Direct Measurement of the Surface Tension of Nanobubbles

Phil Attard

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1505.02217

2015-05-09

Abstract:It is shown that when the nanobubble contact line is pinned to a penetrating tip the interface behaves like a Hookean spring with spring constant proportional to the nanobubble surface tension. Atomic force microscope (AFM) data for several nanobubbles and solutions are analysed and yield surface tensions in the range 0.04--0.05 N/m (compared to 0.072 N/m for saturated water), and supersaturation ratios in the range 2--5. These are the first direct measurements of the surface tension of a supersaturated air-water interface. The results are consistent with recent theories of nanobubble size and stability, and with computer simulations of the surface tension of a supersaturated solution.

Soft Condensed Matter,Statistical Mechanics,Chemical Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the method of directly measuring the surface tension of nanobubbles. Specifically, the author proposes a method by fixing the nanobubble contact line on a penetrating tip, making the interface behave like a Hookean spring, whose spring constant is proportional to the surface tension of the nanobubble. By analyzing atomic force microscopy (AFM) data, the author obtained the surface tension ranges of several nanobubbles and solutions, and directly measured the surface tension of the supersaturated air - water interface for the first time.

### Background and Motivation
1. **Existence of Nanobubbles**:
- Since the existence of nanobubbles was first experimentally confirmed in 1994, it has been widely recognized.
- The initial controversy centered on the extremely high gas pressure inside nanobubbles (10 - 100 atmospheres), which should cause them to dissolve within microseconds. These controversies were later resolved through theory and experiments.

2. **Surface Tension of Supersaturated Solutions**:
- Research shows that nanobubbles can only be in equilibrium in supersaturated water.
- The surface tension of a supersaturated solution must be less than that of a saturated solution.
- Nanobubbles with a fixed contact boundary are thermodynamically stable.

3. **Importance of Surface Tension**:
- A decrease in surface tension means that the internal gas pressure is much lower than earlier estimates, which makes the existence of nanobubbles possible.
- The degree of supersaturation of the solution is also reduced to a practically achievable level.

### Research Objectives
- **Directly Measuring the Surface Tension of Nanobubbles**:
- By fixing the nanobubble contact line on a penetrating tip and analyzing AFM data.
- The aim is to relate the surface tension of nanobubbles to the measured force, thereby directly measuring the surface tension.

### Methods
- **Model Building**:
- The author modeled AFM force - measurement data and analyzed the deformation of nanobubbles when the cantilever tip penetrated the nanobubbles.
- Through small - force expansion analysis, it was concluded that the behavior of the nanobubble interface is similar to that of a Hookean spring.

- **Data Analysis**:
- Analyzed the data of multiple nanobubbles, and the results showed that the surface tension was always lower than that of the saturated air - water interface.
- The supersaturation ratio of the solution was always greater than 1.

### Results
- **Surface Tension Range**:
- A surface tension range of 0.04 - 0.05 N/m was obtained, which is significantly lower compared to 0.072 N/m for saturated water.
- The supersaturation ratio is between 2 - 5.

- **Theoretical Consistency**:
- The results are consistent with recent theories on nanobubble size and stability and computer simulation results.

### Applications
- **Atmospheric Physics**:
- Cloud droplet nucleation always occurs in a supersaturated atmosphere, so the rate of change of surface tension with supersaturation is a key input for quantitative modeling.
- **Other Fields**:
- Directly measuring the surface tension of the supersaturated air - water interface has application value in many fields, such as fluid dynamics, materials science, etc.

Through these studies, the author not only solved the technical problem of directly measuring the surface tension of nanobubbles, but also provided important experimental evidence for understanding the stability and behavior of nanobubbles.