Abstract:Coordinated decision making and actions have become the primary solution for the overexploitation of interacting resources within ecosystems. However, the success of coordinated management is highly sensitive to biological, economic, and social conditions. Here, using a game theoretic framework and a 2-species model that considers various biological relationships (competition, predation, and mutualism), we compute cooperative (or joint) and non-cooperative (or separate) management equilibrium outcomes of the model and investigate the effects of the type and strength of the relationships. We find that cooperation does not always show superiority to non-cooperation in all biological interactions: (1) if and only if resources are involved in high-intensity predation relationships, cooperation can achieve a win-win scenario for ecosystem services and resource diversity; (2) for competitive resources, cooperation realizes higher ecosystem services by sacrificing resource diversity; and (3) for mutual resources, cooperation has no obvious advantage for either ecosystem services or resource evenness but can slightly improve resource abundance. Furthermore, by using a fishery model of the North California Current Marine Ecosystem with 63 species and seven fleets, we demonstrate that the theoretical results can be reproduced in real ecosystems. Therefore, effective ecosystem management should consider the interconnection between stakeholders’ social relationship and resources’ biological relationships.

On the effects of a common-pool resource on cooperation among firms with linear technologies

Sustainable allocation of greenhouse gas emission permits for firms with Leontief technologies

Equilibria in a competitive model arising from linear production situations with a common-pool resource

Biological Interactions and Cooperative Management of Multiple Species

Exploitation of a Productive Asset in the Presence of Strategic Behavior and Pollution Externalities

The Sustainable Supply Chain Network Competition Based on Non-Cooperative Equilibrium under Carbon Emission Permits

Cooperation in the management of charitable resource flows

Commitment vs. noncommitment behaviors in natural resource conflicts: A case study of groundwater resources

Time-dependent effects hinder cooperation on the public goods game

Coevolving Allocation of Resources and Cooperation in Spatial Evolutionary Games

On an Intra-Enterprise Carbon Quota Distribution System

Dynamics of a Quantum Common-Pool Resource Game with Homogeneous Players' Expectations

Generalized Nash Equilibrium Models for Asymmetric, Non-cooperative Games on Line Graphs: Application to Water Resource Systems

The co-determination decision game with consumption externalities

The emergence of cooperation from shared goals in the Systemic Sustainability Game of common pool resources

Playing games against nature: optimal policies for renewable resource allocation

The role of the Allee effect in common-pool resource and its sustainability

Research on Decision-Making and Coordination of Closed-Loop Supply Chain Under Green and Low-Carbon Perspective

Modelling transfer profits as externalities in a cooperative game-theoretic model of natural gas networks

Multistability and complex basins in a nonlinear duopoly with price competition and relative profit delegation

Cooperation and profit allocation in distribution chains