Abstract:Purpose The authors examine whether reports of internal control weaknesses (ICWs) under federal single audit (FSA) guidelines are a useful tool for evaluating non-profit (NP) management, using a unique nationwide sample of NP charter schools. While prior research focuses on external stakeholder reactions to reported ICWs, little if any research addresses the utility of these reports for internal users. The authors fill this gap in the literature, finding evidence suggesting that NP charter school decision-makers use internal control (IC) reports when setting executive compensation – awarding lower pay increases when deficiencies are reported. Design/methodology/approach The authors regress executive compensation changes on reported ICWs and likely determinants of NP compensation, including organization size, growth, liquidity and management performance, using a sample of 173 school/year observations representing 113 unique schools for the years 2012–2015. Findings The authors find a negative relationship with executive pay increases subsequent to reports of initial and repeated IC deficiencies, indicating that lower than average pay increases are awarded subsequent to reports of ICWs. Research limitations/implications Interpretation of the authors' results is subject to several limitations, including the possibility of omitted variable bias and the authors' sample, though it comprises all available data for the sample period, and is relatively small and may be considered exploratory in nature. Further, charter schools represent a unique public/private partnership in the educational sector, and the results may not be generalizable to other NPs. Future research could explore the relationship between reported IC deficiencies and governance in other, broader NP sectors. Practical implications The authors' findings are useful to NP organization boards of directors as they consider what factors to evaluate in their chief executive officer (CEO) compensation decisions. In addition to other criteria, inclusion of IC effectiveness in the CEO reward system is prudent, especially in today's environment of increasingly important information security and IC matters. The results suggest such information is being included. This previously undocumented use is also of particular value to regulators when weighing the costs and benefits of mandating single audits for smaller NPs, who are otherwise unlikely to obtain information on the organization's IC environment. Social implications These findings may help inform the debate regarding NP charter schools, a fast-growing, economically significant and highly controversial sector in public education. Charters are predominantly funded by state and local taxes. As such, the quality of governance in NP charter schools is of interest to a wide range of stakeholders including parents, regulators and the public at large. Originality/value While prior research on ICWs and NPs focuses on external stakeholder reactions to reported ICWs, little if any research addresses the utility of these reports for internal users, especially in relatively smaller organizations. The research leverages the existence of charter schools, which are independent but present nationwide, providing a suitable sample of like organizations. Further, no extant research to the authors' knowledge examines the relationship of NP executive compensation and reported ICWs – a topic previously addressed in the for-profit (FP) literature.

Determinants and consequences of internal audit functions within colleges and universities

The Impact of Domain-Specific Internal Audit Education on Financial Reporting Quality and External Audit Efficiency

Internal Audit Competency Changes in Response to Financial Reporting Quality Failures

Internal audit: A case study of impact and quality of an internal control audit

Internal audit stigma impairs internal audit outcomes

Factors associated with the adoption of data analytics by internal audit function

Internal Audit Effectiveness Antecedents In Higher Education: Do Competency And Time Budget Pressure Matter?

Designing a Characteristics Effectiveness Model for Internal Audit

Internal audit quality and resistance to pressure

Are federal single audit reports of internal control weaknesses a useful tool for evaluating management? The case of charter schools

IN SEARCH OF A MEASURE OF EFFECTIVENESS FOR INTERNAL AUDIT FUNCTIONS: AN INSTITUTIONAL PERSPECTIVE

The Association between Internal Audit Operations-Related Services and Firm Operating Performance

The Failure of Internal Audit: Monitoring Gaps and a Case for a New Focus

Audit Committees and Internal Control Quality: Evidence from Nonprofit Hospitals Subject to the Single Audit Act

Internal audit: from effectiveness to organizational significance

Audit committee effectiveness, internal audit function and sustainability reporting practices

FACTORS AFFECTING THE EFFECTIVENESS OF INTERNAL AUDIT

Former Audit Partners on the Audit Committee and Internal Control Deficiencies

Antecedents and Internal Audit Quality Implications of Internal Audit Effectiveness

Internal control in accounting research: A review

Driving and Inhibiting Factors for Implementing Audit Analytics in an Internal Audit Function