Abstract:Accurate description of neutrino opacities is central both to the core-collapse supernova (CCSN) phenomenon and to the validity of the explosion mechanism itself. In this work, we study in a systematic fashion the role of a variety of well-selected neutrino opacities in CCSN simulations where multi-energy, three-flavor neutrino transport is solved by the isotropic diffusion source approximation (IDSA) scheme. To verify our code, we first present results from one-dimensional (1D) simulations following core-collapse, bounce, and up to ~ 250 ms postbounce of a 15 $M_{\odot}$ star using a standard set of neutrino opacities by Bruenn (1985). Detailed comparison with published results supports the reliability of our three-flavor IDSA scheme using the standard opacity set. We then investigate in 1D simulations how the individual opacity update leads to the difference from the base-line run with the standard opacity set. By making a detailed comparison with previous work, we check the validity of our implementation of each update in a step-by-step manner. Individual neutrino opacities with the largest impact on the overall evolution in 1D simulations are selected for a systematic comparison in our two-dimensional (2D) simulations. Special emphasis is devoted to the criterion of explodability in the 2D models. We discuss the implications of these results as well as the limitations and requirements for future towards more elaborate CCSN modeling.
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
The problem that this paper attempts to solve is the influence of different choices of neutrino opacity on the simulation results in Core - Collapse Supernova (CCSN) simulations. Specifically, the authors systematically studied the role of various carefully selected neutrino opacities when using the Isotropic Diffusion Source Approximation (IDSA) scheme with multi - energy, three - flavor neutrino transport for CCSN simulations.
### Main research objectives:
1. **Verify the reliability of the code**: First, through one - dimensional (1D) simulations, use the standard neutrino opacity set (provided by Bruenn (1985)) to simulate the core collapse, bounce, and the process about 250 milliseconds after the bounce of a 15 - solar - mass star. By making a detailed comparison with the published results, verify the reliability of their three - flavor IDSA scheme.
2. **Evaluate the impact of individual opacity updates**: In the same one - dimensional simulation, gradually introduce different neutrino opacity updates and make a detailed comparison with the baseline run (using the standard opacity set) to check the implementation effectiveness of each update.
3. **Select the neutrino opacity with the greatest impact on the overall evolution**: Select the neutrino opacity with the greatest impact on the overall evolution from the 1D simulations for systematic comparison in two - dimensional (2D) simulations.
4. **Explore the explosion possibility in the 2D model**: Pay special attention to the explosion criteria in the 2D model and discuss the significance, limitations, and requirements for more complex CCSN modeling in the future.
### Research background:
- **The role of neutrinos in CCSN**: Neutrinos play a crucial role in all stages of CCSN, including the core collapse of the star, core bounce, matter accretion after the bounce, the initiation of the explosion, the deleptonization of the proto - neutron star, until the cooling of the neutron star.
- **Multi - dimensional effects**: Multi - dimensional (multi - D) hydrodynamic instabilities play an important role in the neutrino mechanism. Non - linear turbulent flow increases the neutrino heating efficiency in the gain region and contributes to the occurrence of the explosion.
- **Current challenges**: Although many neutrino - driven models have been successfully reported in 2D simulations, the most challenging self - consistent 3D simulations have not yet produced an explosion, especially in the progenitor stars of 11.2, 20.0, and 27.0 solar masses.
### Research methods:
- **Numerical methods**: Include a detailed description of the model setup, neutrino opacity, and the three - flavor IDSA scheme.
- **Model setup**: The 1D simulation uses a standard 15 - solar - mass progenitor star, and the 2D simulation uses a 20 - solar - mass progenitor star.
- **Neutrino opacity**: The baseline model uses the standard weak interaction set (Bruenn 1985) plus nucleon - nucleon bremsstrahlung radiation (Hannestad & Raffelt 1998). Subsequently, different updates such as electron capture rate, neutrino - pair annihilation, and medium modification are gradually introduced.
- **Three - flavor IDSA scheme**: Divide the neutrino distribution function into two parts, flowing matter and trapped matter, and solve them using different numerical techniques respectively.
### Results and discussion:
- **1D results**: A detailed comparison was made with the results of two reference codes, Agile - BOLTZTRAN and VERTEX, to verify the reliability of the IDSA scheme.
- **2D results**: Select the neutrino opacity with the greatest impact on the 1D simulation for 2D simulation to explore its impact on the explosion possibility.
Through these studies, the authors aim to improve the "explosion ability" of CCSN models and provide a basis for further research.