Abstract:Georgia Papadogeorgou, Francesca Dominici. In the last two decades ambient levels of air pollution have declined substantially. At the same time the Clean Air Act mandates that the National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) must be routinely assessed to protect populations based on the latest science. Therefore, researchers should continue to address the following question: is exposure to levels of air pollution below the NAAQS harmful to human health? Furthermore, the contentious nature surrounding environmental regulations urges us to cast this question within a causal inference framework. Several parametric and semiparametric regression approaches have been used to estimate the exposure-response (ER) curve between long-term exposure to ambient air pollution concentrations and health outcomes. However, most of the existing approaches are not formulated within a formal framework for causal inference, adjust for the same set of potential confounders across all levels of exposure and do not account for model uncertainty regarding covariate selection and the shape of the ER. In this paper we introduce a Bayesian framework for the estimation of a causal ER curve called LERCA (Local Exposure Response Confounding Adjustment), which: (a) allows for different confounders and different strength of confounding at the different exposure levels, and (b) propagates model uncertainty regarding confounders' selection and the shape of the ER. Importantly, LERCA provides a principled way of assessing the observed covariates' confounding importance at different exposure levels, providing researchers with important information regarding the set of variables to measure and adjust for in regression models. Using simulation studies, we show that state-of-the-art approaches perform poorly in estimating the ER curve in the presence of local confounding. LERCA is used to evaluate the relationship between long-term exposure to ambient PM$_{2.5}$, a key regulated pollutant, and cardiovascular hospitalizations for 5,362 zip codes in the continental U.S. and located near a pollution monitoring site, while adjusting for a potentially varying set of confounders across the exposure range. Our data set includes rich health, weather, demographic and pollution information for the years of 2011–2013. The estimated exposure-response curve is increasingly indicating that higher ambient concentrations lead to higher cardiovascular hospitalization rates, and ambient PM$_{2.5}$ was estimated to lead to an increase in cardiovascular hospitalization rates when focusing at the low-exposure range. Our results indicate that there is no threshold for the effect of PM$_{2.5}$ on cardiovascular hospitalizations.

A New Method for Partial Correction of Residual Confounding in Time-Series and other Observational Studies

Invited Commentary: Bias Attenuation And Identification Of Causal Effects With Multiple Negative Controls

The covariate-adjusted residual estimator and its use in both randomized trials and observational settings

Imputing Unmeasured Explanatory Variables in Environmental Epidemiology With Application to Health Impact Analysis of Air Pollution

Estimating a Causal Exposure Response Function with a Continuous Error-Prone Exposure: A Study of Fine Particulate Matter and All-Cause Mortality

Discovering Effect Modification and Randomization Inference in Air Pollution Studies

Controlling for unmeasured confounding and spatial misalignment in long-term air pollution and health studies

Identification of confounder in epidemiologic data contaminated by measurement error in covariates

CAUSAL INFERENCE IN THE CONTEXT OF AN ERROR PRONE EXPOSURE: AIR POLLUTION AND MORTALITY.

Measurement error in two-stage analyses, with application to air pollution epidemiology

Sensitivity analysis with multiple treatments and multiple outcomes with applications to air pollution mixtures

Transporting established insights from classical experimental design, implemented using methods that rely on modern computing to address causal questions in environmental epidemiology

Addressing Spatially Structured Interference in Causal Analysis Using Propensity Scores

Estimating the marginal effect of a continuous exposure on an ordinal outcome using data subject to covariate‐driven treatment and visit processes

Exposure prediction approaches used in air pollution epidemiology studies: Key findings and future recommendations

Partial identification and unmeasured confounding with multiple treatments and multiple outcomes

A Bayesian Approach to Correct for Unmeasured or Semi-Unmeasured Confounding in Survival Data Using Multiple Validation Data Sets

Estimation and Inference for Case-Control Studies with Multiple Non-Gold Standard Exposure Assessments: with an Occupational Health Application.

A causal exposure response function with local adjustment for confounding: Estimating health effects of exposure to low levels of ambient fine particulate matter

A new approach to causal inference in mortality studies with a sustained exposure period—application to control of the healthy worker survivor effect

A Proxy Outcome Approach for Causal Effect in Observational Studies: a Simulation Study.