Abstract:Background: Two characteristics of commonly used outcomes in medical research are zero inflation and non-negative integers; examples include the number of hospital admissions or emergency department visits, where the majority of patients will have zero counts. Zero-inflated regression models were devised to analyze this type of data. However, the performance of zero-inflated regression models or the properties of data best suited for these analyses have not been thoroughly investigated. Methods: We conducted a simulation study to evaluate the performance of two generalized linear models, negative binomial and zero-inflated negative binomial, for analyzing zero-inflated count data. Simulation scenarios assumed a randomized controlled trial design and varied the true underlying distribution, sample size, and rate of zero inflation. We compared the models in terms of bias, mean squared error, and coverage. Additionally, we used logistic regression to determine which data properties are most important for predicting the best-fitting model. Results: We first found that, regardless of the rate of zero inflation, there was little difference between the conventional negative binomial and its zero-inflated counterpart in terms of bias of the marginal treatment group coefficient. Second, even when the outcome was simulated from a zero-inflated distribution, a negative binomial model was favored above its ZI counterpart in terms of the Akaike Information Criterion. Third, the mean and skewness of the non-zero part of the data were stronger predictors of model preference than the percentage of zero counts. These results were not affected by the sample size, which ranged from 60 to 800. Conclusions: We recommend that the rate of zero inflation and overdispersion in the outcome should not be the sole and main justification for choosing zero-inflated regression models. Investigators should also consider other data characteristics when choosing a model for count data. In addition, if the performance of the NB and ZINB regression models is reasonably comparable even with ZI outcomes, we advocate the use of the NB regression model due to its clear and straightforward interpretation of the results.

Zero truncated Poisson model: an alternative approach for analyzing count data with excess zeros

The Zero-Inflated Poisson - Probit regression model: a new model for count data

A simulation study of the performance of statistical models for count outcomes with excessive zeros

Random Effects Modeling and the Zero-Inflated Poisson Distribution

Statistical model for overdispersed count outcome with many zeros: an approach for direct marginal inference

A New Regression Model for the Analysis of Overdispersed and Zero-Modified Count Data

Modeling Zero-inflated Count Data Using Generalized Poisson and Ordinal Logistic Regression Models in Medical Research

Detecting overdispersion in count data: A zero-inflated Poisson regression analysis

A comparison of statistical methods for modeling count data with an application to hospital length of stay

Zero to k Inflated Poisson Regression Models with Applications

A Comparative Study of Several Models for Zero Inflation Counting Data

A New Zero–Inflated Regression Model with Applications to Australian Health Survey and Biochemistry Graduate Students Data

Predicting the multivariate zero‐inflated counts: A novel model averaging method under Pearson loss

Network analysis for count data with excess zeros

Zero-inflacted Poisson regression, with an application to defects in manufacturing

ASYMPTOTIC PROPERTIES IN THE PROBIT-ZERO-INFLATED BINOMIAL REGRESSION MODEL

Compound zero-truncated Poisson normal distribution and its applications

Evaluation of negative binomial and zero-inflated negative binomial models for the analysis of zero-inflated count data: application to the telemedicine for children with medical complexity trial

The Zero-inflated Negative Binomial-Exponential Distribution and Its Application

Random effects compound Poisson model to represent data with extra zeros

The consequences of checking for zero-inflation and overdispersion in the analysis of count data