Validation Case Studies of Wireless Monitoring Systems in Civil Structures
J. P. Lynch,K. J. Loh,T. C. Hou,Y. Wang,J. Yi,C. B. Yun,K. C. Lu,C. H. Loh
2006-01-01
Abstract:Growing interest in smart structure technologies has motivated researchers to explore wireless sensor networks for structural monitoring applications. Wireless sensors offer significant cost savings and functionality enhancements compared to traditional cable-based monitoring technologies. First, wireless communication eradicates the need to undertake installation of wires in a structure, thereby saving major costs. Second, embedded computing technologies are integrated with wireless sensors to offer opportunities to locally process measurement data. This paper summarizes two validation case studies where wireless sensors are installed within realistic civil structures. The first case study describes the installation of a wireless monitoring system upon the Geumdang Bridge. The second case study describes the application of wireless sensors to a three-story steel structure excited with base motion. In both case studies, the wireless monitoring system is shown to provide equivalent accuracy compared to baseline cable-based monitoring systems simultaneously installed. Furthermore, the computational power integrated with the wireless sensor prototypes is utilized for real-time data interrogation. environment of a structure in the field can provide a true measure of a wireless monitoring system’s performance. In this study, a wireless monitoring system assembled from wireless sensing units initially proposed by Wang, Lynch and Law (2005) are installed within two full-scale civil structures. The first test structure is the Geumdang Bridge located in Icheon, Korea. This structure is a pre-cast concrete box girder bridge whose total span length is 122 m. The second structure is a three-story steel frame structure whose base is mounted to a large shaking table. White noise and seismic base motions are applied to the steel structure. A common feature of both case studies is the large number of sensing channels employed. For example, the wireless monitoring system installed in the Geumdang Bridge has 14 sensing channels. In a similar fashion, 20 sensing channels are employed in the base-excited steel frame structure. In both validation studies, the data quality of the wireless monitoring system’s response data is compared to that of a cable-based monitoring system installed in parallel. Furthermore, the studies provide an opportunity to showcase the local data processing capabilities of the wireless sensing units. 2 PROTOTYPE WIRELESS MONITORING SYSTEM In this study, a wireless structural monitoring system is designed and constructed primarily using commercial off-the-shelf (COTS) embedded system components. The fundamental component of the wireless monitoring system is the wireless sensing unit. The wireless sensing unit is not a sensor per se; rather, it is an autonomous data acquisition node to which a variety of sensing transducers (e.g. accelerometers, strain gages, linear displacement transducers) can be attached. The wireless sensor is responsible for analog-to-digital conversion, data aggregation, data processing and wireless communication of raw and processed sensor data. In addition to the wireless sensing unit, this study includes the design of two analog signal conditioning circuits that will permit the interface of sensors with lowoutput signals (e.g. low-noise capacitive accelerometers) and metal foil strain gages. 2.1 Wireless sensing units for structural monitoring The wireless sensor prototype, designed by Wang, Lynch and Law (2005), is adopted as the fundamental building block of the wireless monitoring systems deployed in the two validation structures. The wireless sensing unit is designed explicitly for monitoring civil structures. The primary function of the wireless sensing unit is to collect data from interfaced sensors. To execute this task, a 4-channel analog-to-digital converter (ADC) is included in the design of the prototype. The Texas Instruments ADS8341 ADC has a resolution of 16-bits and is capable of sampling as high as 100 kHZ. The ADC is controlled by the wireless sensing unit’s 8-bit Atmel ATmega128 microcontroller. This microcontroller is selected because it offers convenient peripherals (e.g. timers, input/output ports, serial interfaces). With 128 kB read only memory (ROM), the ATmega128 can have many different algorithms embedded for execution. The microcontroller has an insufficient amount of random access memory (RAM) for sensor data storage. In response to this limitation, 128 kB of off-chip RAM is included in the design of the wireless sensing unit computational core. After sensor data has been obtained by the microcontroller, the data is readied for transmission on the wireless channel. The Maxstream 9XCite wireless transceiver is integrated with the wireless sensing unit architecture. This 900 MHz radio can communicate up to 300 m line-of-sight with an overthe-air data rate of 38.4 Kbps. An additional benefit of this radio is that it employs frequency hopping spread spectrum encoding, resulting in a highly reliable wireless communication channel. The fully assembled wireless sensing unit prototype is shown in Fig. 1. The unit is powered by a 7.5 V battery supply assembled from 5 AA lithium batteries. A hardened external container is used to protect the wireless sensing unit from potentially harsh field conditions. The assembled unit is compact in size with a volume of 130 cm. After the wireless sensing unit prototypes are fully assembled, they are programmed with a multitasking operating system as described by Wang, Lynch and Law (2005). In addition to the embedded operating system, engineering algorithms are programmed and stored in the wireless sensing units. Algorithms including a fast Fourier transform (FFT) and autoregressive (AR) model fitting, are implemented for execution during field testing. 2.2 Interface circuit for low-output sensors The majority of structural sensors envisioned for use with the wireless sensing unit modulate their sensor reading upon a voltage signal. The wireless sensing unit ADC is capable of reading voltage signals that span from 0 to 5 V. Some sensors output positive and negative voltage signals with a zero mean; the Figure 1. Fully assembled wireless sensing unit prototype (battery and external container not shown for clarity).