Nuclear Energy: Promise or Peril?
D S Woodhead
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1088/0952-4746/20/4/702
2000-11-30
Journal of Radiological Protection
Abstract:This book represents the outcome of a Peer Review Workshop of the Pugwash Conferences on Science and World Affairs on `The Prospects of Nuclear Energy' held in Paris in December 1998. It is intended to address, in a manner accessible to the non-expert, the contribution that electricity production from nuclear power might make to resolving the dilemma in which an increasing demand for energy to fuel global economic development confronts an energy production policy that has not, as yet, fully taken into account the impacts on the environment and the depletion of the reserves of non-renewable (both fossil and nuclear) fuels. It is accepted that nuclear energy has both negative (e.g. the production of long-lived radioactive wastes and a potential for weapons proliferation) and positive (e.g. a relatively minor contribution to the problem of global warming) aspects. The influences of these factors on the potential of nuclear energy to continue to contribute to the global energy production mix are explored in detail. During the two days of the conference, each of the chapters was exposed to critical discussion by all of the authors contributing to the book, as well as a smaller independent group of scientists and others from a range of relevant disciplines. It is in this sense that the material presented is said to be `peer reviewed', a process that is probably at least as valid as that for a journal article. The text comprises an introductory preface, 18 substantive chapters, a brief summary by the editors, a short, but useful, appendix of technical notes and units, an (obligatory) summary of abbreviations and acronyms, a listing of the affiliations of the conference participants and a comprehensive index. The first chapter provides a simple introduction to the basics of nuclear energy, reactor systems and their radionuclide inventories, the health hazards of radiation and a brief indication of possible future developments (expanded by others in later chapters). It also summarises the current status of the global nuclear programme for electricity production in the context of the costs of the present and future uranium supply requirements, and the economic considerations that will influence the acceptability of this power source. The next two chapters discuss, respectively, the role of nuclear energy in preventing climate change, and the inter-relationship between global energy use and climate change in this century. The conclusion is that the predicted increase in world energy demand (a six-fold rise, fuelled by population growth and the fulfilment of development objectives) cannot be met by carbon-free sources, and that these - including the nuclear option - require substantial investment in R and D to yield their full potential in an environmentally and socially acceptable way. It is noted that the developed world will probably be able to increase gross national product with little, if any, increase in energy consumption through improvements in energy efficiency - the subject of the next chapter. This is, however, concerned with more than just improving the output per unit energy input. It is firmly concluded that the risks inherent in applying the successful, but energy-rich, approach of the present developed nations to the remainder of the developing world are unacceptable. The author, therefore, envisages a decoupling of economic growth from energy consumption, and a parallel application of intelligence and effort towards achieving desired development goals within a scenario of decreasing energy utilisation, i.e. the engineering of substantial policy and cultural change. Chapters 5 and 6 examine the possible role of nuclear power in the economic advancement of the developing countries; both authors are in agreement that this energy source will be required to supply a proportion of the variable electricity demand that will differ between countries. The following, very short chapter of just 4 pages makes some observations on the safety of nuclear power. In the context of the objectives of this book, a more substantial offering might have been expected. The next 7 chapters deal with the problem of managing nuclear wastes, including the ever-contentious issue of whether spent fuel should be reprocessed. Chapter 8 provides a broad overview of the nature of the long-lived wastes, identifies the plutonium isotopes as the source of greatest radiological risk through ingestion for at least 105 years, and indicates the management options available (including recycling of the plutonium for energy production). Although the title of chapter 9 refers to the storage of wastes, it is mainly concerned with the process of assessing the radiological safety of the disposal of high level and long-lived intermediate level wastes into a geological repository. It is concluded that modelling radionuclide behaviour in the geosphere and biosphere over the required period of 107 years into the future is not straightforward, with significant problems still requiring solutions - including that of model validation. Chapters 10-14 focus on the management of the plutonium that is inevitably produced in thermal reactors employing uranium fuel, and that is now becoming available from the dismantling of nuclear weapons. There are essentially two options for the plutonium: either treat it as a waste and dispose of it to a geological repository within the spent fuel (the `once through' fuel cycle), or recover it from the spent fuel for recycling in fast breeder reactors or in mixed Pu/U fuel in thermal reactors. Both options are subject to continuing research and development, but this is far from being the sole determinant for the acceptability of either: the medium- to long-term economics of retaining a nuclear component in the capacity for electricity generation, the perceived relative potential for weapons proliferation, and, not least, the political problem of developing a plutonium management policy acceptable to the general public, are all aspects that are considered here. The next two chapters (15 and 16) provide a more detailed discussion of the merits of fast neutron reactors (without a breeding facility) and accelerator-driven reactors for the purposes of burning plutonium and transmuting other waste radionuclides into less problematic isotopes. Either approach would require substantial research and development before it could make a useful contribution and, it is noted, neither would necessarily be acceptable to the world at large. The final two chapters are concerned with the risks of proliferation and the operation of the international safeguards mechanisms intended to contain the possibility of generating, or trafficking in, fissile materials for weapons production. It is clear that the safeguards system presently operated by the IAEA exerts a substantial measure of control on the risk, but cannot eliminate it. The text is marred by occasional errors that range from the trivial (23494Pu for 23994Pu), to the potentially misleading (the capacity of the tidal plant at Rance in France is 60 MW rather than 60 GW), to an omission that completely changes what I infer, from the overall context, to be the intended sense of a sentence (the lack of `do not' before `exist' in line 2 on page 112). That said, however, the material in this book provides a very useful input, primarily, but not entirely, from a pro-nuclear viewpoint, to the discussions on the role of nuclear power in future global energy production. It should be required reading for anyone concerned with how the international community is going to meet the challenge of a continuing rise in atmospheric CO2 and probable climate change.
environmental sciences,public, environmental & occupational health,radiology, nuclear medicine & medical imaging,nuclear science & technology