UK OMF surgeons support changes to current specialty recruitment process which could include 'Walport' style local selection and national benchmarking

Divya Sharma,James Douglas,Anne Begley,Iain Hutchison,Patrick Magennis
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.bjoms.2024.03.002
IF: 2.018
2024-03-22
British Journal of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery
Abstract:Introduction Recruitment to OMFS specialty training was centralised in 2010. The 'flexibility' for OMFS to respond to specialty specific recruitment issues is reducing and many ST posts are left unfilled. The NIHR appointment process designed to address the problem of recruiting and appointing academic surgeons with local selection with national benchmarking has worked. Material & Methods Using a database of all UK OMFS consultants/trainees, an electronic questionnaire was shared by e-mail, WhatsApp and other social media. Results Of 306 replies, 125 (41%) were Consultants/post-CCT individuals, 66 (22%) Specialty Trainees (ST), 61 (20%) second degree students, 27 (9%) pre-second degree, 26 (9%) dual degree pre-ST trainees and 1 did not indicate their status. 249 (76%) studied dentistry first and 230 (75%) were male. Of those replying, 147 (48%) had no direct experience of national selection. 120 (39%) had experience as a candidate, 20 (7%) as a selector only, 17 (6%) as a candidate and selector and 2 did not record their experience. Of 250 expressing an opinion, 156 (62%) supported local selection with 140 (56%) supporting local selection and national benchmarking, a process used for research training posts by the National Institute of Health Research (NIHR). Geographical continuity was most important for 78% of pre-second-degree trainees, 45% of STs and 54% of second-degree students. 57 respondents completed free text comments. Conclusion There is support for changes in OMFS ST selection including creating OMFS posts which include Foundation and second degree training in NIHR style locally recruited nationally benchmarked posts.
dentistry, oral surgery & medicine,surgery
What problem does this paper attempt to address?