Revisiting Tourism Development and Economic Growth: A Framework for Configurational Analysis in Chinese Cities

Yan Zhang,Jiekuan Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/su151310000

IF: 3.9

2023-06-24

Sustainability

Abstract:This paper comparatively analyzes the sufficiency and necessity of tourism's influence on economic growth in different cities from a systematic configurational perspective. Two important time points in China's tourism development, 2010 and 2019, are also considered in this paper to explore whether the impact of tourism on urban economic growth is temporally heterogeneous. The results demonstrate that tourism is not necessary for urban economic growth. However, the dependence on the tourism economy plays an important role in several urban economic growth patterns. Only one tourism-driven economic growth pattern exists, where tourism drives economic growth led by investment, and this pattern did not change significantly from 2010 to 2019. A tourism-driven low economic growth model also suggests that a high dependence on tourism leads to low economic growth. Two tourism-constrained low economic growth patterns exist: investment–industrial structure tourism-constrained and investment–innovation tourism-constrained. These two patterns indicate that economic growth rates are difficult to increase if the tourism economy is underdeveloped. In addition, tourism-driven or -constrained economic growth patterns have specific spatial clustering characteristics. This paper argues that tourism should actively seek foreign capital utilization and fixed asset investment, and also constantly reduce its independence and blur its industrial boundaries to better integrate or link with other industries to play its economic growth role. Furthermore, city policymakers should be fully aware of their own (tourism) resource endowment and the internal and external environment changes to choose a suitable economic growth model.

environmental sciences,environmental studies,green & sustainable science & technology

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The paper primarily explores the relationship between tourism development and economic growth, particularly within the framework of configuration analysis in Chinese cities. The core issues of the study can be summarized as follows:

1. **Analysis of the Sufficiency and Necessity of Tourism Development**: The paper aims to comparatively analyze the sufficiency and necessity of tourism's impact on economic growth from a system configuration perspective. By examining cases from different cities, the study explores whether tourism is a necessary condition for economic growth and under what circumstances tourism can promote economic growth.

2. **Exploration of Temporal Heterogeneity**: The paper pays special attention to two important time points (2010 and 2019) to investigate whether there is temporal heterogeneity in the impact of tourism on urban economic growth. This helps to understand whether the relationship between tourism and economic growth has significantly changed over time.

3. **Methodological Innovation**: The paper adopts a combination of Fuzzy-Set Qualitative Comparative Analysis (fsQCA) and Necessary Condition Analysis (NCA). These two methods are used to analyze the relationships between variables in complex configurations and to assess the degree of necessary conditions, respectively. This combination of methodologies allows for a more comprehensive understanding of the dynamic relationship between tourism and economic growth.

4. **Theoretical Contribution**: The theoretical contribution of the paper lies in systematically exploring how ecological factors related to the tourism industry jointly promote economic growth in urban areas from the perspective of configuration theory. It reveals the different paths through which tourism impacts economic growth and the mechanisms behind them.

5. **Empirical Findings**: The research results indicate that although tourism is not a necessary condition for urban economic growth, reliance on the tourism economy does play an important role in certain economic growth models. Additionally, there exists a tourism-driven economic growth model that did not undergo significant changes between 2010 and 2019. The study also identifies two low economic growth models constrained by tourism: the investment-industrial structure constrained tourism model and the investment-innovation constrained tourism model.

In summary, through an in-depth analysis of the relationship between tourism development and economic growth, this paper provides valuable insights for urban policymakers, helping them better understand how to promote sustainable economic growth through the rational utilization of tourism resources.