Two- and Three-Dimensional Multi-Physics Simulations of Core Collapse Supernovae: A Brief Status Report and Summary of Results from the "Oak Ridge" Group

Anthony Mezzacappa,Stephen W. Bruenn,Eric J. Lentz,W. Raphael Hix,O.E. Bronson Messer,J. Austin Harris,Eric J. Lingerfelt,Eirik Endeve,Konstantin N. Yakunin,John M. Blondin,Pedro Marronetti

DOI: https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.1405.7075

2014-05-28

Abstract:We summarize the results of core collapse supernova theory from one-, two-, and three-dimensional models and provide a snapshot of the field at this time. We also present results from the "Oak Ridge" group in this context. Studies in both one and two spatial dimensions define the necessary} physics that must be included in core collapse supernova models: a general relativistic treatment of gravity (at least an approximate one), spectral neutrino transport, including relativistic effects such as gravitational redshift, and a complete set of neutrino weak interactions that includes state-of-the-art electron capture on nuclei and energy-exchanging scattering on electrons and nucleons. Whether or not the necessarily approximate treatment of this physics in current models that include it is sufficient remains to be determined in the context of future models that remove the approximations. We summarize the results of the Oak Ridge group's two-dimensional supernova models. In particular, we demonstrate that robust neutrino-driven explosions can be obtained. We also demonstrate that our predictions of the explosion energies and remnant neutron star masses are in agreement with observations, although a much larger number of models must be developed before more confident conclusions can be made. We provide preliminary results from our ongoing three dimensional model with the same physics. Finally, we speculate on future outcomes and directions.

Solar and Stellar Astrophysics,High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

This paper aims to solve the key problems in the theory of Core Collapse Supernovae (CCSNes), especially by exploring these phenomena through one - dimensional, two - dimensional and three - dimensional models. Specifically, the paper attempts to solve the following main problems:

1. **Determine the necessary physical processes**: Through models of different dimensions, researchers have defined the key physical processes that must be included in the core - collapse supernova model. These processes include:
- **General relativity treatment of gravity**: At least an approximate general relativity treatment method is required.
- **Spectral neutrino transport**: Including relativistic effects, such as gravitational redshift.
- **Complete set of weak interactions**: Including the latest nuclear electron capture and energy - exchange scattering with electrons and nucleons.

2. **Evaluate whether the physical treatment of current models is sufficient**: Although the current models already include the above - mentioned necessary physical processes, whether the approximate treatment of these processes in the models is accurate enough still needs to be further verified by future models.

3. **Verify the consistency between model predictions and observations**: The paper shows the results of the two - dimensional supernova model of the "Oak Ridge" group, especially showing that a robust neutrino - driven explosion can be obtained, and the predicted explosion energy and the mass of the remaining neutron star are consistent with the observational results. Nevertheless, more models are needed to draw more confident conclusions.

4. **Explore the results of three - dimensional models**: The paper also provides the preliminary results of the ongoing three - dimensional models, which use the same physical processes. Researchers are speculating about future research directions and possible achievements.

5. **Discuss different treatment methods of neutrino transport**: The paper discusses two practical methods for treating neutrino transport:
- **Ray - by - Ray (RbR) approximation**: This method solves a spherically symmetric problem within each angular space interval and is applicable to two - dimensional and three - dimensional models.
- **Neutrino direction cosine integration (moment) method**: Retain the neutrino energy dimension, but reduce the dimension of the problem by integrating out the angular degrees of freedom of neutrinos.

6. **Analyze the roles of neutrino - driven convection and SASI**: The paper explores the relative roles of neutrino - driven convection and Standing Accretion Shock Instability (SASI) in the supernova explosion mechanism, especially their performance under different precursor masses.

7. **Look into the future**: The paper points out that future work needs to produce more two - dimensional models to better understand supernova dynamics and provide guidance for three - dimensional modeling. At the same time, the limited three - dimensional models will be the key to evaluating our modeling capabilities.

In conclusion, this paper attempts to solve the key problems in the theory of core - collapse supernovae through multi - dimensional simulations and detailed physical analysis, and provide guidance for future research directions.