Abstract:We initiate a study of the dependence on the choice of ground ring on the question of whether a cluster algebra is equal to its upper cluster algebra. A condition for when there is equality of the cluster algebra and upper cluster algebra is given by using a variation of Muller's theory of cluster localization. An explicit example exhibiting dependence on the ground ring is provided. We also present a maximal green sequence for this example.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore whether the cluster algebra is equal to its upper cluster algebra under different choices of the ground ring. Specifically, by studying the influence of different ground rings on the equality between the cluster algebra and the upper cluster algebra, the paper reveals the sensitivity of this property to the choice of the ground ring. In the paper, through a specific example - the Cremmer - Gervais cluster structure, it shows how different choices of the ground ring lead to changes in the relationship between the cluster algebra and the upper cluster algebra.
### Overview of the main content of the paper:
1. **Background introduction**:
- Cluster algebras were proposed by Fomin and Zelevinsky to study the total positivity of Lusztig's canonical basis.
- Cluster algebras study infinite - dimensional algebras through generating seeds, and the transformation between seeds is called mutation.
- The upper cluster algebra is the intersection of Laurent polynomial rings corresponding to all seeds. Due to the Laurent phenomenon, the cluster algebra is always contained in the upper cluster algebra ($A\subseteq U$).
- When $A = U$, this equality can provide more algebraic and geometric information about the cluster algebra.
2. **Main research content**:
- Explore the influence of different ground ring choices on the property of $A = U$.
- Through Muller's theory of locally acyclic cluster algebras, a condition is given such that in some cases $A = U$.
- Provide a specific example to show the behavioral differences of the Cremmer - Gervais cluster structure under different ground rings.
3. **Specific example**:
- Through the Cremmer - Gervais cluster structure, show how the relationship between the cluster algebra and the upper cluster algebra changes under different choices of the ground ring.
- Specifically, when the ground ring is $\mathbb{ZP}$, the cluster algebra is equal to the upper cluster algebra ($A_{\mathbb{ZP}}(CG,3)=U_{\mathbb{ZP}}(CG,3)$), but when the ground ring is $\mathbb{ZP}^+$, the cluster algebra is strictly contained in the upper cluster algebra ($A_{\mathbb{ZP}^+}(CG,3)\subsetneq U_{\mathbb{ZP}^+}(CG,3)$).
4. **Conclusion and outlook**:
- The paper shows the significant influence of the choice of the ground ring on the equality between the cluster algebra and the upper cluster algebra.
- Propose directions for further research, including finding sufficient conditions for more general ground rings and developing versions of the Banff algorithm applicable to different ground rings.
### Key formulas and concepts:
- **Laurent phenomenon**:
\[
A\subseteq \mathbb{ZP}[x_1^{\pm 1},x_2^{\pm 1},\ldots,x_n^{\pm 1}]
\]
- **Upper cluster algebra**:
\[
U = \bigcap_{x\in A}\mathbb{ZP}[x_1^{\pm 1},x_2^{\pm 1},\ldots,x_n^{\pm 1}]
\]
- **Mutation rule**:
\[
x_k'=\frac{y_k\prod_{B_{jk}>0}x_j^{B_{jk}}+\prod_{B_{jk}<0}x_j^{-B_{jk}}}{(y_k\oplus 1)x_k}
\]
Through these formulas and concepts, the paper deeply explores the influence of the choice of the ground ring on the relationship between the cluster algebra and the upper cluster algebra.