Abstract:Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) shifts, if stripped off their uncertainties, must hold key information about the electronic fluid in the cuprates. The early shift interpretation that favored a single-fluid scenario will be reviewed, as well as recent experiments that reported its failure. Thereafter, based on literature shift data for planar Cu a contrasting shift phenomenology for cuprate superconductors is developed, which is very different from the early view while being in agreement with all published data. For example, it will be shown that the hitherto used hyperfine scenario is inadequate as a large isotropic shift component is discovered. Furthermore, the changes of the temperature dependences of the shifts above and below the superconducting transitions temperature proceed according to a few rules that were not discussed before. It appears that there can be substantial spin shift at the lowest temperature if the magnetic field lies in the CuO$_2$ plane, which points to a localization of spin in the $3d(x^2-y^2)$ orbital. A simple model is presented based on the most fundamental findings. The analysis must have new consequences for theory of the cuprates.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is about the different interpretations of the nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) shift phenomenon in copper - based superconductors. Specifically, early NMR shift interpretations tended to support the single - fluid model, but recent experimental results have shown that this model has deficiencies. Therefore, the paper aims to propose a new shift phenomenology that is consistent with the published data through a comparative analysis of NMR shift data in the literature, in order to better understand the properties of the electron fluid in copper - based superconductors. ### Background and Objectives of the Paper 1. **Early Shift Phenomenology** - Early research believed that the NMR shift in copper - based superconductors could be explained by the single - fluid model. For example, for in - plane copper atoms, when the magnetic field is parallel to the crystal c - axis ($c \parallel B_0$), the shift $K_\parallel$ hardly changes with temperature; while when the magnetic field is perpendicular to the c - axis ($c \perp B_0$), the shift $K_\perp$ decreases as the temperature decreases, which was considered evidence of spin singlet pairing. - However, with the accumulation of more experimental data, it was found that some materials also have temperature - dependent shifts in the $c \parallel B_0$ direction, which is inconsistent with the single - fluid model. 2. **Failure of the Single - Fluid Model** - Further research has found that the NMR shifts of some materials such as $\text{La}_{1.85}\text{Sr}_{0.15}\text{CuO}_4$ and $\text{HgBa}_2\text{CuO}_4+\delta$ cannot be explained by the single - fluid model. These materials exhibit multi - component behavior and require the introduction of multiple different temperature - dependent susceptibilities to describe their shifts. - For example, in $\text{La}_{1.85}\text{Sr}_{0.15}\text{CuO}_4$, the shifts of copper and oxygen show significantly different temperature dependencies, indicating the existence of two different susceptibilities. 3. **New Shift Phenomenology** - The paper proposes a new shift phenomenology model by re - analyzing a large amount of NMR shift data in the literature. This model can better explain the shift phenomena in different copper - based superconductors. - Key observations include: - **A. Common $K_\perp (T \to 0)$**: The low - temperature shifts $K_\perp (T \to 0)$ of all materials in the $c \perp B_0$ direction approach a similar value, approximately 0.35%. - **B. Wide Range of $K_\parallel (T \to 0)$**: There are large differences in the low - temperature shifts $K_\parallel (T \to 0)$ of different materials in the $c \parallel B_0$ direction, ranging from 1.2% to 2.0%. - **C. Isotropic Shift Lines**: Many points in the overdoped system and at high temperatures form a straight line with a slope of $\Delta K_\perp / \Delta K_\parallel \approx 1$, which is in line with the expectations of the single - fluid model. - **D. New Orbital Shifts**: The intersection of the isotropic shift line and the common $K_\perp (T \to 0)$ defines a new pair of orbital shifts $K_L, \perp \approx 0.35\%$ and $K_L, \parallel \approx 1.08\%$. - **E. Shift Triangles**: The shift points at almost all temperatures fall within a triangular region, which further supports the multi - component model. ### Conclusion The paper reveals the complexity of NMR shifts in copper - based superconductors through detailed experimental data and theoretical analysis, and proposes a new shift phenomenology model. This model can not only explain the phenomena that the early single - fluid model could not explain, but also provides...

Contrasting Phenomenology of NMR Shifts in Cuprate Superconductors

Properties of the Electronic Fluid of Superconducting Cuprates from 63Cu NMR Shift and Relaxation

A Different NMR View of Cuprate Superconductors

Recent Progress in NMR Studies on Unconventional Superconductors

Spectroscopic Studies of Quasiparticle Low-Energy Excitations in Cuprate and Iron-Based High-Temperature Superconductors

Evidence for Atomic-Scale Inhomogeneity in Superconducting Cuprate NMR

The NMR of High Temperature Superconductors without Anti-Ferromagnetic Spin Fluctuations

Two Ising-like Magnetic Excitations in a Single-Layer Cuprate Superconductor

A short review of the recent progresses in the study of the cuprate superconductivity

Experimental Observables Near a Nematic Quantum Critical Point in the Pnictide and Cuprate Superconductors

Superconducting Cuprates and Magnetoresistive Manganites: Similarities and Contrasts

Fluctuating superconductivity in overdoped cuprate with a flat antinodal dispersion

Two-component electron fluid in underdoped high-$T_c$ cuprate superconductors

Weak Phase Stiffness and Nature of the Quantum Critical Point in Underdoped Cuprates

Order and quantum phase transitions in the cuprate superconductors

Superconducting Fluctuations in Overdoped Bi2Sr2CaCu2

Spin fluctuations associated with the collapse of the pseudogap in a cuprate superconductor

Persistence of vortexlike phase fluctuations in underdoped to heavily overdoped Bi-2201 cuprates

Vorticity and the Nernst Effect in Cuprate Superconductors

Quantum criticality tuned by magnetic field in optimally electron-doped cuprate thin films

Cuprate universal electronic spin response and the pseudogap from NMR