Abstract:BackgroundIssues of balancing data accessibility with ethical considerations and governance of a genomics research biobank, Generation Scotland, are explored within the evolving policy landscape of the past ten years. During this time data sharing and open data access have become increasingly important topics in biomedical research. Decisions around data access are influenced by local arrangements for governance and practices such as linkage to health records, and the global through policies for biobanking and the sharing of data with large-scale biomedical research data resources and consortia.MethodsWe use a literature review of policy relevant documents which apply to the conduct of biobanks in two areas: support for open access and the protection of data subjects and researchers managing a bioresource. We present examples of decision making within a biobank based upon observations of the Generation Scotland Access Committee. We reflect upon how the drive towards open access raises ethical dilemmas for established biorepositories containing data and samples from human subjects.ResultsDespite much discussion in science policy literature about standardisation, the contextual aspects of biobanking are often overlooked. Using our engagement with GS we demonstrate the importance of local arrangements in the creation of a responsive ethical approach to biorepository governance. We argue that governance decisions regarding access to the biobank are intertwined with considerations about maintenance and viability at the local level. We show that in addition to the focus upon ever more universal and standardised practices, the local expertise gained in the management of such repositories must be supported.ConclusionsA commitment to open access in genomics research has found almost universal backing in science and health policy circles, but repositories of data and samples from human subjects may have to operate under managed access, to protect privacy, align with participant consent and ensure that the resource can be managed in a sustainable way. Data access committees need to be reflexive and flexible, to cope with changing technology and opportunities and threats from the wider data sharing environment. To understand these interactions also involves nurturing what is particular about the biobank in its local context.

Ethical governance for genomic data science in the cloud

Cloud-based biomedical data storage and analysis for genomic research: Landscape analysis of data governance in emerging NIH-supported platforms

Future-proofing genomic data and consent management: a comprehensive review of technology innovations

Collaborative analysis of genomic data: vision and challenges

Enabling responsible public genomics

Privacy-Preserving Collaborative Genomic Research: A Real-Life Deployment and Vision

Data Security and Privacy in Genomics Research: A Comparative Analysis to Protect Confidentiality

Privacy in the Genomic Era

Cloud-Assisted Privacy-Preserving Genetic Paternity Test

Balancing the local and the universal in maintaining ethical access to a genomics biobank

Digital phenotyping and sensitive health data: Implications for data governance

The ethical and legal landscape of brain data governance

Functional genomics data: privacy risk assessment and technological mitigation

A contextual integrity approach to genomic information: what bioethics can learn from big data ethics

The ethics weathervane

How to use relevant data for maximal benefit with minimal risk: digital health data governance to protect vulnerable populations in low-income and middle-income countries

Systematizing Genome Privacy Research: A Privacy-Enhancing Technologies Perspective

Towards a new standard in genomic data privacy: a realization of owner-governance

Scalability and cost-effectiveness analysis of whole genome-wide association studies on Google Cloud Platform and Amazon Web Services

Privacy Preservation of Digital Health Records in Cloud

Machine learning and genomics: precision medicine vs. patient privacy