Validity of approximations applied in calculations of single-wall metallic carbon nanotube current-voltage characteristics

Dmitry Pozdnyakov
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10825-012-0419-6
2013-11-11
Abstract:The calculation results of dependencies of electric current in the infinitely long single-wall metallic carbon nanotubes of armchair type with different diameter values on the strength of constant and uniform longitudinal electric field applied to them are presented in this study. On the one hand the results have been obtained by an accurate numerical self-consistent tight-binding full-band solution of the Boltzmann transport equations for electrons and phonons in the electric quantum limit. On the other hand the results have been obtained by solution of these equations after application of a number of commonly used simplifications and approximations. It is ascertained that the approximately calculated dependencies considerably diverge from the rigorously calculated ones. In addition the relaxation time of non-equilibrium phonons in the single-wall metallic carbon nanotubes has been estimated by means of comparison of the calculation results with the well-known experimental data. Its value is equal to 2.2+/-0.1 ps.
Mesoscale and Nanoscale Physics
What problem does this paper attempt to address?
This paper attempts to solve the following three main problems: 1. **Accurately calculate the current - voltage characteristics (CVCs) of single - walled metallic carbon nanotubes (SWMCNTs)**: - The author calculated the current - voltage characteristics of infinitely long armchair - type single - walled metallic carbon nanotubes in the electrical quantum limit by strictly describing the electron - phonon interaction in quantum mechanics. Specifically, the numerical self - consistent tight - binding full - band solution method was used to solve the Boltzmann transport equations of electrons and phonons. 2. **Determine the real value of the non - equilibrium phonon relaxation time τ**: - By comparing the calculation results with the known experimental data, the author estimated the relaxation time τ of non - equilibrium phonons in SWMCNT. The results show that the value of τ is 2.2 ± 0.1 ps. 3. **Evaluate the influence of commonly used approximate methods on the CVCs calculation results**: - It was found that the CVCs calculated by using commonly used approximate methods (such as the linear dispersion relation approximation, the constant scattering rate approximation, etc.) are significantly different from the strictly calculated results. In particular, the maximum error is introduced by the hot - electron and quasi - Fermi - level approximation (HEQFLA), while the elastic electron scattering approximation (EESA) and the linear dispersion relation approximation (LDRA) introduce the least error. ### Specific problems and solutions - **Theoretical background**: - The paper first introduced the research status of SWMCNTs and their importance in micro - and nano - electronics, and pointed out the existing problems in describing their electrical physical properties. These problems include the consideration of different phonon modes, a large range of values for the relaxation time τ, etc. - **Theoretical model**: - The author adopted a strict quantum - mechanical method to describe the electron - phonon interaction and derived formulas for calculating the scattering rate (see formulas (1) - (4)). These formulas are based on the Pietronero - Strassler - Zeller - Rice calculation and combined with some other research results. - **Calculation method**: - By numerically solving the Boltzmann transport equations (see formula (10)), the author calculated the current - voltage characteristics of SWMCNTs under different diameters and longitudinal electric field intensities. At the same time, some commonly used simplification and approximation methods were also applied for comparative calculation. - **Result discussion**: - By comparing the results of strict calculation and approximate calculation, the author found that the approximate method can lead to large deviations in some cases. In addition, by comparing with the experimental data, the real value of the relaxation time τ was determined to be 2.2 ± 0.1 ps, and it was pointed out that the main relaxation mechanism of non - equilibrium phonons is phonon - phonon scattering. ### Conclusion - Through strict quantum - mechanical calculations, the author verified the current - voltage characteristics of SWMCNTs, and determined the real value of the non - equilibrium phonon relaxation time τ by comparing with the experimental data. In addition, the applicability and limitations of commonly used approximate methods were evaluated, providing an important reference for future research. I hope this summary is helpful for you to understand the content of the paper. If you have more questions or need further explanation, please feel free to let me know!