On configuration space, Born's rule and ontological states

Hans-Thomas Elze

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-34234-0_18

2018-02-20

Abstract:It is shown how configuration space, possibly encompassing ordinary spatial structures, Born's rule, and ontological states aiming to address an underlying reality beyond Quantum Mechanics relate to each other in models of Hamiltonian cellular automata.

Quantum Physics,History and Philosophy of Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Cellular automaton ontology, bits, qubits, and the Dirac equation

Hans-Thomas Elze

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1142/S0219749924500138

2024-02-15

Abstract:Cornerstones of the Cellular Automaton Interpretation of Quantum Mechanics are its ontological states that evolve by permutations, in this way never creating would-be quantum mechanical superposition states. We review and illustrate this with a classical Ising spin chain. It is shown that it can be related to the Weyl equation in the continuum limit. Yet, the model of discrete spins or bits unavoidably becomes a model of qubits by generating superpositions, if only slightly deformed. We study modifications of its signal velocity which, however, do not relate to mass terms. To incorporate the latter, we consider the Dirac equation in 1+1 dimensions and sketch an underlying discrete deterministic "necklace of necklaces" automaton that qualifies as ontological.

Quantum Physics,Cellular Automata and Lattice Gases,History and Philosophy of Physics
Ontological States in Non-Interacting Quantum Field Theories

Marcel van Kessel

2024-07-17

Abstract:This is a paper in the field of ontological deterministic theories behind Quantum Field Theories, like for example the cellular automaton theories proposed by 't Hooft. In these theories one has ontological states in which the state of reality is exactly known and no uncertainties are present. Also these states evolve in time deterministically. A first step in finding the ontological deterministic theory behind the Standard Model is to find in Quantum Field Theory the states that behave as ontological states. We present the ontological states for all non-interacting (3+1-dimensional) Quantum Field Theories occurring in the Standard Model. We summarize the ontological states for free scalar bosons and for free masless Dirac fermions, which are known from the literature. We construct the ontological states for vector bosons, in analogy to the scalar boson case. With this we have a set of ontological states for all particles that are known to occur in reality and in the Standard Model.

Quantum Physics,High Energy Physics - Theory
The magical "Born Rule" & quantum "measurement": Implications for Physics

Johan Hansson

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/foundations3040038

2023-10-02

Abstract:I. The arena of quantum mechanics and quantum field theory is the abstract, unobserved and unobservable, M-dimensional formal Hilbert space [not equal to] spacetime. II. The arena of observations and, more generally, of all events (i.e. everything) in the real physical world, is the classical 4-dimensional physical spacetime. III. The "Born Rule" is the random process "magically" transforming I. into II. Wavefunctions are superposed and entangled only in the abstract space I., never in spacetime II. Attempted formulations of quantum theory directly in real physical spacetime actually constitute examples of "locally real" theories, as defined by Clauser & Horne, and are therefore already empirically refuted by the numerous tests of Bell's theorem in real, controlled experiments in laboratories here on Earth. Observed quantum entities, i.e. events, are never superposed or entangled as they: 1) Exclusively "live" (manifest) in real physical spacetime, 2) Are not described by entangled wavefunctions after "measurement", effectuated by III. When separated and treated correctly in this way, a number of fundamental problems and "paradoxes" of quantum theory vs. relativity (i.e. spacetime) simply vanish, such as the black hole information paradox, infinite zero-point energy of quantum field theory and quantization of general relativity.

General Physics
Quantum Mechanics With Noncommutative Amplitudes

Gregory W. Moore

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1701.07746

2017-01-26

High Energy Physics - Theory

Abstract:We formulate a Born rule for families of quantum systems parametrized by a noncommutative space of control parameters. The resulting formalism may be viewed as a generalization of quantum mechanics where overlaps take values in a noncommutative algebra, rather than in the complex numbers.
Quantum Probability and the Born Ensemble

Themis Matsoukas

2023-09-16

Abstract:We formulate a discrete two-state stochastic process with elementary rules that give rise to Born statistics and reproduce the probabilities from the Schrödinger equation under an associated Hamiltonian matrix, which we identify. We define the probability to observe a state, classical or quantum, in proportion to the number of \textit{events} at that state--number of ways a walker may materialize at a point of observation at time t through a sequence of transitions starting from known initial state at t=0. The quantum stochastic process differs from its classical counterpart in that the quantum walker is a pair of qubits, each transmitted independently through all possible paths to a point of observation, and whose recombination may produce a positive or negative event (classical events are never negative). We represent the state of the walker via a square matrix of recombination events, show that the indeterminacy of the qubit state amounts to rotations of this matrix, and show that the Born rule counts the number qubits on this matrix that remain invariant over a full rotation.

Quantum Physics
Quantumness of discrete Hamiltonian cellular automata

Hans-Thomas Elze

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1051/epjconf/20147802005

2014-07-09

Abstract:We summarize a recent study of discrete (integer-valued) Hamiltonian cellular automata (CA) showing that their dynamics can only be consistently defined, if it is linear in the same sense as unitary evolution described by the Schrödinger equation. This allows to construct an invertible map between such CA and continuous quantum mechanical models, which incorporate a fundamental scale. Presently, we emphasize general aspects of these findings, the construction of admissible CA observables, and the existence of solutions of the modified dispersion relation for stationary states.

Quantum Physics,General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,Mathematical Physics
From Abstract Entities in Mathematics to Superposition States in Quantum Mechanics

David Ellerman

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1701.07936

2017-01-27

Quantum Physics

Abstract:Given an equivalence relation ~ on a set U, there are two abstract notions of an element of the quotient set U/~. The #1 abstract notion is a set S=[u] of equivalent elements of U (an equivalence class); the #2 notion is an abstract entity u_{S} that is definite on what is common to the elements of the equivalence class S but is otherwise indefinite on the differences between those elements. For instance, the #1 interpretation of a homotopy type is an equivalence class of homotopic spaces, but the #2 interpretation, e.g., as developed in homotopy type theory, is an abstract space (without points) that has the properties that are in common to the spaces in the equivalence class but is otherwise indefinite. In philosophy, the #2 abstract entities might be called paradigm-universals, e.g., `the white thing' as opposed to the #1 abstract notion of "the set of white things" (out of some given collection U). The paper shows how this #2 notion of a paradigm may be mathematically modeled using incidence matrices in Boolean logic and density matrices in probability theory. Then we cross the bridge to the density matrix treatment of the indefinite superposition states in quantum mechanics (QM). This connection between the #2 abstracts in mathematics and ontic indefinite states in QM elucidates Abner Shimony's literal or objective indefiniteness interpretation of QM.
Noncommutativity in Configuration Space Induced by A Conjugate Magnetic Field in Phase Space

Jan Govaerts

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/math12020180

2024-01-08

Abstract:As is well known, an external magnetic field in configuration space coupled to a quantum dynamics induces noncommutativity in its velocity momentum space. By phase space duality, an external vector potential in the conjugate momentum sector of the system induces noncommutativity in its configuration space. Such a rationale for noncommutativity is explored herein for an arbitrary configuration space of Euclidean geometry. Ordinary quantum mechanics with a commutative configuration space is revisited first. Through the introduction of an arbitrary positive definite $*$-product, a one-to-one correspondence between the Hilbert space of abstract quantum states and that of the enveloping algebra of the position quantum operators is identified. A parallel discussion is then presented when configuration space is noncommutative, and thoroughly analysed when the conjugate magnetic field is momentum independent and nondegenerate. Once again the space of quantum states may be identified with the enveloping algebra of the noncommutative position quantum operators. Furthermore when the positive definite $*$-product is chosen in accordance with the value of the conjugate magnetic field which determines the commutator algebra of the coordinate operators, these operators span a Fock algebra of which the canonical coherent states are the localised noncommutative quantum analogues of the sharp and structureless local points of the associated commutative configuration space geometry. These results generalise and justify a posteriori within the context of ordinary canonical quantisation the heuristic approach to quantum mechanics in the noncommutative Euclidean plane as constructed and developed by F. G. Scholtz and his collaborators.

Quantum Physics,High Energy Physics - Theory
A Quantum-Bayesian Route to Quantum-State Space

Christopher A. Fuchs,Ruediger Schack

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10701-009-9404-8

2009-12-22

Abstract:In the quantum-Bayesian approach to quantum foundations, a quantum state is viewed as an expression of an agent's personalist Bayesian degrees of belief, or probabilities, concerning the results of measurements. These probabilities obey the usual probability rules as required by Dutch-book coherence, but quantum mechanics imposes additional constraints upon them. In this paper, we explore the question of deriving the structure of quantum-state space from a set of assumptions in the spirit of quantum Bayesianism. The starting point is the representation of quantum states induced by a symmetric informationally complete measurement or SIC. In this representation, the Born rule takes the form of a particularly simple modification of the law of total probability. We show how to derive key features of quantum-state space from (i) the requirement that the Born rule arises as a simple modification of the law of total probability and (ii) a limited number of additional assumptions of a strong Bayesian flavor.

Quantum Physics
A Theory of Quantum Observation and the Emergence of the Born Rule

Andreas O. Tell

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1205.0293

2012-05-02

Quantum Physics

Abstract:A realist description of our universe requires a twofold concept of locality. On one hand, there are the strictly Einstein-local interactions which generate the time evolution. On the other hand, the quantum state space calls for a non-local description of multi-particle states. This article uses a behavioristic approach to argue, that an observer in a universe like this has to rely on local interactions to learn about its properties and behavior. Such an observer is fundamentally restricted in his ability to understand and structurally reconstruct the individual local physical universe. We argue, that this reconstruction based on dynamically available information is the defining process of observation in quantum theory. The observer-centric view of the global quantum dynamics is shown to be non-unitary and non-linear in general, even if the universe itself evolves unitarily. Interactions with massless free particles are found to have great influence on observation, because of their special role in the light-cone structure of an Einstein-local universe. For a specific scattering process with a photon of unknown state, the observed outcome can be subjectively random and follow the Born statistic, while the output state is really determined by the photon polarization. Based on this result, a theory of quantum measurement is formulated, which describes a measurement device as a cascade of scattering events.
On the way to Frölicher bornology

Ben Moditi Mahudu,Mukinayi Hermenegilde Tshilombo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2989/16073606.2024.2320441

2024-03-07

Quaestiones Mathematicae

Abstract:In this work we introduce the concept of bornology on the theory of Frölicher spaces. A canonical bornology, called the functional bornology, is induced from structure functions, and bounded maps under this bornology are determined. Based on the structure of structure curves, we deduce that we cannot induce, canonically, a bornology from structure curves. For each of Frölicher subspace and product, an initial and functional bornology are induced and compared. Similarly, for each of Frölicher quotient and coproduct, a final and functional bornology are induced and compared.

mathematics
Is the Born Rule Anthropically Determined?

Michael B. Weissman

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1403.7119

2014-03-28

Abstract:I argue that various derivations of the Born probability rule within strictly unitary quantum mechanics implicitly use anthropic constraints on the properties of the probabilities, but without proposing an ensemble from which those constraints limit a selection. An argument by Mallah obtains the Born probabilities explicitly for standard unitary dynamics but via postulating a hypothetical extra noise-like component of the quantum state. I argue that the implicit anthropic constraints required for well-behaved probability rules would select for a state of the sort Mallah proposes.

Quantum Physics
Cellular automata and Kan extensions

Alexandre Fernandez,Luidnel Maignan,Antoine Spicher

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11047-022-09931-0

2023-01-28

Natural Computing

Abstract:In this paper, we formalize precisely the sense in which the application of a cellular automaton to partial configurations is a natural extension of its local transition function through the categorical notion of Kan extension. In fact, the two possible ways to do such an extension and the ingredients involved in their definition are related through Kan extensions in many ways. These relations provide additional links between computer science and category theory, and also give a new point of view on the famous Curtis–Hedlund theorem of cellular automata from the extended topological point of view provided by category theory. These links also allow to relatively easily generalize concepts pioneered by cellular automata to arbitrary kinds of possibly evolving spaces. No prior knowledge of category theory is assumed for the most part.

computer science, artificial intelligence, theory & methods
Born's rule from epistemic assumptions

Per Östborn

2024-11-03

Abstract:Born's rule is the recipe for calculating probabilities from quantum mechanical amplitudes. There is no generally accepted derivation of Born's rule from first principles. In this paper, it is motivated from assumptions that link the ontological content of a proper physical model to the epistemic conditions of the experimental context. More precisely, it is assumed that all knowable distinctions should correspond to distinctions in a proper model. This principle of "ontological completeness" means, for example, that the probabilistic treatment of the double slit experiment with and without path information should differ. Further, it is assumed that the model should rely only on knowable ontological elements, and that failure to fulfill this principle of "ontological minimalism" gives rise to wrong predictions. Consequently, probabilities should be assigned only to observable experimental outcomes. Also, the method to calculate such probabilities should not rely on the existence of a precise path of the observed object if this path is not knowable. A similar principle was promoted by Born, even though he did not apply it to probability. Another crucial assumption is that the proper rule to calculate probabilities should be generally valid. It should be applicable in all experimental contexts, regardless the setup that determines which attributes of the studied object are observed, together with the probability to observe each of the associated attribute values. There is no need to refer to the Hilbert space structure of quantum mechanics in the present treatment. Rather, some elements of this structure emerge from the analysis.

Quantum Physics,History and Philosophy of Physics
The Born rule in a timeless universe

Ovidiu Racorean

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2203.07074

2022-09-13

Abstract:In canonical quantization of gravity the wave function of the universe is CPT invariant. Thus, if the quantum state of the universe contains a particular history, than it must contain, with the same probability, the time-reversed image of that history as well. In this work, we investigate the meaning of this statement in the context of the conditional probability interpretation of Page and Wootters. Accordingly, we show that a time-reversed history of the universe is consistent with the Page and Wootters mechanism and we derive a time-reversed Schrodinger equation for the evolution of the rest of the universe. Since the same particular quantum state is acquired both in an individual history with time running forward and in its time-reversed image history, we demonstrate that conditioning the state of the universe on the hands of the clock showing a specific time results in the probability of finding the rest of the universe system in a particular state. In this scenario, we conjecture that probability interpretation is an emergent property of the quantum world.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology
Ontological models and the interpretation of contextuality

Nicholas Harrigan,Terry Rudolph

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.0709.4266

2007-09-27

Abstract:Studying the extent to which realism is compatible with quantum mechanics teaches us something about the quantum mechanical universe, regardless of the validity of such realistic assumptions. It has also recently been appreciated that these kinds of studies are fruitful for questions relating to quantum information and computation. Motivated by this, we extend the ontological model formalism for realistic theories to describe a set of theories emphasizing the role of measurement and preparation devices by introducing `hidden variables' to describe them. We illustrate both the ontological model formalism and our generalization of it through a series of example models taken from the literature. Our extension of the formalism allows us to quantitatively analyze the meaning contextuality (a constraint on successful realistic theories), finding that - taken at face-value - it can be realized as a natural interaction between the configurations of a system and measurement device. However, we also describe a property that we call deficiency, which follows from contextuality, but does not admit such a natural interpretation. Loosely speaking, deficiency breaks a symmetry between preparations and measurements in quantum mechanics. It is the property that the set of ontic states which a system prepared in quantum state psi may actually be in, is strictly smaller than the set of ontic states which would reveal the measurement outcome psi with certainty.

Quantum Physics
Quantum Histories and Their Implications

Adrian Kent

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.gr-qc/9607073

2000-05-24

Abstract:Classical mechanics and standard Copenhagen quantum mechanics respect subspace implications. For example, if a particle is confined in a particular region $R$ of space, then in these theories we can deduce that it is confined in regions containing $R$. However, subspace implications are generally violated by versions of quantum theory that assign probabilities to histories, such as the consistent histories approach. I define here a new criterion, ordered consistency, which refines the criterion of consistency and has the property that inferences made by ordered consistent sets do not violate subspace relations. This raises the question: do the operators defining our observations form an ordered consistent history? If so, ordered consistency defines a version of quantum theory with greater predictive power than the consistent histories formalism. If not, and our observations are defined by a non-ordered consistent quantum history, then subspace implications are not generally valid.

General Relativity and Quantum Cosmology,Quantum Physics
A Geometric Substructure for Quantum Dynamics

Anthony John Bracken

2024-11-13

Abstract:The description of a closed quantum system is extended with the identification of an underlying substructure in which an expanded formulation of dynamics in the Heisenberg picture is given. Between measurements a ``state point" moves in an underlying multi-dimensional complex, projective space with constant velocity determined by the quantum state vector. Following a measurement, the point changes direction and moves with new constant velocity along one of several possible new orthogonal paths, with probabilities determined by Born's Rule. A possible generalization to a Riemannian substructure is speculated upon, suggesting an unexpected interaction with the background gravitational field.

Quantum Physics
A structure theorem for generalized-noncontextual ontological models

David Schmid,John H. Selby,Matthew F. Pusey,Robert W. Spekkens

DOI: https://doi.org/10.22331/q-2024-03-14-1283

2024-03-15

Quantum

Abstract:Quantum 8, 1283 (2024). https://doi.org/10.22331/q-2024-03-14-1283 It is useful to have a criterion for when the predictions of an operational theory should be considered classically explainable. Here we take the criterion to be that the theory admits of a generalized-noncontextual ontological model. Existing works on generalized noncontextuality have focused on experimental scenarios having a simple structure: typically, prepare-measure scenarios. Here, we formally extend the framework of ontological models as well as the principle of generalized noncontextuality to arbitrary compositional scenarios. We leverage a process-theoretic framework to prove that, under some reasonable assumptions, every generalized-noncontextual ontological model of a tomographically local operational theory has a surprisingly rigid and simple mathematical structure — in short, it corresponds to a frame representation which is not overcomplete. One consequence of this theorem is that the largest number of ontic states possible in any such model is given by the dimension of the associated generalized probabilistic theory. This constraint is useful for generating noncontextuality no-go theorems as well as techniques for experimentally certifying contextuality. Along the way, we extend known results concerning the equivalence of different notions of classicality from prepare-measure scenarios to arbitrary compositional scenarios. Specifically, we prove a correspondence between the following three notions of classical explainability of an operational theory: (i) existence of a noncontextual ontological model for it, (ii) existence of a positive quasiprobability representation for the generalized probabilistic theory it defines, and (iii) existence of an ontological model for the generalized probabilistic theory it defines.

physics, multidisciplinary,quantum science & technology

On configuration space, Born's rule and ontological states

Cellular automaton ontology, bits, qubits, and the Dirac equation

Ontological States in Non-Interacting Quantum Field Theories

The magical "Born Rule" & quantum "measurement": Implications for Physics

Quantum Mechanics With Noncommutative Amplitudes

Quantum Probability and the Born Ensemble

Quantumness of discrete Hamiltonian cellular automata

From Abstract Entities in Mathematics to Superposition States in Quantum Mechanics

Noncommutativity in Configuration Space Induced by A Conjugate Magnetic Field in Phase Space

A Quantum-Bayesian Route to Quantum-State Space

A Theory of Quantum Observation and the Emergence of the Born Rule

On the way to Frölicher bornology

Is the Born Rule Anthropically Determined?

Cellular automata and Kan extensions

Born's rule from epistemic assumptions

The Born rule in a timeless universe

Ontological models and the interpretation of contextuality

Quantum Histories and Their Implications

A Geometric Substructure for Quantum Dynamics

A structure theorem for generalized-noncontextual ontological models