Investigating the Use of Mastery-Style Online Homework Exercises in Introductory Algebra-based Mechanics in a Controlled Clinical Study

William R. Evans,Mats A. Selen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevPhysEducRes.13.020119

2016-11-29

Abstract:Homework in introductory physics represents an important part of a student's learning experience; therefore choosing the manner in which homework is presented merits investigation. We performed three rounds of clinical trials comparing the effects of mastery-style homework vs traditional-style homework with students in both algebra-based and calculus-based introductory mechanics. Results indicate a benefit from mastery-style over traditional-style homework, principally for weaker students who are less familiar with the material being covered and on questions that are nearer transfer to the study materials.

Physics Education

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to explore the effects of using mastery - style online homework exercises in basic physics courses, especially in the application of algebra - based mechanics courses. The research compares the impact of mastery - style homework and traditional - style homework on students' learning outcomes through clinical trials. The main issues of concern include:

1. **Is mastery - style homework more effective than traditional - style homework?** The research evaluates the effectiveness of mastery - style homework by comparing students' performance after two different forms of homework, especially the help for weaker students.

2. **The impact of mastery - style homework on different types of students** The research not only focuses on the performance of all students, but also specifically analyzes the differences in the impact on weaker and stronger students.

3. **The effectiveness of mastery - style homework under different curriculum settings** The research conducts experiments in algebra - based mechanics and calculus - based mechanics courses respectively to understand the applicability and effectiveness of mastery - style homework among student groups with different mathematical backgrounds.

Through these experiments, researchers hope to find a more effective teaching method, especially for life science students who are not very familiar with physics, in order to improve their learning outcomes and comprehension abilities.