Abstract:BACKGROUND AND AIM: Many multilevel logistic regression analyses of "neighbourhood and health" focus on interpreting measures of associations (e.g., odds ratio, OR). In contrast, multilevel analysis of variance is rarely considered. We propose an original stepwise analytical approach that distinguishes between "specific" (measures of association) and "general" (measures of variance) contextual effects. Performing two empirical examples we illustrate the methodology, interpret the results and discuss the implications of this kind of analysis in public health.METHODS: We analyse 43,291 individuals residing in 218 neighbourhoods in the city of Malmö, Sweden in 2006. We study two individual outcomes (psychotropic drug use and choice of private vs. public general practitioner, GP) for which the relative importance of neighbourhood as a source of individual variation differs substantially. In Step 1 of the analysis, we evaluate the OR and the area under the receiver operating characteristic (AUC) curve for individual-level covariates (i.e., age, sex and individual low income). In Step 2, we assess general contextual effects using the AUC. Finally, in Step 3 the OR for a specific neighbourhood characteristic (i.e., neighbourhood income) is interpreted jointly with the proportional change in variance (i.e., PCV) and the proportion of ORs in the opposite direction (POOR) statistics.RESULTS: For both outcomes, information on individual characteristics (Step 1) provide a low discriminatory accuracy (AUC = 0.616 for psychotropic drugs; = 0.600 for choosing a private GP). Accounting for neighbourhood of residence (Step 2) only improved the AUC for choosing a private GP (+0.295 units). High neighbourhood income (Step 3) was strongly associated to choosing a private GP (OR = 3.50) but the PCV was only 11% and the POOR 33%.CONCLUSION: Applying an innovative stepwise multilevel analysis, we observed that, in Malmö, the neighbourhood context per se had a negligible influence on individual use of psychotropic drugs, but appears to strongly condition individual choice of a private GP. However, the latter was only modestly explained by the socioeconomic circumstances of the neighbourhoods. Our analyses are based on real data and provide useful information for understanding neighbourhood level influences in general and on individual use of psychotropic drugs and choice of GP in particular. However, our primary aim is to illustrate how to perform and interpret a multilevel analysis of individual heterogeneity in social epidemiology and public health. Our study shows that neighbourhood "effects" are not properly quantified by reporting differences between neighbourhood averages but rather by measuring the share of the individual heterogeneity that exists at the neighbourhood level.

Multilevel grouped regression for analyzing self-reported health in relation to environmental factors: the model and its application

Developing a locally adaptive spatial multilevel logistic model to analyze ecological effects on health using individual census records

Multilevel Conditional Autoregressive models for longitudinal and spatially referenced epidemiological data

A 3-level Bayesian mixed effects location scale model with an application to ecological momentary assessment data.

An Original Stepwise Multilevel Logistic Regression Analysis of Discriminatory Accuracy: The Case of Neighbourhoods and Health

Bayesian multiple index models for environmental mixtures

A scalable two-stage Bayesian approach accounting for exposure measurement error in environmental epidemiology

A flexible hierarchical framework for improving inference in area-referenced environmental health studies

Residential Environment and Health: A Review of Methodological and Conceptual Issues

Imputing Unmeasured Explanatory Variables in Environmental Epidemiology With Application to Health Impact Analysis of Air Pollution

Identifying multilevel predictors of behavioral outcomes like park use: A comparison of conditional and marginal modeling approaches

Inequality in Beijing: A Spatial Multilevel Analysis of Perceived Environmental Hazard and Self-Rated Health

Controlling for unmeasured confounding and spatial misalignment in long-term air pollution and health studies

The Effects of Air Pollution on Health: A Study of Los Angeles County

A hierarchical model for estimating exposure-response curves from multiple studies

Influences of Built Environment Characteristics and Individual Factors on Commuting Distance: A Multilevel Mixture Hazard Modeling Approach

Estimating exposure response functions using ambient pollution concentrations

Automatic Region-wise Spatially Varying Coefficient Regression Model: an Application to National Cardiovascular Disease Mortality and Air Pollution Association Study

Variance Function Regression in Hierarchical Age-Period-Cohort Models: Applications to the Study of Self-Reported Health

Bayesian adaptive and interpretable functional regression for exposure profiles

A machine learning approach to determine the influence of specific health conditions on self-rated health across education groups