(Un)predictability of strong El Niño events

John Guckenheimer,Axel Timmermann,Henk Dijkstra,Andrew Roberts

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1710.03216

2017-10-10

Abstract:The El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) is a mode of interannual variability in the coupled equatorial Pacific coupled atmosphere/ocean system. El Niño describes a state in which sea surface temperatures in the eastern Pacific increase and upwelling of colder, deep waters diminishes. El Niño events typically peak in boreal winter, but their strength varies irregularly on decadal time scales. There were exceptionally strong El Niño events in 1982-83, 1997-98 and 2015-16 that affected weather on a global scale. Widely publicized forecasts in 2014 predicted that the 2015-16 event would occur a year earlier. Predicting the strength of El Niño is a matter of practical concern due to its effects on hydroclimate and agriculture around the world. This paper discusses the frequency and regularity of strong El Niño events in the context of chaotic dynamical systems. We discover a mechanism that limits their predictability in a conceptual "recharge oscillator" model of ENSO. Weak seasonal forcing or noise in this model can induce irregular switching between an oscillatory state that has strong El Niño events and a chaotic state that lacks strong events, In this regime, the timing of strong El Niño events on decadal time scales is unpredictable.

Dynamical Systems,Chaotic Dynamics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to explore the frequency and regularity of strong El Niño events and study the limits of their predictability within the framework of chaotic dynamical systems. Specifically, the paper focuses on the following points:

1. **The unpredictability of strong El Niño events**: The El Niño - Southern Oscillation (ENSO) is an inter - annual variability pattern of the equatorial Pacific ocean - atmosphere coupled system. The occurrence of strong El Niño events is highly irregular, and their intensities are erratic on a decadal scale. The paper points out that, despite extensive forecasts, the forecasts in 2014 failed to accurately predict the strong El Niño event in 2015 - 16, indicating significant difficulties in predicting strong El Niño events.

2. **Mechanisms in the low - dimensional conceptual model**: The paper uses a low - dimensional conceptual model - the Jin - Timmermann (JT) model - to study the predictability of strong El Niño events. By describing the changes in the sea - surface temperature differences between the eastern and western equatorial Pacific, the sea - surface temperature in the western equatorial Pacific, and the thermocline depth in the western equatorial Pacific, this model reveals a new dynamical mechanism that limits the predictability of strong El Niño events.

3. **Multi - time - scale analysis**: Through multi - time - scale analysis of the JT model, the paper finds that weak seasonal forcing or noise can induce the model to switch irregularly between oscillatory and chaotic states. In this state, the occurrence time of strong El Niño events on a decadal scale is unpredictable.

4. **Properties of attractors**: The paper analyzes in detail different types of attractors in the JT model, especially those that include strong El Niño events. Through bifurcation analysis, the paper finds that these attractors exhibit mixed - mode oscillations (MMO) and chaotic behavior within certain parameter ranges. The basins of initial conditions of these attractors are highly intertwined, so that a small - amplitude perturbation can cause a switch from one attractor to another.

5. **Mode switching and unpredictability**: The paper further explores the mechanisms of mode switching, especially how the boundary - crisis bifurcations between attractors affect the dynamical behavior of the system when parameters change. By calculating the finite - time Lyapunov exponent (FTLE), the paper shows the high sensitivity of the system to initial conditions, which is one of the key factors leading to the unpredictability of strong El Niño events.

In summary, the problem that this paper attempts to solve is: **How to understand the unpredictability of strong El Niño events and the dynamical mechanisms behind it**. Through the low - dimensional conceptual model and multi - time - scale analysis, the paper reveals the unpredictability of strong El Niño events on a decadal scale and proposes a new dynamical mechanism to explain this phenomenon.