A general law for electromagnetic induction

Giuseppe Giuliani

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1209/0295-5075/81/60002

2015-02-02

Abstract:The definition of the induced $emf$ as the integral over a closed loop of the Lorentz force acting on a unit positive charge leads immediately to a general law for electromagnetic induction phenomena. The general law is applied to three significant cases: moving bar, Faraday's and Corbino's disc. This last application illustrates the contribution of the drift velocity of the charges to the induced $emf$: the magneto-resistance effect is obtained without using microscopic models of electrical conduction. Maxwell wrote down `general equations of electromotive intensity' that, integrated over a closed loop, yield the general law for electromagnetic induction, if the velocity appearing in them is correctly interpreted. The flux of the magnetic field through an arbitrary surface that have the circuit as contour {\em is not the cause} of the induced $emf$. The flux rule must be considered as a calculation shortcut for predicting the value of the induced $emf$ when the circuit is filiform. Finally, the general law of electromagnetic induction yields the induced $emf$ in both reference frames of a system composed by a magnet and a circuit in relative uniform motion, as required by special relativity.

Classical Physics

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the basic principle and description method of electromagnetic induction phenomena. Specifically, the author Giuseppe Giuliani proposed a new and more general law of electromagnetic induction to replace the traditional "magnetic flux rule" (i.e., Faraday - Neumann law). The traditional magnetic flux rule has problems in some cases, especially when the circuit is partially moving. The main contributions of the paper include:

1. **Redefine the induced electromotive force**:
The author defines the induced electromotive force as the Lorentz force integrated along a closed loop per unit positive charge:
\[
E = \oint_l (\vec{E} + \vec{v}_c \times \vec{B}) \cdot d\vec{l}
\]
where $\vec{v}_c$ is the velocity of the charge.

2. **Propose a general law of electromagnetic induction**:
According to the above definition, the author derives a general law of electromagnetic induction:
\[
E = -\oint_l \frac{\partial \vec{A}}{\partial t} \cdot d\vec{l} + \oint_l (\vec{v}_c \times \vec{B}) \cdot d\vec{l}
\]
This law takes into account two independent processes: the time - variation of the vector potential and the influence of the magnetic field on moving charges.

3. **Explain the limitations of the magnetic flux rule**:
The author points out that the magnetic flux rule is not a field law or a law of causality, but only a computational shortcut, applicable to filament - like circuits. For circuits composed of extended conductors, the magnetic flux rule cannot accurately describe physical phenomena.

4. **Apply to specific cases**:
The paper verifies the validity of the new law through several specific cases (such as a moving metal rod, Faraday's disc, and Corbino disc), and shows how to handle the contribution of the drift velocity in extended conductors to the induced electromotive force.

5. **Compatibility with special relativity**:
The new law can correctly describe electromagnetic induction phenomena in different reference frames and meets the requirements of special relativity.

6. **Historical and conceptual discussion**:
The paper also discusses the historical development of the electromagnetic induction theory and the importance of its basic concepts, emphasizing that this issue is not limited to physics teaching, but also involves historical and epistemological aspects.

In summary, this paper aims to provide a more comprehensive and accurate law of electromagnetic induction to solve the deficiencies of the traditional magnetic flux rule in some cases and provide a new perspective for understanding electromagnetic induction phenomena.