The Role of Reciprocity and Directionality of Friendship Ties in Promoting Behavioral Change

Abdullah Almaatouq,Laura Radaelli,Alex Pentland,Erez Shmueli

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-39931-7

2016-10-13

Abstract:Friendship is a fundamental characteristic of human beings and usually assumed to be reciprocal in nature. Despite this common expectation, in reality, not all friendships by default are reciprocal nor created equal. Here, we show that reciprocated friendships are more intimate and they are substantially different from those that are not. We examine the role of reciprocal ties in inducing more effective peer pressure in a cooperative arrangements setting and find that the directionality of friendship ties can significantly limit the ability to persuade others to act. Specifically, we observe a higher behavioral change and more effective peer-influence when subjects shared reciprocal ties with their peers compared to sharing unilateral ones. Moreover, through spreading process simulation, we find that although unilateral ties diffuse behaviors across communities, reciprocal ties play more important role at the early stages of the diffusion process.

Social and Information Networks,Computers and Society,Physics and Society

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is to explore how reciprocity and directionality in friendship relationships affect the effectiveness of behavior change. Specifically, the authors studied whether reciprocal friendship relationships can more effectively generate peer pressure in the setting of cooperative arrangements, and how the directionality of friendship relationships restricts the ability to persuade others to take action. By analyzing self - reported relationship survey data, the authors found that only about half of friendships are reciprocal, and this asymmetry has a significant impact on an individual's ability to persuade others to change their behavior. In addition, the authors also experimentally verified that in reciprocal friendship relationships, behavior change between individuals is more effective, while one - way friendship relationships are less effective. These findings are of great significance for understanding the peer - influence mechanism in social networks, and in particular, provide a new perspective for designing interventions that utilize social influence to promote collective action.