presented, which produces a correct gauge-invariant result. A finite-nuclear-size correction for the Uehling term is also considered. The results are presented for muonic hydrogen and deuterium atoms and for muonic 3He and 4He ions.

optics,physics, atomic, molecular & chemical
Relativistic recoil effects in a muonic atom within a Grotch-type approach: General approach

Savely G. Karshenboim,Vladimir G. Ivanov,Evgeny Yu. Korzinin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.89.022102

2014-04-03

Abstract:Recently we calculated relativistic recoil corrections to the energy levels of the low lying states in muonic hydrogen induced by electron vacuum polarization effects. The results were obtained by Breit-type and Grotch-type calculations. The former were described in our previous papers in detail, and here we present the latter. The Grotch equation was originally developed for pure Coulomb systems and allowed to express the relativistic recoil correction in order $(Z\alpha)^4m^2/M$ in terms of the relativistic non-recoil contribution $(Z\alpha)^4m$. Certain attempts to adjust the method to electronic vacuum polarization took place in the past, however, the consideration was incomplete and the results were incorrect. Here we present a Groth-type approach to the problem and in a series of papers consider relativistic recoil effects in order $\alpha(Z\alpha)^4m^2/M$ and $\alpha^2(Z\alpha)^4m^2/M$. That is the first paper of the series and it presents a general approach, while two other papers present results of calculations of the $\alpha(Z\alpha)^4m^2/M$ and $\alpha^2(Z\alpha)^4m^2/M$ contributions in detail. In contrast to our previous calculation, we address now a variety of states in muonic atoms with a certain range of the nuclear charge $Z$.

Atomic Physics
Reexamination of vacuum-polarization corrections to the self-energy in muonic bound systems

B. Ohayon,U. D. Jentschura

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.110.032820

2024-09-27

Abstract:In muonic bound systems, the dominant radiative correction is due to vacuum polarization. Yet, for the interpretation of precision experiments, self-energy effects are also important. In turn, additional vacuum-polarization loops perturb the self-energy. Here, we show that combined self-energy vacuum-polarization effects can perturb the bound-state self-energy at the percent level in one-muon bound systems with nuclear charges Z = 1-6. We also update previous treatments of the corrections for muonic hydrogen, muonic deuterium, and muonic helium bound systems.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology,Atomic Physics
Vacuum polarization corrections to hyperfine structure in many-electron atoms

J. C. Hasted,C. J. Fairhall,O. R. Smits,B. M. Roberts,J. S. M. Ginges

2024-09-26

Abstract:We perform a theoretical study of vacuum polarization corrections to the hyperfine structure in many-electron atoms. Calculations are performed for systems of interest for precision atomic tests of fundamental physics belonging to the alkali-metal atoms and singly-ionized alkaline earths. The vacuum polarization is considered in the Uehling approximation, and we study the many-body effects core relaxation, core polarization, and valence-core correlations in the relativistic framework. We find that for s states, the relative vacuum polarization correction may be well-approximated by that for hydrogen-like ions, though for all other states account of many-body effects -- in particular, the polarization of the core -- is needed to obtain the correct sign and magnitude of the effect.

Atomic Physics
Relativistic corrections to energy spectrum of hydrogen due to the full one-photon-exchange interaction

Zi-Wen Zhang,Hai-Qing Zhou

2024-03-07

Abstract:In this work, we estimate the relativistic corrections to the energy spectrum of hydrogen resulting from the full one-photon-exchange interaction using a highly precise numerical method. In the frame of the effective Schrodinger-like equation, which is derived exactly from the Bethe-Salpeter equation in quantum electrodynamics, we express the effective potential corresponding to the full one-photon-exchange interaction in terms of eight scalar functions. Unlike the usual calculations performed in the references, where the effective potential is expanded in terms of momenta order by order, we retain the exact momentum dependence in the effective potential to estimate its corrections to the energy spectrum of hydrogen using a highly precise numerical method. We also use the same numerical method to double-check the results in the non-relativistic case to ensure accuracy. We discuss the comparison of the numerical results with those obtained using the usual bound-state perturbative theory. Our calculations suggest that it is possible to accurately account for all the relativistic contributions using this method. It would be interesting to extent these calculations to positronium, muonic hydrogen, and cases involving nuclear structure and radiative corrections.

Nuclear Theory,High Energy Physics - Phenomenology,Atomic Physics
Vacuum Polarization Contribution to Hydrogen and Positronium Energies

A. Yelkhovsky

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.hep-ph/9710377

1997-10-16

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology

Abstract:Relative order \alpha(Z\alpha)^3 shift of the energy levels induced by the vacuum polarization is reexamined for a bound system of two particles with masses m and M. Recent results for hydrogen and for positronium are shown to contain an error due to the inadequate procedure of the infrared divergence handling. Numerically, the correction to the ground state energy constitutes 0.647 kHz for hydrogen and 46.7 kHz for positronium.
Irreducible Three-Loop Vacuum-Polarization Correction in Muonic Bound Systems

G. S. Adkins,U. D. Jentschura

2024-12-23

Abstract:Three-loop electronic vacuum-polarization corrections due to irreducible diagrams are evaluated for two-body muonic ions with nuclear charge numbers 1 <= Z <= 6. The corrections are of order alpha^3 (Zalpha)^2 m_r, where alpha is the fine-structure constant and m_r is the reduced mass. Numerically, the energy corrections are found to be of the same order-of-magnitude as the largest of the order alpha^2 (Zalpha)^6 m_r corrections, and are thus phenomenologically interesting. Our method of calculation eliminates numerical uncertainty encountered in other approaches.

High Energy Physics - Phenomenology,Atomic Physics
Vacuum polarization in molecules II: higher order corrections

D. J. Flynn,I. P. Grant,H. M. Quiney

2024-08-07

Abstract:We outline a general formalism for treating vacuum polarization phenomena within an effective field expansion. The coupling between source charges and virtual fields is examined from the perspectives of electrostatic potentials, induced charge densities and form factors in momentum space. A strategy for the efficient calculation of vacuum polarization potentials is outlined, implemented, and applied towards the construction of fitting potentials that are suitable for molecular electronic structure calculations, which enclose no overall charge by construction. The order $\alpha(Z \alpha)$, $\alpha (Z \alpha)^{3}$ and $\alpha^{2}(Z\alpha)$ effects of a Gaussian nuclear charge on the electron-positron field are applied variationally towards the E119F molecule, as well as the order $\alpha(Z \alpha)$ effects arising from the virtual muon and charged pion fields.

Atomic Physics,Quantum Physics
Vacuum polarization and Wichmann-Kroll correction in the finite basis set approximation

V. K. Ivanov,S. S. Baturin,D. A. Glazov,A. V. Volotka

2024-06-11

Abstract:The finite basis set method is commonly used to calculate atomic spectra, including QED contributions such as bound-electron self-energy. Still, it remains problematic and underexplored for vacuum-polarization calculations. We fill this gap by trying this approach in its application to the calculation of the vacuum-polarization charge density and the Wichmann-Kroll correction to the electron binding energy in a hydrogen-like ion. We study the convergence of the method with different types and sizes of basis sets. We cross-check our results for the Wichmann-Kroll correction by direct integration of the Green's function. As a relevant example, we consider several heavy hydrogen-like ions and evaluate the vacuum polarization correction for $S$ and $P$ electron orbitals.

Atomic Physics,High Energy Physics - Theory,Quantum Physics
Vacuum polarization in molecules I: Uehling interaction

D. J. Flynn,I. P. Grant,H. M. Quiney

2024-08-07

Abstract:Radiative corrections to electronic structure are characterized by perturbative expansions in $\alpha$ and $Z\alpha$, where $\alpha$ is the fine-structure constant and $Z$ is the nuclear charge. A formulation of the leading-order $\alpha(Z\alpha)$ Uehling contribution to the renormalized vacuum polarization is reported in a form that is convenient for implementation in computational studies of the relativistic electronic structures of molecules. Benchmark calculations based on these methods are reported that include the leading-order vacuum polarization effects within relativistic mean-field methods for the E119$^+$ ion and the closed-shell diatomic species E119F.

Atomic Physics,Quantum Physics
Calculating the many-potential vacuum polarization density of the Dirac equation in the finite-basis approximation

Maen Salman,Trond Saue

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.108.012808

2023-04-18

Abstract:In this work, we propose an efficient and accurate computational method to evaluate the many-potential $\alpha\left(Z\alpha\right)^{n\ge3}$ vacuum polarization density of hydrogen-like atoms within the finite-basis approximation of the Dirac equation. To prove the performance of our computational method, we choose to work with the one-electron $_{\,\,\,92}^{238}\text{U}$ atom. In summary, we find that compliance with charge conjugation symmetry is a priori required to obtain physical results that are in line with our knowledge of the analytical problem. We also note that the final numerical results are found to be in excellent agreement with previous formal analytical (and numerical) evaluations that are limited to a few simple nuclear distribution models. Our technique can be efficiently implemented and evaluated in codes that solve the radial Dirac equation in the finite basis set framework and allows the use of arbitrary (radial) nuclear charge distribution. The obtained numerical results of the non-perturbative vacuum polarization density automatically account for the extended nuclear size effect. This method is hence of special importance for atomic Dirac problems whose analytical Green's functions expressions are not at hand or have relatively complicated analytical forms. Furthermore, we propose a vacuum polarization density formula that forces compliance with charge conjugation symmetry and can be used in cases where the relativistic basis violates this symmetry, as is the case in most relativistic basis set programs. In addition, we have shown that vector components of the vacuum polarization four-current vanish in the case where the Dirac Hamiltonian is symmetric under time-reversal symmetry.

Atomic Physics,Quantum Physics
Nuclear structure corrections to the Lamb shift in $μ^3$He$^+$ and $μ^3$H

N. Nevo Dinur,C. Ji,S. Bacca,N. Barnea

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1512.05773

2015-12-17

Nuclear Theory

Abstract:Measuring the 2S-2P Lamb shift in a hydrogen-like muonic atom allows one to extract its nuclear charge radius with a high precision that is limited by the uncertainty in the nuclear structure corrections. The charge radius of the proton thus extracted was found to be 7-sigma away from the CODATA value, in what has become the yet unsolved "proton radius puzzle". Further experiments currently aim at the isotopes of hydrogen and helium: the precise extraction of their radii may provide a hint at the solution of the puzzle. We present the first ab initio calculation of nuclear structure corrections, including the nuclear polarization correction, to the 2S-2P transition in $\mu^3$He$^+$ and $\mu^3$H, and assess solid theoretical error bars. Our predictions reduce the uncertainty in the nuclear structure corrections to the level of a few percents and will be instrumental to the on-going $\mu^3$He$^+$ experiment. We also support the mirror $\mu\,^3$H system as a candidate for further probing of the nucleon polarizabilities and shedding more light on the puzzle.
High‐precision Calculation of Relativistic Corrections for Hydrogen‐like Atoms with Screened Coulomb Potentials

Hui,Li Guang Jiao,Aihua Liu,Yew Kam Ho

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/qua.26653

2021-01-01

International Journal of Quantum Chemistry

Abstract:The first-order relativistic corrections to the non-relativistic energies of hydrogen-like atom embedded in plasma screening environments are calculated in the framework of direct perturbation theory by using the generalized pseudospectral method. The standard Debye-Huckel potential, exponential cosine screened Coulomb potential, and Hulthen potential are employed to model different screening conditions and their effects on the eigenenergies of hydrogen-like atoms are investigated. The relativistic corrections which include the relativistic mass correction, Darwin term, and the spin-orbit coupling term for both the ground and excited states are reported as functions of screening parameters. Comparison with previous theoretical predictions shows that both the relativistic mass correction and spin-orbit coupling obtained in this work are in good agreement with previous estimations, while significant discrepancy and even opposite trend is found for the Darwin term. The overall relativistic-corrected system energies predicted in this work, however, are in good agreement with the fully relativistic calculations available in the literature. We finally present the scaling law of the first-order relativistic corrections and discuss the validity of the direct perturbation theory with respect to both the nuclear charge and the screening parameter.
Relativistic Correction from the Four-Body Nonadiabatic Exponential Wave Function

Krzysztof Pachucki,Jacek Komasa

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1021/acs.jctc.4c00861

2024-09-28

Journal of Chemical Theory and Computation

Abstract:We present a method for calculating the relativistic correction in hydrogen molecules that significantly exceeds the accuracy of all the previous literature results. This method utilizes the explicitly correlated nonadiabatic exponential wave function, and thus treats electrons and nuclei equivalently. The proposed method can be applied to any rovibrational state, including highly excited ones. The numerical precision of the relativistic correction reaches several kHz (∼10^(-7) cm^(-1)), which...

chemistry, physical,physics, atomic, molecular & chemical
Vacuum polarization correction to atomic energy levels in the path integral formalism

Sreya Banerjee,Zoltán Harman

2023-09-25

Abstract:Vacuum polarization corrections to the energy levels of bound electrons are calculated using a perturbative path integral formalism. We apply quantum electrodynamics in a framework which treats the strong binding nuclear field to all orders. The effective potential, derived from the Dyson-Schwinger equation for the photon propagator, is then considered pertubatively. Expressions for the vacuum polarization shift of binding energies is obtained from the poles of the spectral function up to second order. Numerical results are provided to select candidates for novel tests of strong-field quantum electrodynamics by means of precision mass spectrometry.

Atomic Physics,Quantum Physics
Advances in relativistic molecular quantum mechanics

wenjian liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.physrep.2013.11.006

IF: 30.51

2014-01-01

Physics Reports

Abstract:A quantum mechanical equation HΨ=EΨ is composed of three components, viz., Hamiltonian H, wave function Ψ, and property E(λ), each of which is confronted with fundamental issues in the relativistic regime, e.g., (1) What is the most appropriate relativistic many-body Hamiltonian? How to solve the resulting equation? (2) How does the relativistic wave function behave at the coalescence of two electrons? How to do relativistic explicit correlation? (3) How to formulate relativistic properties properly?, to name just a few. It is shown here that the charge-conjugated contraction of Fermion operators, dictated by the charge conjugation symmetry, allows for a bottom-up construction of a relativistic Hamiltonian that is in line with the principles of quantum electrodynamics (QED). Various approximate but accurate forms of the Hamiltonian can be obtained based entirely on physical arguments. In particular, the exact two-component Hamiltonians can be formulated in a general way to cast electric and magnetic fields, as well as electron self-energy and vacuum polarization, into a unified framework. While such algebraic two-component Hamiltonians are incompatible with explicit correlation, four-component relativistic explicitly correlated approaches can indeed be made fully parallel to the nonrelativistic counterparts by virtue of the ‘extended no-pair projection’ and the coalescence conditions. These findings open up new avenues for future developments of relativistic molecular quantum mechanics. In particular, ‘molecular QED’ will soon become an active and exciting field.
Vacuum Polarization Effects in the Hyperfine Splitting of Hydrogen Like Ions

Junis Heiland Hoyo,Bastian Sikora

2024-10-12

Abstract:The hyperfine structure of bound electrons in hydrogen-like ions is considered with corrections to the energy levels due to vacuum polarization (VP). Corrections to the wave function as well as the magnetic potential are determined for both leptonic and hadronic VP. Hadronic VP is treated with a semi-empirical approach. Uncertainties due to the nuclear charge distribution are given and discussed. Point-like, spherical and Fermi distributed nuclear models are considered and the differences of the results are discussed.

Atomic Physics
Polarization in relativistic heavy ion collisions: a theoretical perspective

Francesco Becattini

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1051/epjconf/201817107001

2018-01-01

EPJ Web of Conferences

Abstract:We review the theoretical framework for the calculation of particle polarization in relativistic heavy ion collisions within the hydrodynamical model. The covariant decomposition of the mean spin vector is presented and open theoretical issues addressed.

English Else
Quantum electrodynamic corrections for molecules: Vacuum polarisation and electron self energy in a two-component relativistic framework

Kjell Janke,Andrés Emilio Wedenig,Peter Schwerdtfeger,Konstantin Gaul,Robert Berger

2024-11-13

Abstract:Vacuum polarisation (VP) and electron self energy (SE) are implemented and evaluated as quantum electrodynamic (QED) corrections in a (quasi-relativistic) two-component zeroth order regular approximation (ZORA) framework. For VP, the Uehling potential is considered, and for SE, the effective potentials proposed by Flambaum and Ginges as well as the one proposed by Pyykkö and Zhao. QED contributions to ionisation energies of various atoms and group 2 monofluorides, group 1 and 11 valence orbital energies, $^2\mathrm{P}_{1/2} \leftarrow {}^{2}\mathrm{S}_{1/2}$ and $^{2}\mathrm{P}_{3/2} \leftarrow {}^{2}\mathrm{S}_{1/2}$ transition energies of Li-, Na-, and Cu-like ions of nuclear charge $Z$ = 10, 20, ..., 90 as well as $\Pi_{1/2}\leftarrow \Sigma_{1/2}$ and $\Pi_{3/2}\leftarrow\Sigma_{1/2}$ transition energies of BaF and RaF are presented. Furthermore, perturbative and self-consistent treatments of QED corrections are compared for Kohn--Sham orbital energies of gold. It is demonstrated, that QED corrections can be obtained in a two-component ZORA framework efficiently and in excellent agreement with corresponding four-component results.

Chemical Physics,Atomic Physics

Relativistic corrections to vacuum polarization contributions in muonic hydrogen

Relativistic and Recoil Corrections to Vacuum polarization in muonic systems: Three--photon exchange, gauge invariance and numerical values

Relativistic recoil corrections to the electron-vacuum-polarization contribution in light muonic atoms

Relativistic recoil effects in a muonic atom within a Grotch-type approach: General approach

Reexamination of vacuum-polarization corrections to the self-energy in muonic bound systems

Vacuum polarization corrections to hyperfine structure in many-electron atoms

Relativistic corrections to energy spectrum of hydrogen due to the full one-photon-exchange interaction

Vacuum Polarization Contribution to Hydrogen and Positronium Energies

Irreducible Three-Loop Vacuum-Polarization Correction in Muonic Bound Systems

Vacuum polarization in molecules II: higher order corrections

Vacuum polarization and Wichmann-Kroll correction in the finite basis set approximation

Vacuum polarization in molecules I: Uehling interaction

Calculating the many-potential vacuum polarization density of the Dirac equation in the finite-basis approximation

Nuclear structure corrections to the Lamb shift in $μ^3$He$^+$ and $μ^3$H

High‐precision Calculation of Relativistic Corrections for Hydrogen‐like Atoms with Screened Coulomb Potentials

Relativistic Correction from the Four-Body Nonadiabatic Exponential Wave Function

Vacuum polarization correction to atomic energy levels in the path integral formalism

Advances in relativistic molecular quantum mechanics

Vacuum Polarization Effects in the Hyperfine Splitting of Hydrogen Like Ions

Polarization in relativistic heavy ion collisions: a theoretical perspective

Quantum electrodynamic corrections for molecules: Vacuum polarisation and electron self energy in a two-component relativistic framework