Abstract:Overdispersion due to a large proportion of zero observations in data sets is a common occurrence in many applications of many fields of research; we consider such scenarios in count panel (longitudinal) data. A well-known and widely implemented technique for handling such data is that of random effects modeling, which addresses the serial correlation inherent in panel data, as well as overdispersion. To deal with the excess zeros, a zero-inflated Poisson distribution has come to be canonical, which relaxes the equal mean-variance specification of a traditional Poisson model and allows for the larger variance characteristic of overdispersed data. A natural proposal then to approach count panel data with overdispersion due to excess zeros is to combine these two methodologies, deriving a likelihood from the resulting conditional probability. In performing simulation studies, we find that this approach in fact poses problems of identifiability. In this article, we construct and explain in full detail why a model obtained from the marriage of two classical and well-established techniques is unidentifiable and provide results of simulation studies demonstrating this effect. A discussion on alternative methodologies to resolve the problem is provided in the conclusion.

On Stochastic Representations of the Zero–One-Inflated Poisson Lindley Distribution

Zero to k Inflated Poisson Regression Models with Applications

The Zero-inflated Negative Binomial-Exponential Distribution and Its Application

Zero-Truncated Negative Binomial Weighted-Lindley Distribution and Its Application

Random Effects Modeling and the Zero-Inflated Poisson Distribution

The Positive Negative Binomial-Lindley Distribution and Its Applications

Zero-inflated non-central negative binomial distribution

Time series regression models for zero-inflated proportions

An alternative representation of the negative binomial-Lindley distribution. New results and applications

Zero truncated Poisson model: an alternative approach for analyzing count data with excess zeros

Compound zero-truncated Poisson normal distribution and its applications

A New Zero–Inflated Regression Model with Applications to Australian Health Survey and Biochemistry Graduate Students Data

Multiple arbitrarily inflated Poisson regression analysis

ASYMPTOTIC PROPERTIES IN THE PROBIT-ZERO-INFLATED BINOMIAL REGRESSION MODEL

Inferential properties with a novel two parameter Poisson generalized Lindley distribution with regression and application to INAR(1) process

Quasi-negative binomial distribution: Properties and applications

A new infinitely divisible discrete distribution with applications to count data modeling

The Zero-Inflated Poisson - Probit regression model: a new model for count data

The Binomial–Natural Discrete Lindley Distribution: Properties and Application to Count Data

Exponential Dispersion Models for Overdispersed Zero-Inflated Count Data

Estimation of Population Size Based on One-Inflated, Zero-Truncated Count Distribution with Covariate Information