Spatial and historical determinants of separatism and integration. 1. Qualitative analysis

Bertrand M. Roehner

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1707.06796

2017-07-21

Abstract:Separatism is examined in a long-run perspective. Accordingly, many political or economic factors which may be crucial in dealing with short-term episodes can be safely disregarded. Extending an approach pioneered by J. Jenkins, the paper assesses the role of spatial and historical factors. It shows that the means used to stage a separatist struggle are to a notable extent borrowed from former historical episodes, an analysis which supports and illustrates Charles Tilly's thesis of restricted repertoires of action. The purpose of the present paper is to introduce the model, to make it plausible and to demonstrate its potential usefulness by examining a number of critical examples. A more systematic analysis is carried out in a follow-up paper by using a data set that includes about 40 cases of separatist struggles.

Physics and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The main problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore the long - term spatial and historical determinants of separatist movements. Specifically, the author Bertrand M. Roehner aims to explain, by introducing a model, why certain regions or groups maintain their distinct identities (such as language, culture, etc.) over a long period, while other regions gradually integrate into larger countries or societies. This study pays particular attention to how geographical and historical factors influence these separatist tendencies and attempts to verify the validity of this model through empirical data.

### Core issues of the paper

1. **Separatism from a long - term perspective**: The author emphasizes analyzing separatism from a long - term perspective rather than just focusing on short - term political or economic factors. He believes that many political or economic factors, although they may be very important in the short term, can be negligible in the long term.

2. **The role of spatial and historical factors**: The paper points out that the methods adopted in separatist struggles draw heavily on past historical events, which support and illustrate Charles Tilly's theory about the limitedness of action methods. In addition, geographical factors (such as terrain, location, etc.) have a significant and continuous impact on separatism in the long term, although these factors usually do not trigger dramatic events.

3. **The relationship between language and homeland**: The author proposes the concept of "language and homeland", that is, the language and cultural identity formed by a group on the land where it has long resided. This relationship is especially important in rural societies because language is not only a medium of communication but is also deeply rooted in people's emotional connection with their land.

### Research methods

To verify the above hypotheses, the author adopts the following methods:

- **Qualitative analysis**: Through the study of multiple cases, especially the examples of Switzerland and the United States, it shows how language boundaries become important barriers to internal migration and political consensus.
- **Quantitative analysis**: Use a data set containing about 40 cases of separatist struggles for systematic analysis to test the predictive ability of the model.

### Main conclusions

The main conclusion of the paper is that the spatial determinants of separatist tendencies can be described by a simple formula:

\[
D_s=\frac{p}{l \cdot w}
\]

where:
- \(p\) represents the proportion of the minority population;
- \(l\) represents the length of the border between the minority group and the rest of the country;
- \(w\) is a parameter characterizing the convenience of cross - regional communication.

This formula indicates that separatist tendencies are directly proportional to the proportion of the minority population and inversely proportional to the border length and communication convenience. In other words, when the proportion of a minority population is large but has less contact with the rest of the country, the separatist tendency is stronger.

### Case analysis

For example, in comparing Switzerland and the United States, the author found that the integration pressure of the German - American community in 1900 was 42 times that of the French - speaking region in Switzerland. This is consistent with the subsequent historical development and further proves the validity of the model.

In general, this paper provides a new perspective to understand the long - term dynamics of separatist movements by introducing spatial and historical factors, and also provides valuable references for future policy - making.