Abstract:Introduction: Wearable in-ear electroencephalographic (EEG) devices hold significant promise for integrating brain monitoring technologies into real-life applications. However, despite the introduction of various in-ear EEG systems, there remains a necessity for validating these technologies against gold-standard, clinical-grade devices. This study aims to evaluate the signal quality of a newly developed mobile in-ear EEG device compared to a standard scalp EEG system among healthy volunteers during wakefulness and sleep. Methods: The study evaluated an in-ear EEG device equipped with dry electrodes in a laboratory setting, recording a single bipolar EEG channel using a cross-ear electrode configuration. Thirty healthy participants were recorded simultaneously using the in-ear EEG device and a conventional EEG cap system with 64 wet electrodes. Based on two recording protocols, one during a resting state condition involving alternating eye opening and closure with a low degree of artifact contamination and another consisting of a daytime nap, several quality measures were used for a quantitative comparison including root mean square (RMS) analysis, artifact quantification, similarities of relative spectral power (RSP), signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) based on alpha peak criteria, and cross-signal correlations of alpha activity during eyes-closed conditions and sleep activities. The statistical significance of our results was assessed through nonparametric permutation tests with False Discovery Rate (FDR) control. Results: During the resting state, in-ear and scalp EEG signals exhibited similar fluctuations, characterized by comparable RMS values. However, intermittent signal alterations were noticed in the in-ear recordings during nap sessions, attributed to movements of the head and facial muscles. Spectral analysis indicated similar patterns between in-ear and scalp EEG, showing prominent peaks in the alpha range (8-12 Hz) during rest and in the low-frequency range during naps (particularly in the theta range of 4-7 Hz). Analysis of alpha wave characteristics during eye closures revealed smaller alpha wave amplitudes and slightly lower signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) values in the in-ear EEG compared to scalp EEG. In around 80% of cases, cross-correlation analysis between in-ear and scalp signals, using a contralateral bipolar montage of 64 scalp electrodes, revealed significant correlations with scalp EEG (p < 0.01), particularly evident in the FT11-FT12 and T7-T8 electrode derivations. Conclusion: Our findings support the feasibility of using in-ear EEG devices with dry-contact electrodes for brain activity monitoring, compared to a standard scalp EEG, notably for wakefulness and sleep uses. Although marginal signal degradation is associated with head and facial muscle contractions, the in-ear device offers promising applications for long-term EEG recordings, particularly in scenarios requiring enhanced comfort and user-friendliness.

Systematic Investigation of Optimal Electrode Positions and Re-Referencing Strategies on Ear Biosignals

Advancing towards Ubiquitous EEG, Correlation of In-Ear EEG with Forehead EEG

An in-the-ear platform for recording electroencephalogram

The In-the-Ear Recording Concept: User-Centered and Wearable Brain Monitoring

Optimal Referencing for Stereo-Electroencephalographic (SEEG) Recordings

Optimization of ear electrodes for SSVEP-based BCI

Signal quality evaluation of an in-ear EEG device in comparison to a conventional cap system

Multi-Channel Soft Dry Electrodes for Electrocardiography Acquisition in the Ear Region

Enhanced Automated Determination of Optimal Positions for Electroencephalography (EEG) Electrode Placements using Data-Driven Hybrid Machine Learning (ML) Models

How do reference montage and electrodes setup affect the measured scalp EEG potentials?

Transforming of scalp EEGs with different channel locations by REST for comparative study

Assessing focus through ear-EEG: a comparative study between conventional cap EEG and mobile in- and around-the-ear EEG systems

Optimal Selection of EEG Electrodes Using Interval Type-2 Fuzzy-Logic-Based Semiseparating Signaling Game

Performance of Flexible Non-contact Electrodes in Bioelectrical Signal Measurements.

A Versatile In-Ear Biosensing System and Body-Area Network for Unobtrusive Continuous Health Monitoring

A multichannel reconfigurable EEG acquisition system design with felt-based soft material electrodes

Estimation Of Optimal Location Of Eeg Reference Electrode For Motor Imagery Based Bci Using Fmri

Proper reference selection and re-referencing to mitigate bias in single pulse electrical stimulation data

Automatic sleep monitoring using ear-EEG

The Influence of Different EEG References on Scalp EEG Functional Network Analysis During Hand Movement Tasks

Effect of Channel and Reference Selection on a Non-occipital Steady-State Visual Evoked Potential-Based Brain-Computer Interface