Optimized design of an enthesis-mimicking suture anchor-tendon hybrid graft for mechanically robust bone-tendon repair
Chenyang Wang,Xu Zhang,Dan Michelle Wang,Patrick S.H. Yung,Rocky S. Tuan,Dai Fei Elmer Ker
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.actbio.2024.01.011
IF: 10.633
2024-01-21
Acta Biomaterialia
Abstract:Repair of functionally graded biological interfaces requires joining dissimilar materials such as hard bone to soft tendon/ligament, with re-injuries/re-tears expected to be minimized by incorporating biomimicking, stress-reducing features within grafts. At bone-tendon interfaces (entheses), stress can be reduced via angled insertion, geometric flaring, mechanical gradation, and interdigitation of tissues. Here, we incorporated enthesis attributes into 3D in silico and physical models of a unique suture anchor-tendon hybrid graft (SATHG) and investigated their effects on stress reduction via finite element analyses (FEA) studies. Over 20 different simulations altering SATHG angulation, flaring, mechanical gradation, and interdigitation identified an optimal design, which included 90° angulation, 25° flaring, and a compliant (ascending then descending) mechanical gradient in SATHG's bone-to-tendon-like transitional region. This design reduced peak stress concentration factor (SCF) by 43.6% relative to an ascending-only mechanical gradient typically used in hard-to-soft tissue engineering. To verify FEA results, SATHG models were fabricated using a photocrosslinkable bone-tendon-like polyurethane (QHM polymer) for ex vivo tensile assessment. Tensile testing showed that ultimate load (132.9 N), displacement-at-failure (1.78 mm), stiffness (135.4 N/mm), and total work-to-failure (422.1×10 −3 J) were highest in the optimized design. Furthermore, to assess envisioned usage, SATHG pull-out testing and 6-week in vivo implantation into large, 0.5-cm segmental supraspinatus tendon defects was performed. SATHG pull-out testing showed secure bone attachment while histological assessment such as hematoxylin and eosin (H&E) together with Safranin-O staining showed biocompatibility including enthesis regeneration. This work demonstrates that engineering biomaterials with FEA-optimized, enthesis-like attributes shows potential for enhancing hard-to-soft tissue repair. Statement of significance Successful repair of hard-to-soft tissue injuries is challenging due to high stress concentrations within bone-tendon/ligament grafts that mechanically compromise repair strength. While stress-reducing gradient biomaterials have been reported, little-to-no attention has focused on other bone-tendon/ligament interface (enthesis) features. To this end, a unique bone-tendon graft (SATHG) was developed by combining two common orthopaedic devices along with biomimetic incorporation of four enthesis-like features to reduce stress and encourage widespread clinician adoption. Notably, utilizing designs based on natural stress dissipation principles such as anchor insertion angle, geometric flaring, and mechanical gradation reduced stress by 43.6% in silico , which was confirmed ex vivo , while in vivo studies showed SATHG's ability to support native enthesis regeneration. Thus, SATHG shows promise for hard-to-soft tissue repairs.
engineering, biomedical,materials science, biomaterials