Impact of guided reflection with peers on the development of effective problem solving strategies and physics learning

Andrew J. Mason,Chandralekha Singh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1119/1.4947159

2016-04-30

Abstract:Students must learn effective problem solving strategies in order to develop expertise in physics. Effective problem solving strategies include a conceptual analysis of the problem followed by planning of the solution, and then implementation, evaluation and reflection upon the process. Research suggests that converting a problem from the initial verbal representation to other suitable representation, e.g., diagrammatic representation, during the initial conceptual analysis can facilitate further analysis of the problem.6 But without guidance, many introductory physics students solve problems using superficial clues and cues and do not perceive problem solving as an opportunity for learning. Here, we describe a study which suggests that engaging students in reflection with peers about effective problem solving strategies while effective approaches are modeled for them and prompt feedback is provided may enhance desirable skills.

Physics Education

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem this paper attempts to address is: how to improve students' effective problem-solving strategies and learning outcomes in physics by guiding them to reflect with their peers.

Specifically, the researchers focus on:

1. **Cultivation of Effective Problem-Solving Strategies**: Students need to learn effective methods for solving problems, including conceptual analysis of the problem, planning solutions, implementation, evaluation, and reflection. Many novice physics students, without guidance, often rely on superficial cues to solve problems without realizing it is a learning opportunity.

2. **Shortcomings of Traditional Teaching Methods**: Traditional physics teaching, especially at the university level, often lacks guidance and support for students (i.e., "coaching" and "scaffolding"), similar to a piano teacher only demonstrating without providing timely feedback.

3. **Role of Peer Interaction**: The researchers explore the possibility of helping students learn effective problem-solving strategies through peer interaction (especially reflection). This interaction not only helps students understand their own problem-solving methods but also allows them to learn different ideas and strategies from their peers.

4. **Application of the Cognitive Apprenticeship Model**: The researchers adopted the empirically validated cognitive apprenticeship model, which emphasizes three key components: modeling, coaching and scaffolding, and gradually reducing support. Through these methods, the researchers hope to help students develop self-reliance.

In summary, the main purpose of this paper is to explore whether guiding students to reflect with their peers can effectively improve their problem-solving abilities and learning outcomes in physics.