CDW slips and giant frictional dissipation peaks at the NbSe$_2$ surface

Markus Langer,Marcin Kisiel,Rémy Pawlak,Franco Pellegrini,Giuseppe E. Santoro,Renato Buzio,Andrea Gerbi,Geetha Balakrishnan,Alexis Baratoff,Erio Tosatti,Ernst Meyer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1038/nmat3836

2016-05-12

Abstract:Accessing, controlling and understanding nanoscale friction and dissipation is a crucial issue in nanotechnology, where moving elements are central. Recently, ultra-sensitive noncontact pendulum Atomic Force Microscope (AFM) succeeded in detecting the electronic friction drop caused by the onset of superconductivity in Nb, raising hopes that a wider variety of mechanisms of mechanical dissipation arising from electron organization into different collective phenomena will become accessible through this unconventional surface probe. Among them, the driven phase dynamics of charge-density-waves (CDWs) represents an outstanding challenge as a source of dissipation. Here we report a striking multiplet of AFM dissipation peaks arising at nanometer distances above the surface of NbSe$_2$ - a layered compound exhibiting an incommensurate CDW. Each peak appears at a well defined tip-surface interaction force of the order of a nN, and persists until T=70K where CDW short-range order is known to disappear. A theoretical model is presented showing that the peaks are connected to tip-induced local 2$\pi$ CDW phase slips. Under the attractive potential of the approaching tip, the local CDW surface phase landscape deforms continuously until a series of 2$\pi$ jumps occur between different values of the local phase. As the tip oscillates to and fro, each slip gives rise to a hysteresis cycle, appearing at a selected distance, the dissipation corresponding to "pumping" in and out a local slip in the surface CDW phase of NbSe$_2$.

Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

### What problems does this paper attempt to solve?

This paper aims to explore and explain the charge - density - wave (CDW) phase slips observed on the NbSe₂ surface and the huge frictional dissipation peaks they cause. Specifically, the researchers are concerned with:

1. **Nanoscale friction and dissipation phenomena**: How to detect and understand friction and energy dissipation phenomena at the nanoscale through ultrasensitive non - contact atomic force microscopy (AFM). Such phenomena are particularly important in nanotechnology because moving parts are a core component of nano - devices.

2. **CDW phase - slip mechanism**: The researchers hope to reveal the specific mechanism of CDW phase slips, especially how the interaction between the AFM probe and the CDW leads to local 2π phase slips and produces significant energy dissipation peaks when the AFM probe approaches the NbSe₂ surface.

3. **Temperature dependence**: Study the behavior of these dissipation peaks at different temperatures, especially the changes near the temperature (about 70 K) at which the short - range order of CDW disappears. This helps to understand the relationship between CDW phase slips and temperature.

4. **Verification of theoretical models**: Establish a theoretical model to explain the experimentally observed phenomena, especially how to explain these huge dissipation peaks through probe - induced local CDW phase slips. This model assumes that CDW acts as an elastic medium and will undergo a phase change when the probe approaches, resulting in energy dissipation.

### Specific problem description

- **Background**: The study of nanoscale friction and energy dissipation is crucial for the development of nanotechnology. Especially for materials with complex electronic structures, such as the charge - density - wave (CDW) in NbSe₂, their unique physical properties may trigger new friction and dissipation mechanisms.

- **Research object**: NbSe₂ is a layered compound that exhibits incommensurate CDW at low temperatures. This material forms CDW below TCDW = 33 K and exhibits superconductivity below T = 7.2 K.

- **Experimental method**: The researchers used two different AFM techniques - oscillating AFM and tuning - fork - based AFM - to measure the non - contact frictional force on the NbSe₂ surface under ultra - high - vacuum (UHV) conditions. They observed a series of huge dissipation peaks that occur within the nanometer - distance range.

- **Theoretical model**: To understand the origin of these dissipation peaks, the researchers proposed a theoretical model that treats CDW as an elastic medium and describes the change in CDW phase as the probe approaches. The model predicts that when the probe approaches the surface, the CDW phase will undergo a 2π slip, resulting in energy dissipation.

### Conclusion

Through the combination of experiments and theoretical models, the researchers found that these dissipation peaks are caused by probe - induced local CDW phase slips. These slips occur under specific probe - sample interaction forces and are manifested as multiple discrete dissipation peaks. This finding not only reveals a new frictional dissipation mechanism in CDW materials but also provides new ideas for future research on other materials with incommensurate phases.

### Key formulas

The key formulas involved in the article include:

1. **Energy dissipation calculation formula**:
\[
P = P_0 \left( \frac{A_{\text{exc}}(d)}{A_{\text{exc},0}} - \frac{f(d)}{f_0} \right)
\]
where \(P_0\) is the dissipation power caused by the cantilever's own loss, \(A_{\text{exc}}(d)\) and \(f(d)\) are the distance - dependent excitation amplitude and frequency respectively, and \(A_{\text{exc},0}\) and \(f_0\) are the corresponding values of the free cantilever.

2. **CDW energy function**:
\[
E[\varphi(x)] = \int \left[ (\nabla \varphi(x))^2 + V(x) \rho(x) \right] dx
\]
where \(\varphi(x)\) is the phase parameter, \(V(x)\) is the external perturbation potential, and \(\rho(x)=\rho_0 \cos(Qx + \varphi(x))\) is the total density (ions and electrons).

Through these formulas and models, the researchers successfully explained the experimentally observed phenomena.